The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIX, No. 4 · October 1916
50printed page
scan 2 of 26

THE MACCABAEAN

SIMON FRUG

THE Jewish world will have a long list of losses to review when this black war ends. Already the list includes Peretz and Sholom Aleichem, among the leading notables, and now the report comes of the death of Frug, the poet, who of all Yiddish poets strikes most clearly the simple note of the olden day, before Jews congregated in the Russian cities and created their economic parties, and began to ape the methods of foreign and often decadent literatures. Frug speaks for the town Jew, who is close to nature, to whom Succoth was not a jest, but a reality. He knows a great deal about the farm, about trees and birds, and does not hesitate to sing, although in forlorn tones, of the day when the Jew pressed the plow unto the yielding soil and felt himself part of God’s plan of life. Frug deals without reserve with the old symbols of Jewish poetry, calling upon the store of Jewish learning to give picturesqueness to his figures of speech. His success in Russian literature, which was considerable, aided him in his attempt to place Yiddish poetry upon a basis of originality and innate power, rather than as a dependent upon the forms and thought of other literatures. In the final summary of Jewish literature, the simplicity and clearness of Frug will place him high on the list of Jewish poets.

THE EASY CRITICS

WITH the growth of the American Zionist organization, large problems have arisen, which the officers have engaged with a devotion few people outside the inner circle appreciate. Intricate problems of finance, relief, organization, propaganda, come up daily for action, and decisions must be made with judgment of conditions that are constantly changing. Under the circumstances, mistakes are unavoidable, but no one who knows will charge responsible Zionist officers with neglecting to give to their task the best that is in them, sacrificing their time and strength to cope with the situation. Under the circumstances, also, there must be criticism; the movement is democratic and thrives on an intelligent discussion of all its problems. Some of the criticism is unworthy of the name because it is not open and above-board, being conducted anonymously, as if the critics were unwilling to take the full responsibility for what they are saying. Some of the criticism is clear and frank, and it is welcome. Such a criticism is that of the Rev. Joseph Friedlander, whose open letter to the Provisional Committee appeared in the “Jewish Exponent.” It is to be regretted that the letter appeared without at the same time giving an opportunity to answer the questions asked. It is also to be regreted that Dr. Friedlander did not inform himself in advance from the Zionist records on many of the points raised. Had he done so, more than half of his letter would have been unnecessary. As it is, Mr. de Haas’ letter gives in a clear form categorical replies to all the questions asked, justifying the policies of the Provisional Committee. These policies, once understood, will meet, we have no doubt, with the approval of all Zionists who appreciate the large responsibility assumed

by the American Zionist organization since the outbreak of war. We ask all our readers to study Mr. de Haas' letter, in order that they may the better understand the work the Provisional Committee is doing.

THE DISCARDED COMMISSION

Te commission that was to have gone to the occupied territories on behalf of the Joint Distribution Commitee did not succeed in having its passports vised. Word was received from Germany that inasmuch as Dr. Magnes was there, the commission was unnecessary, and action should be postponed until Dr. Magnes returned to New York. This was a practical refusal to allow the other members of the commission to enter Germany. It was said that this action was taken because all the members of the commission are natives of Russia, Dr. Magnes being the only American by birth. But the matter now scems to be clear. Allthe circumstances point to the miraculous agreement of events with the intentions of the American Jewish Relief Committee, against whose wishes the commission was appointed, and which has been opposed to severing relations with the German Hilfscomite. It seemed strange that Dr. Magnes should go alone in advance of the commission to Russia. It was also peculiar that when he reached Germany, he should have placed himself at once in touch with the officials of the Hilfsverein, and contrary to instructions, visit Warsaw and make recommendations to the Joint Distribution Committee. It seems also strange that together with his report there should come an urgent request for money from Max Warburg, which has been granted, when it was distinctly understood and agreed that under no circumstances should the German Hilfscomite receive additional moneys for the occupied territories. We are not inclined to attribute Machievellian talents to the Joint Distribution Committee, but nothing could have been more effectively arranged to suit its purposes than what has actually occurred in the European commission affair. The discarded commissioners and the organizations they represent are entitled to sympathy.

WHAT IS THE JOINT DISTRIBUTION COMMITTEE?

IT is through the Joint Distribution Committee that the American Jewish Relief Committee—in other words, the American Jewish Committee—hopes to obtain control over the relief activities of American Jewry by indirect methods, a control it could not obtain directly. First, the Central Relief Committee was invited to distribute its collections jointly with the American Jewish Relief Committee. But the Central Relief Committee was invited as a special partner. It was not given an equal voice on the Joint Distribution Committee. Later, when the People’s Relief Committee was formed, it was also invited to send three representatives. In this way the American Jewish Relief Committee obtained a deciding voice in the distribution of funds. At meetings of the Joint Distribution Committee, it was represented

by from six to nine members; the other committees combined had no more than six. Then the Joint Distribution Committee, which did not collect money at all, began to engage in the work of collecting funds. Joint appeals were issued. It was proposed to issue joint common receipts. A bulletin was published, and an executive secretary was engaged. Felix M. Warburg being treasurer of the American Jewish Relief Committee and chairman of the Joint Distribution Committee became, in effect, the head of the relicef work, although Mr. Warburg’s views on matters of distribution were diametrically opposed to the views of the People’s Relief Committee and the Central Relief Committee. The People’s Relief Committee and the Central Relief Committee are representative organizations; they have had conferences and conventions. The American Jewish Relief Committee was formed in the usual way at a conference, which, since September, 1914, has not been called together to review what has been done. It is far away from being representative of the organizations that participated in the Temple Emanu-El meeting. But through its control of the Joint Distribution Committee and by neglecting to report back to its constituents, it is now able to say that it is master of the relief situation. But that mastery cannot continue for long. When Dr. Magnes returns to New York, and reports—as it is predicted he will report—that monies to the occupied territories should go through the German Hilfscomite, there will be a readjustment which is bound to bring about a more responsible administration of the relief funds.

THE VOICE OF DR. NORDAU

D* NORDAU speaks with feeling, and yet there is a reassuring serenity in the latest article he has written on the Jewish situation. A great deal of what is being written nowadays is hysterical exaggeration and confused thinking. If one were to take it at its face value, one would have to conclude that the world —the Jewish world—has gone insanc. It is comforting to know that somewhere in the world Jews are thinking with ante-bellum clearness and equanimity. The world has treated the Jews with un- merited brutality especially since the war-cloud burst, but that is no excuse for us to lose our heads, and to indulge in exaggeration and hopeless wailing. Dr. Nordau does not whine, and while he protests, he thinks of the day after peace, and what we must at least appcar to be in the eyes of the world when an inventory is taken of the consequences of the conflict. Are we to wecp for the fallen? Arc we to shriek about the thousands wlo have given their lives for the various nations, serving in all armies, and dvire for all flags? Or are we to use the facts t"at so many have fallen, so many have been loyal and faithful, so many have been destroyed, to obtain recognition for the remnant left, and on the basis of service renderecd demand rights due? There is a point when excess of grief raises the inference of un- manliness.

The Reviewer
October, 1916