THE MACCABAEAN
fact that fourteen representatives of the National Workmen's Committee voted for Mr. Marshall, who, in Jewish life as well as on all issues in American life, represents principles they oppose. The explanation of this phenomenon may be found in the unofficial slate drawn up in advance of the meeting by a committee composed of representatives of the workmen and of the American Jewish Committee.
The outcome of the roll-call was foreseen by the democratic forces. When the election of Mr. Kraus was announced, it developed that beyond making an issue of the chairmanship, the minority had no program, except one of limitation. This was revealed in the second outstanding incident of the meeting.
Mr. Marshall was made the chairman of the committee to report on the question of constructive relief. He was a minority in that committee, a number of his own followers voting with the majority in favor of a free consideration of the problem by the Congress. Mr. Marshall made a powerful argument in favor of restricting the Congress to the consideration of constructive relief through the existing relief committee, pleading that to do otherwise would involve the permanence of the Congress. Against this argument, Dr. Wise spoke with remarkable eloquence, pointing out that the Congress ought not to be limited to a consideration of the problem through the existing relief committees; it should be free to do the work through them or through such other agencies as might be created or utilized. The vote on this question was unmistakably against Mr. Marshall's contention. Many of his own followers voted against him. The count showed sixty against him, and twenty-nine with him.
When the question of permanent chairman came up, it was hoped that the defeat of the morning would bring about the election of a compromise candidate, satisfactory to both parties. The leaders of the American Jewish Committee made the issue the candidacy of Mr. Marshall. His friends would not withdraw his name. Attempts were made to suggest other candidates, but only his name would satisfy his friends. Had they contented themselves with merely placing his name in nomination as the minority candidate, the conflict would not have aroused such bitterness of feeling. Instead of the simple precedure usual in such cases of making the minority nomination the nominators of Mr. Marshall tactlessly and unfairly attacked Mr. Kraus by charging that he was the head of a secret Jewish organization. When they did this, it was clear that Mr. Marshall could not by any possibility be elected, and that Mr. Kraus would receive the overwhelming majority, for among the men on the other side were prominent mem-
bers of the Benai Berith, who knew that the charge was unfounded and malicious. But Mr. Kraus, with rare generosity, met the situation by offering to withdraw, provided Mr. Marshall also would withdraw. The challenge of Mr. Kraus was accepted by Mr. Marshall, and instead of electing a man who had been neutral on the Congress question, the meeting had the added pleasure of electing to the leadership of the committee a man who is identified with the Zionist movement and with the Congress movement as a representative of the original Congress committee. This was the penalty Mr. Marshall's friends had to pay for their tactless behavior.
The only other incident worthy of notice—or unworthy of notice, as tastes may go—was the incident of Mr. Meyer London. The workmen's committee took advantage of the strong desire for peace in the Congress movement to threaten withdrawal unless Mr. London was elected on the administrative committee. A majority of the delegates were determined not to permit Mr. London's election, on the ground that he had publicly insulted his own people in a speech delivered in Boston, and that he had not satisfactorily explained his remarks or apologized for them. The workmen's representatives, however, under cover of the pretext, wanted to withdraw on the ground that they had not been given adequate representation on the administrative committee. This was an obvious evasion of the issue. Dr. Magnes' intervention on behalf of Mr. London revealed the hypocrisy of the threat, and brought the issue to a head. Mr. London was compelled to make his explanation to the assembly, which, while characteristic and only partly satisfying, was accepted by the majority, and the incident was closed by his election to the Committee.
The names of the officers of the new Committee reveal the quality of the control of the future organization of the Congress: Nathan Straus is chairman; Harry Cutler, Harry Friedenwald, Isaac Hourwich, Morris Hilquit and Leon Sanders, vice-presidents; Adolph Lewisohn, treasurer; Bernard G. Richards, executive secretary; Harry Cutler, chairman of the Administrative Committee; and Louis E. Kirstein, vice-chairman of the Administrative Committee. These officers constitute the Office Committee, which will be the executive branch of the entire committee. On the so-called administrative committee, we have a majority of nationalists and Zionists.
Congratulations are due to the well-organized Zionist group, including the Mizrachists and the Poale Zion, and to their allies in the Orders and Verbands, and especially credit is due to Mr. Kraus and his friends, for the victory here briefly recorded and commented upon.
Reform Judaism and Zionism
(Continued from Page 132)
It will be a progressive Jewish life. It will not be apart from the life of the modern world; it will be in and of the modern world. It will accept and welcome the items of modern life in all its aspects and state them in terms of the Jewish soul, just as our lexicographers are to-day busy finding equivalents in our ancient tongue for the terms of modern science and thought. It will realize a Jewish democracy and illustrate through this realization the possibilities of the highest democracy to all the world
Those who are Zionists and members of Reform Jewish Synagogues do not feel any inconsistency in their position. To the contrary, their zeal for Reform in Judaism is deepened and purified and directed aright by
their interest in and loyalty to the Zionist ideal. They see in Zionism the biggest and most inclusive interpretation of Judaism, the great hope of Jewish life, of the possibilities of the realizationof Jewish ideals, of the preservation of the Jew and through him of Jewish spiritual values, the promise of the preservation of religious Judaism and of its healthy evolution, of the larger service of the Jew to himself and to the world. The Reform Jewish Zionist looks forward to a Day of God, to use the old prophetic term, in which the wish of the Great Lawgiver will be realized, that “all the people be prophets,” a people dedicated one and all to the fulfillment of the Jewish hope, that “out of Zion will go forth the Law and the word of our God from Jerusalem.”