The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 1 · January 1917
19scan
of 24
Facsimile · scan 19 of 24
Scan of scan 19
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

death, provides a happy common platform for the Zionists and the President of the Jewish Territorial Organization. For Pinsker was the father of all those who see in Auto-Emancipation the path of salvation. His book, published in 1881, was a brilliant anticipation of much later history and literature, and its brilliance was not that of flowers or of jewels, but of fire. Its problem was seen with a burning sense of the great Jewish tragedy _and resolved in words of flame. It was @ great book. Yet Herzl, when he wrote his “Judenstaat’ 'in 1895, had probably never heard of it, and this, though Pinsker’s book had preceded his in calling forth a Congress from almost every country of Europe. I said that Pinsker was the father of all Auto-Emancipation, proceeded Mr. Zangwill. But it is a wise child that knows his own father, and I, too, had never seen this book till years after the Ito was established. Before Pinsker there had been the American Sephardi, Mordecai Manuel Noah, who in 1825 not only planned a great Jewish colony on an island in the State of New York, but actually bought land for it, and issued an invitation to the Ghettos of Europe to 800% to his Ararat, and even held the Dedication Service—as readers of my story, ‘Noah’s Ark,” may remember. How comes it that a Russian like Pinsker, an Austrian like Herzl, an American like Noah, and an Englishman like myself, are all found putting forth the same solution of the Jewish problem? Is it plagiarism? Not at all. Herzl, Pinsker, (Noah, were in sublime unconsciousness of one another. It is because there is what the advertisements call “ a felt want” and this want prompts everywhere the same suggestion for meeting it. The bulk of our troubles springing from our lack of a common land or even of a majority anywhere, it is a natural suggestion that we should re-establish ourselves upon a normal national basis.

The interesting fact remained, said Mr. Zangwill, that Herzl’s Congress, called for Territorialism, ended in the adoption of Palestine as its goal, that Pinsker’s Congress, called for Territorialism, ended in a society to aid Palestine immigrants, and that even Noah’s institution “Ararat” was replaced by a rallying call to Zion. What was the reason for this recurrent transformation? It was—except possibly in Noah’s case—that no other land could be found at once adaptable, adequate and attainable and so these revolutionary spirits fell back perforce upon the old racial dream. But that—paradoxically enough—was the very reason why he (Mr. Zangwill) turned back from Palestine— for in his case the usual order was reversed and he had come into Territorialism from Zionism. For if his predecessors had found no other land adaptable, adequate and attainable, his unhappy discovery was that Palestine, too, was unadaptable, inadequate, and unattainable. It seemed a vicious circle—the Territorialist became a Zionist and the Zionist a Territorialist—and if Dr. Weizmann could show the way of escape from it nobody would be more grateful to him than would he, for there was another curious coincidence. All the four men he had mentioned were writers, though Pinsker, like Nordau, was a physician, and three out of the four were dramatists. Now writers, and especially dramatists, were accustomed to depict the world in their own colors and moulds—the world, however, insists obstinately on remaining of

its own color and mould. But Dr. Weizmann was a man of science, and a man on whom the Zionist movement was sincerely to be congratulated, and on whom it might well pin its hopes.

it might well pin its hopes. Judaism alone in the world, said Mr. Zangwill in conclusion, is without a policy, though now I am glad to say there are substantial signs of universal agreement in the program of equal rights everywhere, and no substantial disagreement with a supplementary Palestine plank. I am much struck by the remark of a famous Hindoo nationalist, Lajpat Rai, in a book which he has just published in New York. Nine years ago Lajpat Rai was deported from India as a dangerous agitator for Home Rule, but being allowed by the wisdom of Lord Morley to return, he devoted himself to mere social and religious activity. Now, however, in his book, he writes as if those nine years were wasted, for he has discovered, or re-discovered, that without Nationalism the character of a people is “emasculated.” “Nationalists,” he says, “maintain that the first condition of life —life with respect and honor, life for profit and advantage, life for progress and advancement—is political freedom. Life without that is no life. It is idle, therefore, to think of matters which are manifestations or developments or embellishments of life.” The Jewish problem is infinitely more complex than the Indian, for the people are not upon a land. But political freedom at least they must have, in whatever land. And whether in Russia or in Palestine freedom can only come to those who demand it, for even if conferred as a gift it would be spiritually barren. The only formula of salvation is, as the great Jew we are honoring to-night rightly perceived, Auto-Emancipation.

