BOOKS—NEW AND OLD
CONDUCTED BY BERNARD G. RICHARDSOCCUPATIONAL SERVICE OFFICERCONDUCTED BY BERNARD G. RICHARDS
Forecast of Free Russia in the future
“Great Russia, her Achievements and Promise,” by Charles Sarolea. New York. Alfred A. Knopf. 1916.
The great upheaval in Russia staggered us. With the violence of a tornado it came upon us and swept away before our very eyes people, house, foundation and all. The thoroughness and the comparative ease with which the evil forces were uprooted and the speedy recuperation from this exceedingly fatal operation amazed and astounded us. We are still wondering how the strangling grip of Czarism upon one hundred and eighty million people suddenly lost its hold, and we marvel at the latent powers of the long-suffering Russian people.
To understand this wonderful phenomenon it is essential to understand the character of the Russian people. A most valuable contribution to the understanding of Russia is "Great Russia," a book by Dr. Charles Sarolea, Belgian Consul in Edinburgh, editor of Everyman, London, who is a man of wide learning and distinguished scholarship. Written almost a year before the present transformation of Russia, it forecasts many things that have now come to pass. Although not so bold as to predict the complete overthrow of Czarism, the author of "Great Russia" anticipated an early change in Russia. He says: "And it is because the Russian is animated with that noble passion for freedom, it is because he is not politically servile like the Prussian, it is because the Slav refuses to be a slave, that we may look forward with every confidence to the results of the new Liberal Constitution which the Russian people conquered in 1905."
“Great Russia” aims “to give a systematic and coordinated survey of Russian history and policy,” and to remove “some of the most glaring British misconceptions of a wonderful people—who are destined after this war to be the dominant influence in World Politics.” Taking into consideration the limited space in which this had to be done, the author fairly succeeds in his task. In a clear-cut, terse, and readable English, he analyzes the character and the problems of the Russian people in a scholarly manner. The average person is wont to think of the Russian people in terms of the Russian government—barbarous, despotic, and uncivilized. “Great Russia” shows that it is not so. The Russian people are better than their government. Russia stands for liberty and democracy. The true character and ideals of Russia have found adequate expression in the masters of Russian literature, Turgeniev, Tolstoy, and Dostoevsky. “Freedom with the Russians is an elemental instinct, a fanatical passion, the passion which creates martyrs, which sends its votaries to Siberia and to the scaffold.” In a number of instances, however, in contrasting the Russia and Germany, Dr. Sarolea allows himself to be led away by his hatred for Germany, and his enthusiasm for Russia becomes akin to worship.
An admirable chapter is the one on the problem of the Russian Jews. It gives a sympathetic, fairminded, and honest exposition of the Jewish problem, refuting some existing popular misconceptions of
the character and position of the Jewish people. Not attempting to conceal the faults of the Jews, Dr. Sarolea manifests a rare insight into the circumstances and a profound knowledge of the causes that brought about these faults. He recognizes a truth that many writers fail to realize, that the Jews are a nation, even though they may not be a pure race. He says: “The bonds which hold a nation together are sentimental and spiritual, and no nation has ever welded together by stronger moral and spiritual bonds than the Jewish nation. . . .” In a very logical manner he picks out the fallacies in the reasoning back of the anti-Jewish legislation and finally maintains that the emancipation of the Jews will solve the Jewish problem in Russia. “There is only one solution to the Jewish problem, and that is a complete reversal of the old policy of intolerance and inequality and iniquity, an uncompromising acceptance of the principle that liberty with all its risks and perils is preferable to protection with all its false security.”
“Great Russia” enables us to gain an insight into the character of the Russian people, and recent developments have increased the value of the book.
SAMUEL CAPLAN.
Philosophy and Judaism
A History of Mediæval Jewish Philosophy, by Isaac Husik, A.M., Ph.D., pp. I-L; 1-462. The Macmillan Co., New York, 1916.
On the very last page of his book, Dr. Husik informs us that "there are Jews now and there are philosophers, but there are no Jewish philosophers and there is no Jewish philosophy." But have we not heard the terms "Philosophy of Judaism," "Philosophy of the Bible," etc., etc? It seems but the other day that our Rabbi employed these terms in his sermon, for the thousandth time. Was it merely the homiletical highfalutin of the "Mission of Israel" and "Ethical Monotheism" brand? Dr. Husik's book should serve as a disillusionment to a number of pulpit stars who fail to perceive that ethical maxims, wise saws, bits of skepticism of the Koheleth kind, statutes and dogmas, Talmudic dialectics, Midrashic exegesis, Kabbalistic mysticism or even the program of assimilation do not constitute what they have been pleased to call out of a profound ignorance Jewish philosophy or the Philosophy of Judaism.
But surely, there has been such a thing as Jewish philosophy, in the mediæval period at least! There has, as the present volume under discussion proves in a convincing and able manner. But that philosophy was not based primarily on Bible, Talmud or other Jewish literature. Greece, not Judæa, was the source; Aristotle, not Moses, the authority. Indeed, the great Jewish interpreters of Greek philosophy humored themselves with the preposterous legend that the Greek philosophers were rank plagiarists and lifted their philosophical speculations bodily from ancient Israel.
Dr. Husik has made a valuable contribution to Jewish literature. He has given us in this work a clear
