The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 2 · February 1917
54printed page
scan 9 of 24
Facsimile · scan 9 of 24
Scan of p. 54
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

puts the necessary stop to our critical faculty by giving us a flawless object of reverence, by directing our attention toward absolute perfection. Man’s reverence for God is the fountain-head of all reverence; if this source be dried up, then gradually all lesser springs will cease to flow. So it is that the irreverence of the young people of to-day is closely related to the rationalism of the older generation whose critical faculty recognized no injunctions. Again, religion is distinguished from all other ideal aids to righteousness in that, in the course of time, it has accumulated various means of meeting the needs of all types of men:—the simple, the sophisticated, the saintly, the erring, the intellectual, the emotional, those who are happy and those who despair. It is religion alone, moreover, that gives us a concrete heritage to hand on from age to age, by its symbolic expression in words,— such as the word God,—in tangible objects, ceremonies, observances, set prayers. These fixed forms are like a crystal chalice sealed against the evaporation of its contents, making possible the transmission of the spirit within the form, even by a generation too blind to see aught but the outward shape, until again the priceless contents reach the eyes of men with clearer vision. All other ideal devotions if examined at one point in time, or in particular manifestations, give evidence of a moral effect corresponding to that of religious self-surrender; it is only when we follow their evolution that we see the difference, Their power to heighten morality is transient, but the power of religion carries over from year to year, from age to age.

It was while I was preparing a talk for one of the many groups of girls I taught, that I came face to face with the question that proved to be one of the recognizable beginnings of my departure from the Society for Ethical Culture. I found myself using the phrase: “The end does not justify the means.” “How do I know that it does not?” I asked myself. “We are all working for ends, not for means,—why then need we concern ourselves about the means?“ While I was following a process of reasoning that lasted many days, I came to various landings on the way, and on one of these I asked myself, “How do I know that right is right?” My answer to this question gave direction to my changed views from that day to this. I said to myself that no individual alone, no matter how wise he be, and that no group of individuals at any given point in time, can be trusted to know with certainty that which is the ultimate right; but that where we find coincidence in the teachings of wise and holy men, corroborated by the experience of generation after generation, there we have the best evidence of truth ; there a deposit is left upon the sands of time which will not be washed away, which will gradually be massed higher and higher toward the infinite and eternal. The kind of truth I had in mind was not abstract or philosophic; it was the essence of experience, distilled from myriads of lives, and crystallized by men of moral genius who themselves had lived close to righteousness; it was wisdom in the ways of life. But where could I find such truth stored? How instruct myself in it? I could not take Felix Adler’s teachings or any other great and good man’s teachings as infallible, because, I said to myself, “A man’s experiences are limited by his personality and by the brief span of his life. O that a man could lead an impersonal existence, and live through many ages, collecting wisdom.” It occurred to me then that in early times whole nations whose existence lasted through thousands of years, codified their experience. Would not the study of such a compendium be the closest that any one living at one point in time could come to a knowledge of

wisdom? We cannot know by any proof of logical reasoning that a Bible teaches the truth about right and wrong; but my mind at least becomes convinced by circumstantial evidence tested by millions of men throughout the ages. Nevertheless, though I sank deeper and deeper into this thought, I could not find the bottom; for I realized that though the teachings of a Bible might be to us like wells in our long march through the wilderness, yet we might ignorantly defile the waters, unless some one vested with authority guarded them from pollution. For wrong interpretations of the teachings of a Bible are pollutions of the truth, But I think I struck the bottom of the thought in which I was immersed, when I came to the idea that though we could not trust any individual’s interpretation of precepts, yet there would again be much in favor of trusting the teachings of any corporate authority that was the living successor to similar bodies in century before century of the past, and that would be the adjuster of interpretations to the needs of the present. This adjustment would be necessary because of the element of imperfection inhering in everything human,—in what is written as well as in the eyes that read. Given a Bible and a Vatican or a Sanhedrin, we should come as near to knowing absolute wisdom in matters of conduct as it would be possible for man to-day to attain to; and we might feel justly confident that far off generations would come nearer to the goal. I did not at this time think of the Vatican or of a Jewish equivalent, because I had none of the prerequisite knowledge to lead to a particularized conclusion; much later these concepts fitted into the place prepared for them.

Many and many a time since those days have I asked myself what it is that has saved the Jews from the perils of private judgment run riot, such as finally overtake all those religions that do not submit to authority. Where was our authority? We have had no Sanhedrin for the days of our need. Moreover we have in almost all ages been granted intellectual freedom; we have not had to subscribe to dogmas by positive affirmation. How is it then that we did not split up into diverse sects? It seems to me that our rigid system of education, by fixing the contents of each man’s knowledge, by making the Law and the Talmud the chief part of each man’s mental make-up, acted as our preservative. During the formative years of the Jew’s life, the Law and the Talmud were the dominant factors in his environment physically and spiritually: physically, because most of his days and nights were spent in the Hebrew school and seminary, and spiritually, because the education he received there erected a wall about his thoughts keeping him almost free from outside influences, and holding him true to ancient type. The living Jew became part of a no longer living past; the past, as it were, converted the present to its own shape and substance. The quarantine in which Israel’s spirit dwelt was enforced from without by bigotry, as it was enjoined upon each community from within by intense group consciousness, fostered by the teachings of the schools.

The quarantine of the Jewish spirit is lifting in the East as it has already been raised for a hundred years in the West. External barriers and inward compulsions are everywhere breaking down. There is both hope for us and the desolation of despair in the consequent assimilation of our ways to the ways of other men. Though we gain through our contact with the world, yet unless Israel be in some way enabled to create a central body of authorized adiusters of the Law, each Jew will become a law unto himself, and Israel will break up into insignificant parts and will disappear, The schools partially ful-