The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIX, No. 5 · November 1916
83printed page
scan 11 of 26

Zionism and Reform Judaism

A Symposium on Zionism by Leading Reform Rabbis of the country

A circular letter addressed to a large number of reform rabbis by the Zionist organization through a special committee composed of Dr. Max Raisin, Dr. Max Heller and Dr. Martin A. Meyer, has elicited a batch of interesting replies, given herewith as a contribution to an understanding of the position of reform rabbis on the Zionist question. Dr. Philipson's view, that one of the dogmas of reform Judaism is a denial of the nationalistic aspirations of the Jewish people is not shared by many of his colleagues. There is no doubt that a great deal of the dogmatic opposition to Zionism has disappeared during the past few years. These letters are published with the consent of the writers.—Editor.

"Zionism is Antithesis of Reform."

Cincinnati, O., October 16, 1916. Dear Colleagues: Your appeal to the “Reform Rabbinate in America” in behalf of Zionism, a copy of which has reached me is, in all truth, a surprising performance, to say the least. It is to be admired more for its zeal than for its discretion. In your zeal for the Zionist cause you assume an attitude towards those of us who are non-Zionists which I, for one, cannot permit to pass unnoticed and unchallenged.

I do not know whence you draw your information that the “best Reform elements are willing to admit that it (Zionism) has accomplished wonders in bringing about a spiritual and religious renaissance, etc.” You may have sources of information that are closed to me, but, as far as I know, it is claimed generally by reformers that the renaissance which the Zionists are attributing constantly to Zionism is neither spiritual nor religious but nationalistic and cultural. This constitutes one of our main points of criticism and dissent. Zionism qua Zionism, as conceived by Herzl and as interpreted by its most acclaimed leaders, Nordau in Europe and Brandeis in America, neither of whom has taken any active part in the religious side of Jewish life, spells secular nationalism and not spiritual religionism. Zionism is the Jewish counterpart of that latter day preachment of nationalism which is finding its logical and frightful expression in the murderous war across the sea. Zionism interprets the term “the Jewish people” to mean a small politico-national unit such as is Serbia or Montenegro (as in fact one. of its leading spokesmen has declared) while we non-Zionists conceive the Jewish people to be an international religious people united by spiritual and not politico-national bonds. That famous Biblical phrase that speaks of Israel as “a unique people in the earth” makes the matter very clear. A unique people! How unique? In that it is different from every other people. Without a country or a political organization of its own, this people, living in all lands and part of all nations, was to become unique through its spiritual message and its international character. Thus has it happened and so is it to-day. The solution of the so called “Jewish problem” lies in the complete realization of this ideal through the obtaining of freedom and equal rights for Jews in all lands.

I can not but resent the implication of unfairness on the part of us who are non-Zionists when you write “we appeal to your sense of fair play to judge the movement, etc” Because we do not see as you would

have us see, are we therefore unfair? It were easy to respond with a tu quoque. But that would be calling names and not argument. You also say "we are confident that an unbiased study of what Zionism has accomplished, will induce you to greater consideration of its claims, etc." Would you imply that those of your colleagues who are not sympathetic with Zionism have taken snap judgment? that we have not given unbiased study to the movement? This is a very serious charge. We non-Zionists, too, have given and are giving constant attention and thought to Judaism and Jewish interests. If we have reached certain conclusions antagonistic to Zionistic contentions, you will grant, I hope, that these conclusions are based upon study and reflection as sincere as you claim for yourselves in your espousal of Zionism.

You are making an especial plea to Reform Rabbis in the interest of Zionism. As one who has given some study to the history and significance of the Reform movement, I can only say that, to my mind, Zionism is the antithesis to the very fundamentals of the reform movement in whose name you address us. What your understanding of the reform movement may be I know not. But if it be in a line with the interpretation of Judaism as set forth by the founders of our reform movement, Geiger and Holdheim, Wise and Einhorn and the others, then it passes my comprehension how you can square your Zionism with the prophetic universalism which is the very essence of our Reform movement. May I suggest, as you suggest to us, mereIy changing your words to suit the case that “I am confident that an unbiased study of what the Reform movement stands for may convince you of the incompatibility of politico-nationalistic Zionism with the fundamental teachings of the Reform movement.” I would not presume to make this suggestion had you not shown me the way by implying that we non-Zionists had jumped to our conclusions without sufhcient unbiased study of the subject in hand.

I can not but marvel as to what has led you to conduct this propaganda for Zionism among your colleagues. Is this a form of missionary activity? Are you looking upon us non-Zionists as needing conversion to Zionism to insure our salvation much as Christian missionaries look upon Jews? Your letter smacks somewhat of this. Can you not grant that we non-Zionists have as good ground for our interpretation of Judaism as you have for yours? Far would it have been from me to have addressed to Zionistic colleagues a letter similar in tone, appealing to their “sense of fair play” and bidding them devote “unbiased study” to

the antagonistic attitude of Reform Judaism to the theory of Zionism. I should have considered this entirely too presumptuous.

With best wishes for your welfare, I am, in the spirit of devotion to Judaism,

Sincerely yours,

DAVID PHILIPSON.

* * *

Not Hostile.

New York, N. Y., October 20, 1916. Gentlemen:

At present, I am not a member of any Zionist organization; although I have at various times, in the past, belonged and contributed to Zionist organizations both in South Bend and five years ago at Cambridge, England, during a short stay at the University.

I am not hostile to Zionism. Indeed I admire it. I look upon Dr. Herzl as one of the rare souls of Jewish History. The enthusiasm and idealism of my numerous Zionist friends is captivating.

My reason for not being actively engaged in the Zionist cause is the feeling that other fields of Judaism stand in greater need of cultivation. It is the behest of Religion, in the loftiest sense of the term, that the inner life of men be duly stressed. The extent of the human soul's independence of outward things and the paramount importance of inward qualifications are in our religious work, prone to overlook. Zionism, with all of its charm and even promise is yet a species of faith in the external term. There is no need to contest that particular kind of faith; there is however to call attention to the deeper verities.

Sympathetic though I am toward Zionism, I am therefore avoiding active and open afflliation with its propaganda.

In the person of our great leader, Dr. Stephen S. Wise, the Free Synagogue is obviously contributing a significant quota to the Zionist cause.

Trusting that this complies with the request in your letter,

I am

Most cordially,

ABRAHAM CRONBACH.

* * *

To the Contrary.

Houston, Texas, October 15, 1916.

Gentlemen:

As long as Judaism is not an integral’ plank in the Zionist platform, and its leaders—as in this city—are mainly “religionless” I cannot take any interest in it.

H. BARNSTEIN.

Eighty-three