The Maccabaean · Vol. XXIX, No. 3 · September 1916
26printed page
scan 2 of 26

THE MACCABAEAN

the peace agreement. The Zionist organization sent out a referendum to all affiliated societies. It may be said that not less than 100,000 Jews participated, directly or indirectly, in the formation of the opinion expressed on the peace agreement. Involved in this vote were a number of issues: National or group rights, a free or limited Congress, democracy, direct representation, the permanence of the Congress, constructive relief and immigration. For the first time in our history Jews were asked to declare themselves publicly on questions that involve the future of Jewish life. Certainly the discussion, the propaganda in the press, the mass meetings, clarified the ideas of thousands of Jews. The Congress movement has been the most effective educational undertaking in our generation.

The "Terrible Infant"

A word is due the part played by the Poale Zion in the Congress movement, and especially in connection with the rejection of the peace agreement. Our friends in that party, the “infants ter- ribles,” have been the stalwart guardians of all things radical in the Congress movement. They have declared for principles time and again, and just at the moment of victory they weaken on their principles and become the advocates of sompromise. They lack the power of sensing a victory. For example: They were in favor of an open program, free and unlimited. But when it seemed that a large body of Jewish opinion could be secured for an open program they insisted that the Congress must, specifical- Iy, include a clause about the Jewish homeland in Palestine. That was their constitutional prohibition. They favored an open program, but unless they were guaränteed that Palestine as a homeland would be unconditionally brought up, they would raise a rumpus. Then, when they encountered the radical workingmen, they compromised on the homeland proposition, and accepted instead an incoherent statement about national institutions and were satisfied with it, forgetting that at the same time they had agreed toa Congress exclusively for Jewish rights. With that compromise they came to the Congress Committee and, aided by Pincus Rutenberg, insisted that it be accepted verbatim. When the Congress Committee accepted the compromise, not in its entirety, but in principle, and they saw that the National Workmen’s Committee, in spite of that, refused to amalgamate with the Congress Committee, there were many Poale Zionists who were of the opinion that there could be two co-ordinate Congress Committees co-operating; there were others, however, who insisted that the National Workmen’s Committee had broken faith. The latter seceded from the Workmen’s Committee and began a terrifving campaign to force the Congress Committee to call the preliminary conference. Rııtenberg went West and persuaded the Middle Western Committee to issue an ultimatum that unless the preliminary

conference was called at once they themselves would call such a conference. When the Congress Committee called the preliminary conference these same men urged that something be done to bring in the opposing elements, and on the day when the Philadelphia conference was convened Rutenberg came with a compromise, not with the National Workmen’s Committee, but with the American Jewish Committee! This compromise of Rutenberg’s was rejected by the Poale Zion, but after the Philadelphia conference many of them insisted that negotiations with the American Jewish Committee must be continued. When an invitation was received from the Hotel Astor Conference to send a committee there, they favored it, although it was a foregone conclusion that if such a committee were sent some peace compromise was inevitable.. When the Hotel Astor Conference invited the Congress Committee to appoint peace commissioners the Poale Zion did not object. When the peace commissioners reported the Poale Zion did not raise any of the points they raised later on; they had nothing to say about group rights, they wanted constructive relief; they had nothing to say about the permanence of the Congress, they did not want national organizations represented by more than one-fourth of the delegates. They did not appear when the peace agreement was accepted by the Congress Committee. But when the Congress Committee referred the peace agreement to the delegates to the PhiladIphia Conference they at once decided, through their CK, that the peace agreement must be rejected. Now that the peace agreement is rejected, we expect to find the Poale Zion agitating that further negotiations be begun, in order that something may be set up which they may arain attack.

They Forgot a Trifle

Their trunks are packed. but they have no passports. That is, they have passports, but Mr. Felix M. Warburg forgot to get them vised by the German Government. And thus it is that Messrs. Abel, Abramowitz, Billikopf, Bogin and Panken are cooling their heels in the vieinity of Hoboken; they do not know whether they are here—in the Land of the Free—or there, on the broad ocean looking toward the occunied territories. These passports were a trivial matter. It did not enter Mr. Warburg's mind to inquire about them until a few days before the commission was to have sailed. During all this time the commissioners were going through the horrible experiences of the banqueted. Rabbi Abramowitz was banqueted by his orthodox friends, who said farewell to him with feeling. Mr. Panken was given a series of ban- auets that impaired his otherwise good digestion, by trades unions, by the “honorable” Forwards Associations and others. Mr. Abel, a modest man, modestly and quietly was given a farewell in a restaurant by his closest friends. They were readv to go, but Mr. Warburg forgot

that you must have a passport vised before it is really a valid and useful document. Mr. Warburg’s earnest desire that the commission proceed to Berlin to assist Dr. Magnes in his arduous labors is indicated by his efficient handling of the passport incident.

The Emergency Fund

The budget of the Provisional Zionist Committee for this year has been compiled. It shows that not less than $240,- 000 will be required to meet all its obligations; what it has undertaken to contribute to Palestine, what it will give for the maintenance of the international organization and what it will require to carry on Zionist work in this country and to make possible the collection of the sum needed. This is a large undertaking, practically a doubling of last year’s budget. It means that the Zionists will have to increase their efficiency, enlarge their organization. It is surprising how few Zionists, active on behalf of the Emergency Fund, understand what that Fund is designed to do. They think that the Emergency Fund aims merely to send money to Palestine. They forget that the Emergency Fund has been used not only to maintain life, but also to make that life self-supporting, or, at least, make it contributory to its own support. The term constructive relief has been brought into Jewish life by the Provisional Committee. And not only is it necessary that money for relief be sent to Palestine; the committee has, by acting as transmitting agent, sent into Palestine during the past year about half a million dollars, sent by individuals to friends and relatives, thus in a natural way bringing new life into Palestine. All this work has been done at the expense of the Emergency Fund. Furthermore, in order that these large sums may get into Palestine safely it has been necessary to keep the channel clear of obstructions; this involved the maintenance of an agency in Constantinople and other expenses in belligerent countries. And if the Zionist organization is to maintain its position and exercise its influence in Jewish life, which reacts upon the collections, the organization must also be maintained without any diminution of its powers. This means that wherever necessary our influence must be strengthened, our organs of public agitation must be supported and everything that tends to make Zionism a power must, for the sake of the immediate results as well as for the permanent effect, receive some attention from the Provisional Committee. All this means a complicated, and not simple operation. By disseminating correct information Zion'sts will be doing a great service to the Emergency Fund. Knowledge of what we are doing is bound to bring support. We hope that Zionists will at once begin their work for the year, and that as the first step they acquaint themselves with the things done by the Emergency Fund for the maintenance of the Zionist position.

The Reviewer September, 1916