The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 4 · April 1917
4printed page
scan 10 of 28

THE MACCABAEAN

sians, 5.9 millions (4.7 per cent). Since that census was taken these parts of the population have increased considerably, about 40 per cent, but the proportion has remained about the same. But we do not want to assert that the Little Russians or White Russians are to be looked upon as separate nations. In a vast majority they consider themselves Russians of a different mold and only small groups among them have national aspirations of any sort. For all that they are bound to intensify the struggle for the national uni- featinn af Rieca.

There can be no doubt that even among the defenders and partisans of a complete transformation of conditions in Russia, certain people will refute the basic principles of national autonomy. These elements will base their arguments on the fact that the most numerous alien race of the population of Russia —the Poles—who according to statistics constitute about 6.3 per cent of the total population, will have nothing to do with the internal questions of the country after their separation from it after the war. On the other hand the alien peoples of Russia will gain in national force from their having but a very slight Slavic admixture, for to them the incessant apostro- phizing of Russia as a Slavic state will be bereft of all moral significance. For in counterbalance to the three Russian groups there will be the other nations consisting of from 28 to 30 per cent of the total population. Surely in view of this fact, free Russia will not be able to ignore the question of national autonomy. The Armenians, Grusinians, Letts, Esthonians, Lithuanians, Germans, Moldavians, and even the Tatare have made it clear at every Duma election that they wanted to preserve their national individuality, and when the Russian state is reconstructed they will doubtless demand guarantees for their national entiretly dependence. Since their national sentiment has been much intensified of recent years, they will unquestionably repeat their old demands of the year 1906 and will. struggle energetically to have them granted.

After the Polish question has been settled it is to be foreseen that the Caucasian peoples, strengthened by the adjunction of Armenia, and the Jews as the most numerous alien race, will play a prominent part in this conflict. It is a marked advantage that the great majority of Russian Jews still use the Yiddish language and thus establish their claim to national entity in the eyes of the world. For up to the present day language is the decisive indication of national existence. In 1897, 5,063,- 000 (96.9%) of the 5,216,000 Jews of Russia stated Yiddish to be their language of intercourse. Even if a new census will show a smaller proportion of Yiddish-speaking Jews, their number will certainly be great enough to give them grounds for national demands. This fact gives the Russian Jews, whatever attitude the various elements may assume toward the language question, a lever with which to raise their national aspirations.

Moreover, it is possible that all the peoples which are struggling for national autonomy will receive more potent assistance from the Little Russians than we have reason to suppose from previous experience. It is true that at present the number of Little Russians who demand national rights is too insignificant to be of any importance. It is true that only certain ones of their representatives joined the Society of Autonomists even in the revolutionary “Duma of the People’s Wrath,” the First Duma, nay, most of the nationalistically inclined Little Russians claimed merely a few concessions regarding the language of instruction in the schools, and these were based on

Two-two

the prevailing ignorance of Great Russian among the masses. On the other hand we must not forget that despite severe persecutions there has been a group of Little Russians working in secret which has daunt- lessly waved the banner of Little Russian nationality, sworn by the Little Russian poets, and developed the Little Russian theatre. This group, inconsiderable in number, but evincing possibilties of growth, is certainly a manifestation with which the national law- makers will have to reckon in the event of a liberal régime. The example of the Galician Ruthenians may become contagious. If millions have achieved self-consciousness there as Ruthenians, it is possible that the same tendency may manifest itself elsewhere notwithstandine adverse circumectancesc.

There have been violent and profound philological and demographic discussions between native and foreign savants and politicians as to whether Little Russian is an independent language or a dialect. For us it will suffice if as a result millions of Little Russians will demand that Little Russian be introduced as a language of instruction in the schools. It is true that we have no reason to look back with satisfaction on the relations which have prevailed between the Little Russians and the Jews. It is in the southwestern provinces of Podolia, Volhynia and Kiev, where the Little Russians constitute 70 to 80 per cent of the population and the Jews about 13 per cent, that the antagonism of the dominant nation to the Jewish minority has made itself felt more strongly than in any other part of Russia. In this region, but sparsely inhabited by Great Russians, the firmest bulwarks of Russian reaction were erected. It is easily demonstrated to what an extent the attitude towards politics was influenced by the hatred called forth by the organization of Pogroms. In the governments of Poltava and Kharkov where, as there are few Jews, the Jewish question could not become a matter of vital importance, this same Little Russian population evinced decidedly liberal tendencies. In the provinces of Podolia, Volhynia, Kherson, and to a certain extent in Kiev, however, the Jew-hatred cultivated and utilized by official and individual reaction made the population literally blind to its own vital interests. It is an old law that the unenlightened masses abandon themselves to a single instinct and reap the consequences thereof in all matters.

Certainly at this historic moment I do not begin to believe that as a result of the revolution Jewish prejudice will disappear forthwith. It is to be hoped, however, that in a free and teachable Russia the people will learn to distinguish and to analyse, that they will not let themselves be so dazzled by hatred as to make it an omnipotent maxim for their intricate economic and cultural problems. If the tendencies become constructive instead of destructive, and more subtle differentiations occupy the humanitarian souls and spirits in Russia, anti-Semitism is bound to have an entirely different trend.

Let us hope, therefore, that the national differences between the Jews and the Little Russians, among whom at least 22 million Jews live, will continue to be clearly defined. In establishing the principle of national demands the Little Russians, in so far as they cleave to this principle, will be of assistance to the small nations of Russia, and thus indirectly to the Jews. / ee / / 0

To summarize: We have seen that about 30 per cent of the total population of Russia will make a categorical demand for national rights, and that moreover a considerable part of the remaining 70 per cent

April, 1917