The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIX, No. 4 · October 1916
60printed page
scan 12 of 26
Facsimile · scan 12 of 26
Scan of p. 60
Text · transcribed from the scan

The Ohio Bureau has raised within two months as much as the State of Ohio raised for Zionist purposes in the previous year. We anticipate at least as good results from San Francisco; and the Order Knights of Zion, the Order Sons of Zion, have each, through our method of operation, raised five and six times the amount of the subsidies involved; so that from the point of view of economy, and of results, this policy has effected just what it should effect. The next question that can properly arise is, is this expenditure on American organization and administration successful? though it be disproportionate to the amounts provided for Palestine and other Zionist obligations. We have spent in the United States, briefly, $85,534.41, as against the total receipts, exclusive of transfer items, $356,940.72, so that the cost of operation is not over 25 per cent., but the same expense bill includes the cost of our Transfer Department, which raised for Palestine and for Europe $600,000.00 so that the working cost of our operation for the Transfer Department and the Emergency Fund, and all that which in the opinion of your correspondent cries to heaven for redress, is roughly equal to about 8 per cent., a sum which anyone who has knowledge of the workings of any institution, or one who merely takes into account the work and complicated character of the operation which we are carrying out efficiently, would not regard as extravagant. We are very proud of the Transfer Department. It has provided $600,000 worth of self-help and has enabled 60,000 people to locate each other; and instead of doing $600,000 worth of charity, which in all probability compared with the expenditure account of relief campaigns, would be more costly. It is perfectly true that we are proud that the Transfer Department does not represent charity. We enable anyone in this country, at our cost, to help their kindred abroad; and whereas we would have been overwhelmed with the task of supplying Palestine with immense relief funds out of the Zionist resources, we have actually, throughout this war, managed through this medium and independent of what our Organization is giving the schools and other organizations we support, and the actual relief funds that we have helped to provide, and which through our pressure have provided; and independent of large loans that we have been creating for the advantage of Palestine, we have managed, as a measure of self-help, to transmit to Palestine $1,000 a day for every working day for two years. We have made no charge for this, as we have made no charge for the European Transfer Account, because we feel that this is exactly the kind of thing that the Zionist Movement, as a Movement embodying the principle of self-help, should do when it engages upon benevolence. The Transfer Department, both in Palestine and in Europe (we have now extended it to Roumania and we operate in Galicia, Egypt, Russia, and Occupied Territories, etc.), has been successful because of the enormous care and patience and attention we exercise in carrying on the operation. We roughly estimated on June 30th that during the past year we have used one million sheets of paper, letter size, in connection with our various departments, independent of circulars and printed matter. Our Transfer Department makes fifteen entries for each item received, recording the receipt, forwarding the confirmation, the advice to the sender, and the surrender of the receipt originally signed by the payee to the sender. In addition to the correspondence involved in each item, we have in this way been warranted in the confidence placed in us not only by Jews, but by non-Jews, Arabs and Syrians, by large corporations having probably as good a service as the United States Government itself; and individual remitters have been referred to us by the United States Post Office because we found means of regular communication with the Orient, when all regular postal facilities had broken down. The result is that for each item transmitted we eventually give the remitter the receipt of the individual to whom he has sent the money; and this is no simple task. Take into consideration the fact that money is sent to persons in Jerusalem who are eventually found and paid in Egypt, or sent to persons presumed to be in some town in the Occupied Territories or in Galicia, and the receipt, when it reaches us, comes from some obscure town in Siberia, countersigned by the local official. All this means labor, and in order to do this and all our other work (and we have a very high regard for economy in every detail) we have found it necessary to occupy five thousand feet of floor space, paying $4,500 a year rent, and to employ about fifty persons in our offices. We are not parading the fact because we regard it all as part of the day’s work that we have helped to discover sixty thousand families in this country, relatives of those abroad; and that we are now moved by the same motive of self-help, and, without blare of trumpet, to locate, through specially appointed committees, relatives in Europe for those here seeking their whereabouts. Our operations extend practically all over the globe. We are acting for Jews in Australia, New Zealand, Argentine, Brazil, Canada, England, Chile, South Africa, China, Panama, Russia. We are the means of corresponding, via New York, between one part of Palestine and the other. We are the connecting link between Russia and Egypt, and we are performing all these tasks as agents, as propagandists, as organizers, as developers building the Zionist Movement at one end, in America, and stabilizing the position of the Jews in Palestine at the other, at a cost of 8 per cent. of the amount of moneys we are handling. Or, to give your correspondent all that he wishes, we are doing all this at the cost of, say, 25 per cent. of the moneys deliberately raised for relief and organization. Now, as to the nature of our appeal. Your correspondent infers that we have misled the public, and that we have asked the public to give for one purpose and are using the money for another. This is categorically untrue. As Zionists we have nowhere appealed to the spirit of pity. We have always appealed to the sense of duty. During the first year we raised a good deal of money by verbal propaganda and our messages to the public were messages of hope. The question of feeding the hungry did not even arise during the first few months of the war. It was a question of maintaining the Zionist institutions and organization, and every one of our receipts has at all times made it clear that we are not asking for charity, but that we are asking for the Zionist institutions and the Zionist Organization, and that through these we are doing real constructive work in Palestine while we help to maintain the people whose sufferings are so real as not to stand in need of the rhetorical flourishes indulged in by your correspondent as a means of assault upon our organization. This is a very brief account of our work and the underlying policy which was developed by the Provisional Committee and which has been carried out in its details by office committees which meet two or three times a week, and which has been sanctioned by the Boston and Philadelphia Conventions, and which has met with the most unqualified praise from the Inner Actions Committee, the Greater Actions Committee and from every Zionist Organization in the world. We now proceed to discuss in detail the various questions which the Reverend Mr. Friedlander has put to our Accountant Department. He queries the system of the record published in the July Maccabaean, ignorant, probably, of the fact that even in the system of accounting we attempt to attain the highest efficiency, and that the record published is in character similar to that used by the Interstate Commerce Commission in its reports. 1) Q.—“What were the total receipts of the Provisional Committee for that period (June 30, 1915, to June 19, 1916), ex-cluding ‘Transfer’ items? I wish to exclude ‘Transfer’ items in order to get at the operations of the Committee itself, exclusive of its activities on behalf of individuals. This is a separate matter and should have a separate accounting. I will speak of it later.” A.—A simple calculation of the figures appearing on page 169 of The Maccabaean for July, 1916, will answer this question readily: Total receipts ..............$791,971.65 Deduct receipts of the Transfer Account .............. 435,030.93 Answer to Q. No. 1: Total receipts of the Provisional Committee for the period from June 30, 1915, to June 19, 1916, excluding Transfer items ...........$356,940.72 This item includes $46,156.43, representing loans and pending items. These pending items are received for various purposes which at the time of receipt by us are not clearly earmarked by the transmitter. We therefore carry such items in our pending account until we have ascertained exactly to what purpose the money is to be applied. We have had as much as a single item of $10,000 received by us from four to six weeks ahead of the notification of the Sixty October, 1916