The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 1 · January 1917
29printed page
scan 8 of 24

THE MACCABAEAN

question as a scientist. As an analytic investigator, he penetrated to the heart of the matter and struck at the root of the trouble. As an expert physician he did not devote his efforts to the symptoms of the disease, because the symptoms, though conspicuous and painful in themselves, are after all merely the external indication of an internal collapse. Hence what is to be gained by cleverly removing the symptoms? New ones are bound to appear in either an old or new form. By treating the symptoms we merely deceive the patient and temporarily allay the anxiety of his friends. A physician who wishes neither to deceive nor to reassure, but to root out the evil, will not resort to deception but honestly strive to discover the cause of the malady and adopt means for its elimination.

It must be admitted that we have had quacks in plenty. Some of them attempted to charm away the wound, while others swathed it in bandages to hide it from view. All of them had this in common; they were cowards who dared not face the unvarnished truth. They feared that the naked truth would force them to stop rehearsing their antics in whatever form, and by its irresistible logic compel them to seek a radical cure, an absolute solution to the burning Jewish Question. There can be but one radical cure for the malady, only one solution to the Jewish Question. The radical cure is an exodus from bondage into freedom; the absolute solution is national emancipation.

Moreover there can be no partial emancipation—by halves, by thirds, or by quarters. Whoever is half slave and half free is, as a matter of fact, completely enslaved. His social status is at times worse than that of a bondman; he can marry neither into the slave class nor into the free class. One-half of his nature militates against the other, and within the limits of one soul there is no room for two masters.

The Jewish Question has not been solved yet—not because of any want of external conditions necessary for the absolute solution, but because, above all, those who stand at the top of our social ladder are themselves servile bondmen. External conditions may of their own accord be propitious or may be made so; but of what avail are these conditions if the leaders of the people, its spokesmen and arbiters, recoil at the very mention of the absolute solution of the Jewish Question. Not only that: they rise in arms against the absolute solution, fight its adherents and consider no tactics too impure or too base for their warfare. Of what good will be the consent of the powers on the day when the chronicles of the family of nations will be read, if the consent of our people will not be forthcoming at the moment when its fate is to be considered?

For this reason, Pinsker's pamphlet, pleading for auto-emancipation, shows as yet no symptoms of old age. It was written to meet the needs of the day, but that day has not yet passed. Our generation has not learnt its lesson; would that the coming generation may no longer stand in need of Pinsker's pamphlet for guidance and that the dream of emancipation be realized.

However, in one respect Pinsker has erred, and that constitutes the weak spot in his pamphlet. It is a characteristic mark of the age during which this great Jew lived.

"It is obviously out of the question for us to think of creating perfect harmony (between the Jewish people

One-twenty-eight

and other peoples). Such harmony has never existed even among the other nations. The millenium, that hoped for a day when internationalism will be destroyed and all the nationalities will be fused into a universal brotherhood of man, is still far off and beyond our gaze. Until that messianic era dawns, the aspirations and ideals of the nations must limit themselves and strive to preserve an equitable equilibrium."

Those are Pinsker's words. It is one of Pinsker's theses, which, although it is stated parenthetically, nevertheless has a great value. But its value is a negative one.

Even a man of Pinsker's stamp, profound and keen thinker as he was, could not escape the fascination of an unholy cult which drew so many under its baleful influences by its deceptive external glamor. It has been only in most recent years, when the general theory of nationalism has been scientifically established, that some of the bolder spirits have begun to set themselves free from its magic spell.

In truth, if such is to be the nature of the messianic era, if on that day, at the blast of a Shofar all nations are to rush forward and be fused, that is—sacrifice their distinctive egos upon the altar of a new creature called "Humanity," if such is to be the fate of the nations "in the end of days," if that is to be the closing chapter of History preceding the day of redemption, then why strive to hasten its advent? Is it for the sake of the oppressed nationalities? But then the ideal of national emancipation and national freedom must descend from its lofty pinnacle and rest content with a humbler intermediate station which has but a transient and transitional value. Such an ideal is comparatively low and is overshadowed by a higher one. Pinsker did not specifically mention this "loftiest of the lofty," but left it to be inferred. It is Cosmopolitanism as it was understood for several generations past until about the middle of the nineteenth century.

To-day there is scarcely one among the savants and scientists who are working on the theory of nationalism—and their number is legion—that does not spurn that unholy cult. If there be a ladder reaching from earth to heaven, nationalism stands upon the topmost rung. It is not a temporary shelter, but a permanent dwelling that mankind is building. And mankind is but an abstraction; in the concrete it signifies a united family of nations—united, but not fused. It will have built that permanent dwelling when it will have drawn the boundaries of nations and established rules for their conduct in such a manner that each might enjoy complete liberty without, on the other hand, infringing upon the rights of his neighbor. To be sure this is a distant ideal, but then it has a basis in fact and springs from historic development. It is rooted in the soil and does not dangle in mid air. On us, on our inner consciousness and our determination to give it palpable expression depends, in a certain measure, the possibility of hastening the advent of the day of redemption when national violence and national robbery will be obliterated, in exactly the same way that organized government has, also only in a certain measure banished wrong-doing and crime from the state.

It may be that Pinsker wrote his pamphlet in German with a view to influencing the Occident because he clearly foresaw that we would need the help of the Occident in executing our program, that he therefore paid this tribute to their views on the coming millenium, in order to make his own views more acceptable to them. If that was so we should consider those statements as a concession rather than an essential thesis in his system of thought.

January, 1917