Dr. Weizmann, in his address on Pinsker,. reviewed the period in which he lived and the circumstances which had led him to come to the only conclusion which was possible to arrive for any honest thinking and feeling Jew. The speaker dwelt exhaustively on the small book16% “Auto-Emancipation,” which was destined to become historic. Pinsker diagnosed the Jewish disease in a most scientific way. He was well equipped for that purpose, because he was the patient as well as the doctor. Dr. Weizmann went on to emphasis the fact that everything that was written by Pinsker in 1882 was applicable to the present time. He laid stress on the rashness of the Jew, his intellectual lack of stability as well as his physical mobility. He had lost all individuality and was all adaptability. Intellectually as well as materialy he was the middleman, exchanging great ideas in small currents. It is all mere accident lacking a definite aim, a sound tradition. It merely depended whether he was an English Jew, a French or German .Jew. The very activity of the Jew had become a curse to the Jewish people because it was at the cost of hfs Jewish national individuality. Such a condition was inevitable as long as the Jews were landless. It appeared very simple but Jews had become so subtle that they failed to see th most obvious. In conclusion, Dr. Weizmann said that Pinsker like Herzl later, started with some gigantic scheme, but he realized that conditions must be taken into account and instead of the vague large scheme of mere territorialism he became President of the Odessa Chovevi Zion, for which he worked hard till his

death. Like Herzl, too, he first appealed to the Western Jews, to the rich, the magnates, but he too soon realized that the salvation of the Jews must come through the people itself, hence his close identification with the work of Eastern Jewry.

Another meeting in commemoration of the twenty-fifth anniversary of the death of Dr. Leo Pinsker, was held in the East End under the joint auspices of the West End Hebrew Circle and the East End Zionist Association. The meeting was addressed by Nahum Sokolow, Dr. Weizmann, and Leon Simon. The very Reverend Dr. Moses Gaster presided. Dr. Gaster opened the meeting in Hebrew, explaining the purpose of the gathering which was to commemorate one of the leaders of the Jewish National movement ~+Dr. Leo Pinsker. Mr. Sokolow then addressed the gathering. He pictured vividly the thoughts and aspirations of the period of Pinsker’s birth, the illusions of the Jewish “inteligenzia,” the hope and belief that the salvation of the Jewish question would come the moment they became educated and hid Jewishness when outside the Jewish home. Pinsker was carried away by the stream. He believed with the others of his time that internal Jewish reform if not total assimilation could be the only panacea of the Jewish problem. Dealing with Pinsker’s personality, the speaker said that Pinsker’s depth of feeling and his lofty ideals could be seen from his devotion to his profession. He was a distinguished medical man, but regarded his call as a priesthood rather than as a profession. His great soul he gave to his people when he arrived at the conclusion that the remedies offered by his contemporaries were mere palliatives. His booklet, ‘“Auto-Emancipation,” was a courageous document. It was an historic appeal to the Jews themselves. It was eloquent, and some of its passages had a prophetc ring about them. It burned with holy indignation. Mr. Sokolow dealt with the question, frequently asked how a man with such a comprehensive and far-reaching mind as that possessed by Pinsker could, after formulating such ajl-embracing solutions to the Jewish problems come afterwards to confine his activity to Chovevi Zion, of which he was first President. Pinsker realized the needs of the movement, He knew that great thoughts are realized through small deeds, Hence his devotion to the pioneer work of Jewish colonization in Palestine. In the name of the Zionist Actions Comite as well as on his own behalf, he came to honor the memory of Pinsker, which he regarded as but the fulfilment of the Commandment “Honor thy father.” Pinsker indeed was one of the fathers of Jewish nationalism.