taken. Nevertheless, Mr. Schiff forestalled criticism by pronouncing in advance a curse upon all interferers with the orderly administration of the relief, orderliness meaning unanimous accord with the views of Dr. Magnes and Mr. Felix M. Warburg. Coming direct from Warsaw, Dr. Magnes is presumed to know the conditions in Poland. But his assertion that the German Hilfscomite is the only agency for the distribution of relief in Poland is contradicted by the facts are these: The Provisional Zionist Committee through its transfer department is sending money to individual Jews in all parts of Poland. This money is sent through the U. S. State Department to the American Consul at Warsaw and by him delivered to a special committee of Jews in Warsaw, who see to the delivery of the money to the persons for whom it is intended. No German committee intervenes. The money is clearly American money until it reaches its destination. The Warsaw committee has sent us receipts direct from the persons to whom the money was sent. In this way, not only was Warsaw reached—and Dr. Magnes concedes that funds could be sent to Warsaw for distribution in its province without the intermediation of a German Committee—but other cities are reached, like Grodno, Wilna, Bialystock, Kobrin, Lida, Makow, Pinsk, Prushany, Brest-Litovsk, Antopol, Slonim, Suwalk, Wilkewisk, Narewka, Novogrudek, and Tarogen. Now, from the report of the Joint Distribution Committee it appears that the money sent to the German Hilfscomite is actually distributed by local committees in the various cities. The names of the committees are given. They are all the names of Polish Jews. It is the duty of Dr. Magnes to answer this question: Why cannot a Warsaw committee be established representing all elements of Polish Jewry, to whom the relief monies might be sent through our State Department, this Warsaw committee recognizing the local committees already in existence, and deciding upon the principles of distribution after consultation with as many of these committees as could be reached. Are they not as competent as a committee resident in Berlin? Why is it necessary, in view of the existence of the Warsaw committee, of the Lodz committee, of the Bialystock, the Grodno committees, for us to send American Jewish relief money to the German Hilfscomite? The argument is not one based upon efficiency, but upon policy. The dignity and self-respect of the Jews of Poland demand that they be treated with respect, without intermediaries. They should not be compelled to accept American Jewish relief money from German Jews, who are, under the circumstances, compelled to adjust their policy to the policies of the German government. This is an important issue in Jewish life, and it cannot be disposed of by an ex parte statement. It affects the neutrality of American Jewry.
THE MACCABAEAN
THE TRANSFER DEPARTMENT
WE ASK our readers to peruse with care the statement on the Zionist transfer department, which appears in this issue of The Maccabaean. This unique institution is the original contribution of the Zionist organization. It aims to bring out the natural relief of individuals by their relatives residing here. At a time when it was impossible to send money to the belligerent lands. the free service rendered by the transfer department resulted in throwing into the broken Jewish communities the relief contributions of kinsmen. This was not charity. When the plan was first proposed, in September, 1914, to the American Jewish Relief Committee, it was treated as a fantastic idea, and men like Mr. Oscar S. Straus ridiculed it. Then when the Provisional Zionist Committee undertook to do this work for Palestine, and it was seen that the plan was a practical one, the American Jewish Relief Committee, in a perfunctory manner, adopted it for Europe. After a few months trial, it gave the work up. The Provisional Zionist Committee then extended its transfer operations to Europe, and succeeded in raising quite a large sum in this way. Recently, observing the success of the Provisional Zionist Committee in its European transfer work, the Joint Distribution Committee again opened a transfer bureau. Under the circumstances, it would have been a gracious act for the Joint Distribution Committee to have approached the Provisional Committee and attempted to co-ordinate the work, or to turn over all its transfer work to the latter. There would have been a saving of expense. The results would have been more satisfactory. The transfer department of the Provisional Committee costs about $15,- 000, which is charged up, in large part, against the Emergency Fund. What the expense of the Joint Distribution Committee is in this respect, we have not been informed, for the Joint Distribution Committee does not make known its expenses. But it preferred to ignore the transfer department of the Provisional Committee, and now here and there complaints are heard against the Committee for duplicating the work of the Joint Distribution Committee. This is unfair. With great difficulty, the Provisional Committee has introduced a system of administration in its transfer department, which is now as near perfection as it can possibly become under the fluctuating conditions of war. Absolute neutrality is observed in the sending of remittances to the belligerent lands. The money is sent through our State Department. It reaches United States representatives, and is by them handed over to committees or individuals. Individual receipts are being received by the Provisional Committee, which are sent to the remit- ters. A classified index of remitters and recipients is kept, and all inquiries are thus easily replied to. The financial con- facts, which he should also know. The trol provides for a supervision which an-