The Maccabaean · Vol. XXX, No. 1 · January 1917
32printed page
scan 11 of 24

THE MACCABAEAN

terms particularly in the western world; and Zionism is as impatient of the one as of the other. However, in all truth it must be said that Orthodoxy does not lend itself so readily to this siren song, as its emphasis upon a knowledge of Hebrew and its adherence to the generally used ritual of the synagogue as well as the general practice of Jews throughout the centuries protects it from the excesses of the assimilationist theory.

Zionists, too, read the history of the Reform movement. They find that the rejection of the national hope and its correlations is but one part of the Reform program. With the desire of the Reformers to adjust Jewish life to modern standards, Zionism is in the deepest sympathy; but it insists that such readjustment shall not be at the expense of the Jewish values involved. It does not look to Protestant forms and ideals as setting the standard of Jewish conduct and belief. It believes that on strictly Jewish grounds the desired restatement is possible, and protests against the lack of standard so sadly expressed in the remark of the college professor, who spoke of his inability to determine what character of service he was participating in, in one of hears large metropolitan synagogues. To some of his hears no doubt the remark gave great satisfaction. To the Zionist it was a tragic illustration of the unfortunate tendency to assimilate to the most absurd extreme.

Zionism will not "ghettoize" Judaism. It will restate Judaism in modern terms but it will be in accord with the history, traditions, hopes and practices of the Jewish people. It frankly differs with Reform Judaism's rejection of the national hope on the grounds that such rejection was contrary to the spirit of Jewish life and thought during the preceding centuries and that thereby Judaism was deprived of one of its strongest protectives against disintegration. And it would humbly point out that the rejection of the national hope did not bring about the results in the attitude of the non-Jewish world towards the Jew that the sanguine Reformers expected. From without we are still constantly reminded that we are a separate people; and our practice from within even among those Jews who are not affiliated with the synagogue—all the more among the religious minded—insists upon the particularity of the Jews among the peoples of the earth.

Zionism is not only a philanthropic movement, having in mind one possible means of relief of the tense situation of the Jews of Eastern and Southeastern Europe, but is a philosophy of Jewish life which would stay the processes of disintegration never more evident than at present among Jews the world over. It therefore fears the further results of the centrifugal tendencies only too manifest in assimilationist circles. It views the creation of national Judaisms at the expense of national Judaism with increasing alarm. It is not only interested in American Israel or Russian Jewry or Palestinian Israel. It is interested in world Israel, Catholic Israel, to use the late Dr. Schechter's compelling term.

Zionism refuses to confine the Jewish soul to a single expression of that soul. The contents of Bible and Talmud as well as all those later items, accounts of which we include in our presentations of Jewish history, demonstrate that Jewish life did not contemplate being restricted to its religious expression. In the codes of the Bible and Talmud we find provision not only for cult and creed and morals but also for all those multifarious phenomena which are associated with that totality of expression which constitutes national life. That these provisions are shot through and through with the spirit of Jewish religious and ethical idealism does not alter the

fundamental fact of their being national. The Reform pulpit itself reveals its own inconsistency in this matter by the attention it pays to Jews who left the synagogue for one reason or the other, the Heines, Disraelis and Spinozas of our history, as well as by its marked attention to phases of Jewish activity in which Judaism as a religion has played little if any part, e. g., The Jew in Music; The Jew and Journalism; The Jew in Medicine, etc., etc.

This contention of the Zionist that Jewish life is more than a religion, does not eliminate or neglect the Jewish religion but rather co-ordinates it with all other expressions of Jewish life. Yes, the Zionist gratefully regards this spiritual activity of the Jew as his greatest contribution to the world; but it adds, it is not his only contribution. It better understands the religious life of the Jew because of its association with these other aspects of Jewish genius. It does not become less significant, this religious element of Jewish life, but more significant. And the possibilities of its further development become more assuring when the Jewish religion does not hang in the air, but is understood as the highest interpretation of all the values which the Jewish heart and mind have conceived. To suggest a parallel: Historical study teaches that Greek life was significant because of its unique contributions to the theory and cult of the beautiful. But Greek life expressed itself in a myriad other forms, and concerned itself with scores of other matters, not to be neglected in our estimate of the whole of Hellenism; indeed without our rather full knowledge of them, Hellenism would be a rather empty shell. So, too, though the supreme expression of Jewish life is the religious, it is not its sole expression. And to limit our interest in Jewish life to that one expression is artificially to limit it and to attempt to understand one aspect of Judaism apart from all its other aspects. It is the totality of Jewish experience and expression that fires the imagination and stimulates the zeal of the nationalist. And Zionism expects to continue Jewish life upon this maximum basis, and not to threaten its future by a minimum, no matter how splendid that minimum may be. The prosiness of modern Jewish life is a surface indication of its want of those deeper emotional and imaginative qualities which alone can furnish a vital basis for loyalty which will evoke service and sacrifice.

As we see it, Reform Judaism with its insistence upon the sufficiency of the religious element of Judaism has seen the Jewish problem solely as the problem of the individual. There can be no debate about the importance of the personal element in the religious life. But Zionism sees the problem of the Jewish people as a whole. This difference I take it is fundamental, but implies no basal antagonism as the one is included in the other. Probably the fact that the assimilationist has so construed the problem of Jewish life, as that of the individual, makes clear the reason of the defection of so many of the best minds of our group during the past century, a far greater number it is estimated than during any other similar period of our history. The stress that Jewish thought has always placed upon the social aspect of religion and of life points to the correctness of the Zionist position from the traditional point of view. And modern life is coming more and more to the Jewish ideal of social relations. Zionism teaches its followers that they dare not exercise their individualism at the expense of the welfare of the whole Jewish people. By putting the individual Jew into vital relation with the whole of Jewry, it rouses his pride and demands his service for the greater end in view. It will not deny him his private right of