The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 1 · January 1917
2scan
of 24

THE MACCABAEAN

tion was left by the peace agreement to the united Congress Committee. At the Hotel Savoy conference, it was decided by a vote of 60 to 29 that the question be left to the Congress, with freedom to decide what should be done. An attempt was made to compel the Congress to work through the existing relief committees, which failed. The defeat of the restrictive clause meant not only that the Congress would take up the problem of constructive relief, but also was an indication of the attitude of mind of the Committee on the general proposition for which the Congressists have been contending. It was our thought that the Congress should be absolutely free, but in the interests of peace, we agreed to limit the Congress as to scope and time. One concession was wrung from the new converts to the Congress movement, which was, that the united Congress Committee could place the problem of constructive relief on the Congress program. To that extent, the Congress has now recovered a part of the freedom taken from it. It is hoped through this opening to obtain for the Congress other rights which circumstances may compel it to assume. It is clear, however, that the members of the united Congress Committee have no fear of the consequences should the Congress be allowed to take up other questions of equal, if not larger import than the question of constructive relief. As the various elements in American Jewry come together, and misunderstandings are removed, they realize more and more that the Jews of America need no constitutional prohibitions against freedom of action on any matter of Jewish interest.

LUCIEN WOLF RESIGNS

MR. LUCIEN WOLF has finally been eliminated as a factor in English Jewish politics. Dr. Moses Gaster has been elected in his place as president of the National Union of Jewish Rights. The new spirit of Jewish democracy has permeated English Jewry, and it has become impossible for one man, or a small group of men, to act on behalf of the Jewish people without their consent. Mr. Wolf, serving the old leadership, sought to represent Jewish aspirations, and did not think it necessary to consult with his constituency. In ante-bellum days, this would have been passed by with a shrung of the shoulder, but since the outbreak of the war, the Jews of England have felt that the interests at stake were too serious to permit such irresponsible conduct. Mr. Wolf was asked to resign, and a Zionist has been elected to succeed him. It is to be hoped that this will put an end to irresponsible articles like the recent article in the Fortnightly Review, and that the Jews of England will unite not only as to what is to be done, but also as to what should not be done.

JEWISH RIGHTS IN POLAND

THE American "Jewish Chronicle" has made public the details of the recent German legislation bearing upon the reorganization and recognition of the Jews in the occupied territories. As was suspected,

THE B'NAI BERITH THE Independent Order B'nai Berith takes its place in the Congress movement as one of the democratic forces. The Order is to be congratulated upon its decision. For many years, the B'nai Berith has maintained a democratic organization, strongly disciplined, organized for philanthropic purposes, but wavering as to the larger interests of the Jewish people. It maintained its

this legislation does not give national recognition. It is intended to provide for an organization of Jews and the basis of the qualification of voters is religious. Furthermore, it provides for two Curias, or legislative branches. One Curia is to be elected by Jewish voters who have certain educational qualifications and persons who have obtained rabbinical degrees from a recognized Jewish institution. The other Curia is to be composed of representatives elected by the common people, as it were. The curious part of this enactment is that the two Curias are to have an equal number of representatives in the Community council. Inasmuch as the persons who have the educational qualifications are, for the most part, members of the assimilating group, it is clear that the legislation provides that the assimilators, in spite of the fact that they are a small minority, shall have an equal if not a predominant voice in the affairs of the Community. Under the circumstances, it is not surprising that this recognition of the Jews is regarded in many quarters as a move directed against Jewish nationalist aspirations in Poland. .

international character, and rested upon its laurels, leaving to other forces with more energy to acquire a predominating influence in Jewish life. With the acquisition of new elements, the B'nai Berith has with difficulty held to a neutral attitude on many of the pressing questions of the day. One thing was clear. If it wished to hold its own, and prevent its own submergence as an important deciding factor, it would have to abandon its neutrality. At the Hotel Savoy conference, Mr. Kraus made his decision. He cast the lot of the B'nai Berith with the democratic, nationalistic elements. He thus aided materially in the overthrow of the erstwhile Eastern leaders, and re-established his own organization in the good opinion and esteem of many of its friends.

MR. SCHIFF’S BIRTHDAY

WE JOIN in the felecitations extended to Mr. Jacob H. Schiff upon his seventieth birthday. Mr. Schiff has been an outstanding figure in American Jewish charity and philanthropy for the past thirty years. On all matters relating to the development of the institutional life of American Jewry, he has always been a clear-headed, generous and thoughtful leader. At one time, he was the only man to whom one could turn with a project of large and significant dimensions, with a certainty that he would give his thought and his means to its realization, provided it met with his views as to what ought to be done. He has had imagination and vision and the ability to carry with him a large constituency. The philanthropic leadership of American Jewry has established a number of institutions that have been of undoubted value in raising the self-respect and knowledge of our people. It has created a chain of institutions intended to provide for many of the needs of American Jewry. A list of such institutions would be imposing. In all of these activities Mr. Schiff has been not only a contributor of money, but also of thought and sagacious direction. In recent years, however, Mr. Schiff has found himself in the midst of a strong Zionistic and nationalistic revival, which has evoked a new stream of Jewish activity, and brought within the Jewish fold forces that have placed Jewish life upon an altogether different footing. Instead of working with this stream, Mr. Schiff has sought to throw the weight of his influence against it. He has not only held to his philosophy of life, grounded in the theories of German reform Judaism, but he has been, willingly or unwillingly, a propagandist of his views. This was regretable, for it became the duty of many who had a personal affection for the philanthropist to take issue with the propagandist. Thus it appeared that a large number of Jews, personally favorably disposed toward Mr. Schiff, and admiring him for his generosity and sacrifices for Jewish causes, had to combat his propaganda. But this fact does not prevent the expression of our best wishes for a long life and a happy one, and of our hope that he will soon be convinced by the good the Zionists are doing to become a friend and not an opponent of the Zionist movement.

CONTENTS

EDITORIALS121
ON THE BIOGRAPHY OF LEO PINSKER, By Reuben Brainin123
Achad Ha’am126
Schmarya Levin127
By S. M. Melamed129
Lipsky133
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR135
OF THE KNIGHTS OF ZION136
THE ZIONIST MOVEMENT138