The Hebrew Movement In America
IN no respect have we, the organized Zionists of America, been so remiss in the performance of our sacred duty as in the matter of the Hebrew movement in this country. For many years we have been content to leave the responsibility for this all important phase of our endeavors to a handful of uninfluential Hebraists. True, these few stubbornly insisted upon securing for the object of their devotion —Hebrew—“a place in the sun” of Zionist activity and made their demands vocal at the annual Zionist conventions; but each time these demands, modest as they were, were put through the ruthless mill of committees and sub-committees and emerged lean and battered, and shorn of all practical value. Instead of attempting something substantial, the convention would accordingly adopt viva voce a few rhetorical resolutions—and there the matter would rest for a twelvemonth.
Two conditions were responsible for this apparently cold attitude on the part of leading Zionists. In the first place, the latter were as a rule American bred; and, although they were obliged by the very logic of their own Zionist theories and convictions to concede the justice of the Hebraists’ demands, nevertheless, being personally and individually strangers to the new Hebrew literary renaissance, and coming little in contact with the new type of immigrant, the standard-bearer of the traditions of Wilna and Odessa, they failed to complete the circuit between theoretic accord and practical co-operation. They were, moreover, for a long time under the influence of the “political” wing of the Zionist organization, and the publication of Hebrew journals and books, the establishment of Hebrew kindergartens and schools, the development of Hebrew drama and poetry—all that seemed to them far afield from “political” Zionism.
Today it is happily quite unnecessary to be at pains to expose the fallacy of that conception of politics. Even our extremists now concede that the growth and development of a national language and literature is one of the strongest and most effective of political weapons in the hands of a struggling nationality—a weapon eagerly seized by the Magyars, Czechs, Irish and others.
In spite of the seeming indifference of official Zionism to the repeated appeals of the Hebraists, the latter continued their labors, sustained by the spiritual force emanating from Europe, and operating on them through the medium of the European Hebrew press. Wherever possible they organized Hebrew societies, and even where that was not feasible they formed little groups of enthusiasts who struggled feebly against the cold, unsympathetic, un-Hebraic environment. With a few brilliant exceptions their work was usually limited to speaking Hebrew at meetings and arranging Hebrew lectures. Beyond that they were powerless. Many of them cherished golden dreams of a Hebrew press in this country, of schools and: teachers’ seminaries, of a Hebrew stage, of the. popularization of Hebrew classics—but most of these projects never crossed the threshold of Dreamland. et \ eae
As the years rolled by, these stray Hebrew clubs strove to get out of the rut into which they had sunk by attempting to unite in some kind of federation. This they hoped to strengthen the existing societies and organize new ones, as well as command greater attention
and respect arhong “the mighty of the land.” No less than ten such unsuccessful attempts were made, and they served, if anything, but to emphasize the pitiful weakness of the whole fabric. Every failure left a bitter after-taste and increased the number of the disheartened and the dicoruntled
The abortion of these early attempts was due, in my opinion, chiefly to three causes: (1) the lack of money, (2) the absence of strong leadership, and (3) the lack of organizing ability. Any one of these would be a serious impediment to a young movement, but it was the last which proved fatal. The lack of a proper sense of organization and discipline has wrecked many a fair Jewish enterprise. Particularly has it been the tragic lot of the East European Jew to see with the utmost lucidity and distinctness the problems of his life and their proper solutions, yet, to find himself, because of his defective training and unstable economic condition, bereft of the means of converting his vision into fact. So these Hebraists, filled with a noble ambition and deeply convinced of the tremendous national import of their work, were yet unable to cope with the practical difficulties. They were all immigrants, mostly ignorant of the language of this country, and as a rule poorer than their average fellow immigrants. Strangers to the methods of organization in vogue in Western lands and to the ordinary practice of parliamentary procedure, they blundered and blustered, quarreled over trifles, neglected opportunities, scrimped most where they should have been lavish, and squandered the little they had where least productive.
These organizations, which blossomed and decayed with all too great rapidity, left many an unsightly derelict floating in their wake. There were ill-starred journalistic ventures. There were feeble attempts at publishing books, or rather pamphlets. Now and then evening courses in Hebrew language and literature were launched amid great enthusiasm—only to meet the fate of other undertakings. Perhaps the only thing of permanent value contributed to Jewish life in America by these early gropings was in the field of Jewish education. Within the walls of the Talmud Torah and Hebrew School scores of enthusiastic Hebraists toiled patiently and perseveringly, and here they wrought a revolution. If we today have anything resembling a renaissance in Jewish education, it is the fruit of their labor and self-sacrifice.
Of late, however, there has been noticeable a renewed activity among the Hebraists—a ferment which continued with unabated vigor and culminated in the formation of the Histadruth Ivrith last year and the holding of the first convention last month. The men responsible for the formation of the Histadruth were well aware of the fact that others had attempted before them and had failed. But they were newer and younger men, whose spirits had not yet been dampened by adversity and who, above all, believed that certain features of their plan, which they considered original, would insure the survival of the new organization. And it cannot be denied that the Histadruth Ivrith does seem to be a healthy, vigorous infant, destined to live and reach the full stature of manhood. Its good fortune will not, however, be due to the greater enthusiasm or superior abilities of the present group of workers, for previous, attempts