The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIX, No. 4 · October 1916
49printed page
scan 1 of 26
Facsimile · scan 1 of 26
Scan of p. 49
Text · transcribed from the scan

THE MACCABAEAN

DEVOTED TO ZIONISM AND ALL JEWISH INTERESTS

ESTABLISHED OCTOBER, 1901

VOLUME XXIX.

Published monthly by The Federation of American Zionists, a corporation under the laws of the State of New York, 44 East Twenty-third Street. Chairman of the Executive Committee, Louis Lipsky; Honorary Secretary, Bernard A. Rosenblatt; who may be addressed at 44 East Twenty-third Street. Cable address, Maccabaean, New York. Publication office, 44 East 23rd Street, New York. Entered at New York Post Office as Second Class Matter. Subscriptions for one year $1.00 payable in advance. All foreign countries, including Canada, $1.25. Single copies, ten cents.

Subscribers are advised to notify us at once of any change of address.

VIEWS AND COMMENTS

AN AMERICAN JEWISH CONGRESS IN SIGHT

IT IS fair to assume that the new peace agreement will be accepted by the delegates to the Philadelphia Conference. Strengthened by the returns on the first vote which rejected the peace agreement, the sub-committee of the Congress organization committee went into conference, determined not to accede the principles involved. They stood for placing a limitation upon the representation to be accorded the national organizations, and for such a phrasing of the clause regarding group or national rights as would not stultify the national elements participating in the Congress. They also insisted that constructive relief should not be excluded from the purview of the Congress. All three propositions the sub-committee of the Conference of National Organizations conceded. The national organizations will be given only twenty-five per cent. of the delegates to the Congress. The clause relating to national rights is so worded as to enable the Congress to take up all rights that may be asked for by the Jews in the lands affected; the obnoxious term, “group dights,” is eliminated. The committee of 140, which is to organize and call the Congress may, in its discretion, place the question of constructive relief on the agenda of the Congress. These three important points were conceded by Mr. Marshall’s committee. On the other hand, the permanence of the Congress, immigration, and the consideration of theoretical resolutions remain on the excluded list, and it will not be possible to bring them up except by unanimous consent. It is clear that the Congress committee has achieved a victory, which gives ground for the hope that the Congress may eventually become that for which all nationalists and Zionists have been striving for many years. In the meantime, however, the Congress to be held is a Congress for Jewish rights, full rights, plus construc-

tive relief, and all other questions are excluded. But as the education of our people continues, unanimity of sentiment will grow on the urgency of considering at the Congress a number of other questions that are now regarded as divisive. What has been achieved is all that could have been achieved, under the circumstances, without dividing American Jewry on the leading issues. It is hoped that the second referendum will be adopted as speedily as possible in order that the actual calling of the Congress may procced at once.

THE POALE ZION CONVENTION

THE Poale Zion convention is being held in Boston as we go to press. During the past year, this party in Zionism made gratifying progress in America, thanks to the energetic participation of its leaders in all Jewish movements arising out of the war, and thanks to the compactness of its organization. It has not yet succeeded in reaching the English-speaking Jews, and it will take a long time for it to do so, for the proportion of radicals among the English-speaking Jews is lower than among the Yiddish-speaking Jews, and the number of the former is much less. The Poale Zion make a great deal of capital out of their opposition to the anti-nationalist socialists, but it is a question whether they could not accomplish more by entering into the socialist ranks and fighting these forces from the inside, instead of from the outside. In the Congress movement the Poale Zion has been strong in their opposition to compromise, in theory, but in fact were the originators of most of the compromise ideas in the movement. They have altered their point of view a number of times, but while changing their methods they have held to their principles with zeal. In the relief work they have been working consistently with the People’s Relief Committee, in which they play an important part. They have not been as active for the Emergency Fund as was expected, but they proffer the excuse that they have been compelled to substantially aid all Poale Zion institutions as a result of the war, many of them located in Palestine. It is to be hoped that during the coming year they will be recalled to the duty which they owe to the Emergency Fund, and divert the attention of their workers to the direct Zionist work, which needs the co-operation of all Zionists capable of sacrifices. The Poale Zion have a great capacity for sacrifices, which should now be placed in immediate Zionist service.

CONTENTS

VIEWS AND COMMENTS49
Schaffer51
THE WHITE LILY, By M. Bernstein and N. Straus55
"ZIONISM AND THE JEWISH FUTURE," By Lord Cromer57
Jacob de Haas59
M. Raskin62
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR63
PALESTINE, By Israel Belkind64
THE ZIONIST MOVEMENT66
WHERE AND WHOM TO JOIN72

October, 1916

Forty-nine