THE MACCABAEAN
Years passed, and I myself became a teacher who tried to impart to others some of the lessons my mind had grasped and my will had desired to follow. No teachings bear fruit unless the teacher has sincerely tried to practice whatever he recommends ;—not that it is necessary for a guide to reach the goal before pointing out the way to others, but he may not lag behind. Therefore sometimes after I had planned what promised to be an interesting lesson, I would not let myself use the material, since I knew that in teaching it my lips would be merely the mouthpiece of my mind, and not the expression of an earnest will or the result of personal effort. Had I been solemnly ordained for this particular work each day, I could not have felt the more the responsibility I had assumed. My faith in the value of each and every point in every lesson was Quixotic; as if I were the distributor of rations indispensable to the health of every soul; or as if these lessons might be the Providence that would safeguard my dear girls from tragic error, Such intensity, such disproportionate gravity, is not lovable when seen by itself, without relation to the whole character: therefore I was very often out of joint with those whose lives touched mine only at some corner of one of my serious interests. I have observed the same thing among other young people. The terrible seriousness of the devotee who is not yet acquainted with life as a whole, and is not yet tolerant, acts as an irritant to those who have a sense of proportion. \
Nevertheless, although my feeling of responsibilty was pathetically and ludicrously exaggerated, it sometimes saved me from fatal mistakes, as in the following instance. The girls whom I taught were almost without exception daughters of orthodox Jewish parents; but having come more completely than their parents under the dominance of America and irreligion, they were far less observant of tradition outside their homes than in them. One of the obligations I had always emphasized in my talks with the girls, was 116 duty of the young to understand the old; I believed that the more enlightened the daughter, the greater became her responsibility toward her home. Therefore, despite the fact that in the early years of my teaching I felt superior to belief in religion, and did not know anything about the practices of Judaism, yet I did not permit myself consciously to do or say aught that would make the girls criticize their parents; although I see now that my ignorance of tradition was in itself a disintegrating social factor, and must moreover have led me unawares into many trespasses. The time came when I fell under religious influence, and that not Jewish, and when I was beset with the temptation to transmit my new knowledge to others, as one is tyrannized over by a nagging secret that cries for publication despite the seal set upon one’s lips. At atime when I was most deeply affected by this new influence, the girls of one club importuned me to read the New Testament with them. To yield to their wishes would have relieved my own heart; but here that very sense of responsibility that so often 160 me to ridiculous extremes. stood me in good stead. I had not myself accepted Christian doctrine, although I seemed to be approaching conversion: but I knew very well that if I began to read the New Testament with the girls, I should be sufficiently convincing to convert some of them. It did not seem right to take advantage of their youth and their love for me, in a contest that ought to depend solely on the merits of the issue; nor could I accommodate my conscience to the result of such action on my part,—the separation of the girls from their fathers and mothers. Therefore I told
the girls that I required the consent of their parents as a condition of studying the New Testament with them. That put an end to the matter. It is true that years later, when my will had become Judaized and I then tried to interpret to these same girls their own people and Israel’s beliefs, I did for this very purpose read parts of the New Testament with them; but it was then better for the girls tn read the hnoke with me than hv themcelvec
No one who agrees with Matthew Arnold that the object of religion is conduct, and that conduct is three-fourths of life, can take departure from the Ethical Society and enter into a formal religious congregation, without being confronted many times by questions pertaining to the relative effectiveness of ethics with and without religion. Since it is the purpose of the formal religions which relate man to God, to make man good, and since the Society for Ethical Culture can show results comparable to those of formal religion in this respect, does it not follow that man can live very well without any other religion than what has been called “a religion of morality?” Indeed, may it not be that a cause to serve is all that men need? For the same doubt of the indispensability of religion arises, when we contemplate the moral effect upon groups of men, of self-surrender to any ideal—such as emancipation of slaves, universal suffrage, single tax, social revolution, nationalism. Whenever we find a group united by a great leader or animated by a single idea, we find in the finer spirits the same results of their common devotion as we find among conscious observers of a religious faith,—at first even a heightened effect. We see men like Felix Adler, William Lloyd Garrison, Henry George, Kropotkin, Mazzini, Herz]; and we think that since they surpassed the multitude in virtue, and since their teachings and example moved some of their disciples to lead lives more heroic and glorious than can be matched by pious mediocrities, therefore any ideal may be substituted for religion without loss to mankind. We see striking by-products of virtue even in a mistaken and mischievous cause, when its adherents act from pure motives. The effect of their devotion is the same upon themselves, though not upon the world. A like effect may also be produced upon individuals by single-hearted service to science or art. Always it is true that self-surrender to an ideal purges the soul of a certain amount of dross. What is it then that makes religion morally productive beyond all other devotions?
In the first place, religion directs man’s attention to the whole of morality, not only to self-sacrifice or courage or intellectual honesty, or to this or that. It wilf have no specialization in virtue, no limitation; it forever keeps alive a divine dissatisfaction with self. a deep humility. In this respect, Ethical Culture coincides with religion. All other ideal pursuits, humanitarian or scientific, are narrower. Moreover, both religion and ethics direct our thoughts not only to one section of the world, to one nation, to one class, but again, to all, the rich as well as the poor, the persecutor as well as his victim. They do this, though we try to twist their teachings to suit our own behavior. Religion alone. however, 76- lates the whole of life on earth to the infinite. Not only can no definite accomplishment, such as the freeing of slaves, the founding of a righteous nation in Palestine. the abolition of poverty, satisfy the requirements of religion ;—its demands cross over beyond our mortal life into eternity, establishing a relation of responsibility between the living and the dead. This is a potent ethical factor in religion: Moreover, it is religion alone that