The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIX, No. 6 · December 1916
110printed page
scan 18 of 34

THE MACCABAEAN

tion, between the designs on their ancient tombstones and their modern peasant embrodiery. (The curious reader may care to look up the Journal of Hellenic Studies, Vol. XXIV, pp. 260 and 289.) The Jews, however, in spite of the standardizing influence of Greek culture and Roman institutions, we have always with us, and the world is the richer for them in more senses than one. So again Babylon and Assyria have been taken while Armenia and Egypt and Persia remain.

It is hard to explain these vicissitudes of ancient history, but one thing seems clear. However nationalities may have died out through assimilation and the decay of self-consciousness in the past, they are not likely to continue to do so. The apostles of uniformity and standardization are in fact nowadays in a dilemma. If they attempt to stamp out a national consciousness by oppression they only kindle it into new life, as there is ample recent history to show. If they try “killing by kindness” they are apt to find that the favored population begins to take an interest in its past, and that a national movement springs up in the happier and more wholesome field of education and literature. There must be many instances of this in the United States. In the British Isles Sir Walter Scott’s novels and the recent achievements of Irish and Welsh drama are sufficient examples. Scott did a great service to the United Kingdom by interesting English readers in Scotland and so overlaying—or sub- limating, as I believe the psychologists call it—the traditional atmosphere of enmity and suspicion between the two nations—the legacy of the Jacobite risings of the eighteenth century. Yeats and Synge have done something of the same kind for Ireland, and Rabindranath Tagore is doing it for India. I cannot help feeling, though I speak with diffidence, that imaginative work of the same kind remains to be done for Slavic and Jewish and Italian and German America, and that this would do more to knit together the peoples of the American commonwealth than the policy of assimilation and the melting-pot can hope to achieve.

For the central fact about nationality, as I see it, is that it is not, as so many Europeans and even Americans believe, a political force at all, but a spiritual force. In essence it has nothing to do with politics. Its connection with law and government is accidental and due to the folly of governments in interfering with intimate spheres into which it is not their business to penetrate. Civic obligation does not require and could not possibly compel a British citizen of German descent to feel about Germany as ordinary Englishmen do. How can he help feeling differently, and more intensely? But if citizenship cannot prescribe to us how we should feel, neither should nationality prescribe to us how we should think. It may lay down for us the way in which we think—for

One-hundred-ten

there seems to be something innate in modes of thought and feeling, as the persistence of national and even family types seems to show—but there is nothing national about the actual processes either of reasoning or of moral judgment. These are universal human faculties. The opinions which they enable us to form are ours in virtue of the fact that we are human beings living in society, and we accept them, or should accept them, not from blood or tradition or sentiment, but at the bar of reason and conscience alone. And if this is true of opinion, still more it is true of conduct in relation to public affairs. The distinction between the two spheres is surely clear, and certainly vital; yet both chauvinists and sentimentalists in all countries are constantly ignoring it.

RZ u a Re ER SR A ee RE RE ee A Politics is a science and an art that has been developed, still very imperfectly, to meet certain universal human needs. Its conceptions and its achievements are not national but universal; they belong to the higher life of the human race as a whole. No nation or section of mankind can claim or desire a monopoly or a patent right in respect to law or liberty or democracy or the principle of representation. These are great universal discoveries, or landmarks of human progress, which serve to bind men together, not to herd them off into national pens. The idea or ideal that every nationality must have its own independent government, which became prevalent during the nineteenth century, is a purely modern growth and, as Lord Acton pointed out at the time, a palpable absurdity. It is moreover quite incompatible with the migration and mobility which have become permanent and increasing features of modern civilized life. Men who are living together in society need justice and liberty not in virtue of their intimate sentiments or their race or language or religion, but in virtue of their needs as social beings. No one would dream of putting the Norwegians of Minnesota or the Germans of Wisconsin under a separate government in virtue of their particular sentiments, and the ideal of the national state would seem equally misplaced in the east of Europe had not the political evolution of that part of the world been hopelessiy retarded by the wickedness or imbecility of the governments concerned. The state is not the expression of national individuality, like art or literature or intimate modes of thought and feeling. It is a community of human beings organized on the basis of mutual service. Thus it is that as commerce and intercourse are gradually causing the world to shrink and bringing into existence a world society, we are slowly moving towards a single World-State. But it is equally certain that nationality is alive and will prove indestructible, and that in a world exposed at every turn to vulgar and soulless standardization, its conscious preservation is essential to meet the deeper needs of the human spirit —New Repupblie. London.

December, 1916