THE MACCABAEAN
in which the men and women of the next generation shall have a country to love and defend because they have a part in the universal opportunities to create homes and develop their individual lives through immediate contact with the earth.
Because I have characterized the movement as individualistic I would not have you think that it is lacking in organization. On the contrary, there are hundreds of organizations working for the realization of its aims. Among these I mention first the Joseph Fels Fund Commission because it is the only national organization of America, and there is also being organized at present an international movement under the same general title. This organization was established in 1909 to collect funds from supporters over the country, which were doubled by Mr. Joseph Fels. The money has been used to further Single Tax campaigns, notably in Oregon, Colorado, Missouri, Rhode Island, New York and New Jersey. It has sent out lecturers, aided individuals and distributed Henry George’s works and hundreds of thousands of books, pamphlets, and leaflets explaining and urging the objects of the movement. It has also aided and in some measure supported such publications as “The Public,” and “The Single Tax Review.”
But, you will ask, with all this leadership and organized effort, what has so fai been done to put the Single Tax in opera: tion? Surely in all the years since Henry George wrote “Progress and Poverty,” some country or some division of a country should have been found where the people were willing to try the Single Tax and test its claim as a solvent for social injustice.
In reply I must point out that, while the Single Tax is capable of being introduced slowly through a gradual shifting of taxation from improvements on to land values thereby making it easier of application than most far-reaching reforms, there are still difficulties which make justice in this direction slow of realization. In the first place, the vested interests of life are largely bound up with land values. Monopolies which at first sight seem far removed from the earth always rest back directly upon crude products drawn from land, water ways, mines or special franchises. And nothing is more sensitive than property. Landlords know instinctively what effects the Single Tax would have, and they can be trusted to unite solidly and furnish funds in any attempt to defeat its being brought into application. Their attitude is always that of Sir William Lever, who, when approached on the subject, turned with the quick sharp words: 71 am in favor of income taxes and of inheritance taxes, but not of taxes on the land.”
In the second place, our present system of collecting taxes has led to utter confusion in public thinking and in fact has made it impossible for most people to think about taxation at all. No business man in America knows what taxes he pays in the course of a year. He may know how much he pays on real and personal property, for his poll, and for his dog, how much he pays on stocks, bonds and other investments and on income, but how
much he pays every time he buys a suit of clothes, a cigar or a cup of coffee no one ,
ANAL? VV Oe This condition is further aggravated by the fact that one system of taxation provides national resources, another state income, and a third the money for state and municipal expenses. We cannot hope to affect federal taxation until a majority of the people of the United States is convinced of the justice and feasibility of the Single Tax; we cannot affect state taxation until a majority within that state is willing to try the experiment. In most states local taxation is arranged on a uniform plan of state laws, and even where home rule in taxation is provided for in the constitution. the experiment can affect only the local taxes, while state and federal taxes are still collected on the old lines. It is difficult to work out such a partial reform, because the issues are confused through the imposition of different kinds of taxes in the same district, steadily augmenting budgets of expenditure, and because of the efforts of neighboring areas ta diccredit the exyxnerimment.
In spite of all these difficulties, local and state experiments have been tried in different parts of the United States with results that must be very encouraging to all of us who believe in the ultimate triumph of human justice. In Oregon, for instance, the initiative and referendum have been secured as means by which the people may realize their desires. Home rule in taxation, enabling each locality to determine the means by which it would raise its local taxes, has been won, though it was afterward lost. State campaigns have been carried on and, while they have not yet been very successful, they have educated public opinion throughout the state until it has become possible for Mr. William O’Ren to bring forward the most complete measure for the realization of the Single Tax ever presented to American voters. This measure has the pledged support of the labor vote, and the educative effect of the impending campaign must prove very great, whether the measure is lost or won.
In the State of Missouri, a state-wide campaign for limited Tax was waged in 1912. It provided for a separate assessment of improvements and land values and for a gradual shifting of taxation from improvements to land values, so that in 1920 all improvements would be exempt. The farming population was not prepared for the measure and looked upon it as an attempt to saddle city taxes on the countryside. Intense feeling was everywhere aroused, meetings were broken up, rotten eggs were thrown, people favoring the tax were boycotted, and yet the measure polled 86,000 favorable votes. The results in the cities were very encouraging: Kansas City cast 33% of its vote for the measure; and in St. Louis it carried 46% of the total vote. This seems a very satisfactory result for a campaign waged in comparatively unprepared territory; competent ob- servers feel sure that the Single Tax has grown steadily in favor throughout Mis- souri since the campaign of 1912.
assessors had readjusted values in such a way as to present the working of the new law in its most unfavorable aspect. Since in the first year only 50% of improvements was to be exempt from taxation, it was possible to raise assessments on improvements and drop them on real values so as to confuse the public mind with regard. to the actual working of the new measure. At the same time four-fifths of the taxpayers who had improved property were benefited financially by the new measure. The next year 99% of improvements would have been exempt and no matter how administered the new law would have justified itself with the people. Meantime Denver had been deeply disturbed by a Single Tax campaign, and with its assistance the new law was repealed in Pneblo before it had really oone into effect
One of the most interesting experiments in the application of the Single Tax is that carried out by Mr. J.’ J. Pastoriza, Tax and Land Commissioner of Houston, Texas. The tax laws of the State called for taxes not only on real estate but also on all forms of personal property including cash in savings banks. Mr. Pastoriza proposed to the people of the city that, since these laws were never really carried out, he should exempt all cash deposits in banks and all household furniture and goods in stock, should assess all improvements on land at from % to % of their value and should raise the remaining money needed for city purposes directly on land assessed at 100% of its value.
To carry out such a plan it was necessary that Mr. Pastoriza should have the support not only of a majority of the citizens but of all of them, since any tax payer could ₪0 before the court and secure an injunction restraining his action at any time. For four years the tax payers supported this in- povation with the result that Houston became one of the most prosperous cities in the state with bank deposits greater than any other city of its population and with a wonderful development of business and public buildings. Mr. Pastoriza was re-elected by a large majority on his record, but after four years, dissatisfied land speculators secured an injunction restraining his action and left him no course but to enforce the laws of the state. If the state constitution of Texas had provided for home rule in taxation, it is inconceivable that the City of Houston would not be to-day a perfect demonstration of the benefit of such a system.
Meantime the hearings of the United States Commission on Industrial Relations held at Dallas, Texas, in 1915, showed that the whole state is rapidly passing under the dominancy of landlordism and that in many counties two-thirds of the holdings are worked by tenant farmers. In no state in the Union are the abuses of landlordism more oppressive than in California. Two million acres are owned by the Southern Pacific Railway, while in Kern County, which is larger than Connecticut, 0% of the irrigation lands is owned by the Southern Pacific, the Kern County Improvement Company and the firm of Miller and Lux. Henry George was born in California and his ideas have always had a large following in the State. Two successive cam-