THE MACCABAEAN
were repeatedly made, and far more sympathetic allusions were uttered by some of the delegates. But a great opportunity was suffered to go by—perhaps forever. In the midst of the crisis of many centuries, while the Jewish world in tears was awaiting a brotherly and enheartening word, the academic platitudes of a Yankee Doodle universalism were offered for help and healing. And why? Because the passion of many professional pleaders of Reform Judaism is not so much for the fulfilment of the deathless hopes of their people as it is for loyalty to the perishable imaginings of the Jewish reformers of 1848. The leaders in council consulted not with the eternal genius of their people, but with fugitive views of the founders of the Reform movement, thus substituting the infallibility of reform pioneers for the fallibility of prophets, priests and rabbis. Of other mental and moral stuff were the Geigers and the Holdheims and Einhorns of their day.
And the outcome? If this deadening leadership be followed, Reform Judaism may be saved, but only for itself. Instead of remaining a living tide in the ocean of Jewish being, it will have become a stagnant pool, unreplenished by the springs of Jewish life and Jewish hope. Is this to be the fate of Liberal Judaism,—to perish as a petrifying sect? Or is it to live as a vitalized and vivifying branch of the body of Jewish life? History will tell. May its verdict not be against the suicidal slayers of a great hope of the eternal people Israel.
THE NATIONAL WORKMEN'S CONGRESS CONVENTION
HE National Workmen’s Committee on Jewish Rights—one of the parties to the Congress peace agreement—continues to play a dubious part in the Congress movement. The inspiration for the organization of Jewish workmen interested in the emancipation of the Jews and in a Jewish Congress came from the Poalei Zionists and the Jewish nationalists in the labor movement. When the subject was first broached, the labor leaders and the Jewish socialistic leaders were opposed to the entrance of the workmen in a specifically Jewish movement. But there ensued such a large demand for proletarian participation in the Congress movement that the leaders were forced to give their sanction to it. It was an unwilling assent. It was a co-operation grudgingly granted. From the first, they sought to divert the movement, to limit it, to circumscribe and narrow its objects. At the first workmen’s convention an executive committee was elected. This committee did the unusual thing in workmen’s circles. It practically ignored its instructions. First, it confused the text of the instructions and then proceeded to carry out such fragments of the instructions as served its purposes. They were for a Congress, but only if it were limited to the acquisition of Jewish rights. They were for a united Jewry upon a minimum program, but reserved for themselves independence of action. Finally, after a great deal of squirming and bickering, they arrived at the theory that the interests of the Jewish workmen in Jewish affairs coincided with the views and interests of the American Jewish Committee to the extent of supporting the American Jewish Committee’s candidates for office and policies in the Congress movement! The result was—Union upon a compromise program. \
Having succeeded in limiting the scope of the Congress, although failing to secure control of the movement, one would surmise that the National Workmen's Committee would now work unreservedly with the Congress Committee of 140. But in spite of the fact that
they opposed a permanent Congress, they called a second convention of labor organizations with the intention of consolidating their lines and establishing a permanent organization of their own to deal with Jewish rights and all other subjects they had deliberately excluded from the Congress program. In other words, they objected to a permanent Jewish organization representing all elements and to deal with all phases of the Jewish question, but desired the power for themselves to continue working for these ends independently of the rest of the Jews of America.
When the proposal for a permanent labor organization was brought up at the second convention, the resolution was adopted, but the United Hebrew Trades and a number of other labor organizations withdrew from the convention. Thus, in addition to the Poalei Zionists the National Arbeiter Verband and other socialisticnationalistic organizations who withdrew as soon as it became evident that the ringleaders of the National Workmen’s committee were usurping their powers, we now have the spectacle of the National Workmen’s Committee practically representing a rump of the Jewish workmen’s organizations of America. The Jewish Socialist Federation and the Arbeiter Ring are all that remain in the National Workmen’s Committee. The Jewish Socialist Federation has a membership which is larger than the membership of the Poalei Zionists by a few thousand, and the Arbeiter Ring is an organization of the size of an ordinary insurance fraternitv. °
en nee nn EE EEE EE EEE ES With the desire of the Bundists to organize the Jewish workmen for Jewish interests, we have, of course, no quarrel; the more interested they become, the better they will understand the Zionist movement, which the leaders seem to think it necessary to combat. But the logic of their action passes our comprehension. If it is proper for the Jewish proletariat to organize permanently for Jewish rights and Jewish immigration and constructive relief, why should there be any objection to the organization of the middle class elements and the well-to-do classes for the same purposes, alf parties and elements co-operating in a national Congress? If these men believe in union, why should they organize permanently for themselves, especially as they know that if anything is to be done for the solution of the Jewish problem it will have to be done by a united Jewry, counselling together, acting after thorough discussion and mutual understanding? It becomes evident that such a policy of contradictory action raises the question as to the sincerity of the motives of the National Workmen’s Committee in the Congress movement.
