THE MACCABAEAN
rulers, and all of them turning, as they dream, their faces to the East, with the question whether from Armageddon will come the restoration of Zion.
This chance companion of a journey came back to our memory as we read Mr. Zangwill’s “The War for the World” (Heinemann). T'here is the same piquancy that comes from divided sympathies, the same mingling of an ardent English patriotism with a much less correct attitude towards the Eastern Ally, and all the while the wistful, restless glance goes roving across the horrors of the conflict to a Land of Promise. The patriotism of the Jew of the last generation towards the land of his adoption was as conventional as it was sincere, and it tended towards an artistic emphasis and exaggeration of the national traits. In London it roared in the persons of the young lions of the “Daily Telegram,” while in Cologne it growled with the ultraBismarckian roughness of the “Gazette.” It gave us the splendors of Disraelian Imperialism, while in France it posed in the royalism of the “Gaulois,” and postured in Hungary as the extravagant Magyarism of the “Pester Lloyd.” Always a little more royalist than the king, it wore the protective coloring that fitted its environment. It assimilated without criticism, ahıd with all its service it gave nothing of its own. That average clever Jew is with us still, and he has written on both sides in this world-war a big fraction of its polemical literature. It is only the Jew of genius who dares to select and to love his adopted land for her better self. He will turn his remorseless wit upon her. He will idealize her to-day and satirize her to-morrow, but he alone brings an acceptable gift to the altar, for he alone, through all the follies and infidelities of the day, has seen and embraced the spirit of his foster-mother. To whom do we owe the lurking fondness which most of us would admit for the Germany of the pre-Bismarckian period? It is proper to talk of Kant and Goethe and Beethoven. But we suspect that it was really from the quips and jests, the sentiment and the home-sickness, of the exile Heine that most of us formed our mental picture of romantic Germany. The first Jew in European literature who dared to be himself, he discovered the idea of Germany where others had onlv tried to be Germans.
Mr. Zangwill in this provoking and stimulating book has performed in his own more serious way a like service to England. “Serious” may seem an odd word, for his pages glitter with jests and epigrams, with inversions and parodies, with puns good, bad, and indifferent, but with it all, he feels where Heine only sentimentalized. He is a decided partisan of the Entente, an excellent patriot, and an almost conventional critic of the German State-idea. But his peculiar function is to hold up to the England of war-time, the England of compulsory service and the Defence of the Realm Act, the ideal England of the ancient liberties. It is done with a sharpness of perception which no prophet of English race could quite achieve, for it is done with cosmopolitan insight and hereditary experience. The Pale lies behind it, and there rings in it the penetration of a people which cannot take its liberties for granted. There is more in this attitude, however, than a patriot’s distress. Amid a civilization rent by the extravagance of its national passions, this spokesman of a race to which fate has denied nationalitv. returns passionately to his cosmopolitan and
pacifist ideal. The first Pacifist was a Jew, and to Mr. Zangwill it never even occurs that Christianity may be the dogma of the Trinity or the mystery of the Eucharist. For him it is simply love, and, as Tolstoy saw it, non-resistance.
The Jewish race, if it dared to be itself, was made to understand and preach the nullity of force. Like women, it has this instinctive perception, for, like women, it cannot exercise force. But it requires genius to be oneself, and it is the exceptional Jew, as it is the exceptional woman, who has the intellectual courage to pıeach to an unbelieving world the vanity of force. Lessing thought that the mission of the Jew was to teach tolerance to the World. Mr. Zangwill hints at an even loftier task—its conversion from its destructive nationalism. But the average Jew is proud to command himself by his prowess in either army, and woman, to borrow his jest, seems likely to step from the munition factory to the vote, like “Venus rising from her shell.” "The hardest of all tasks is to be oneself.
The truth is that the world is so complex that even the Jew of genius cannot be consistently himself. Mr. Zangwill, though his "spiritual home" is England, has written in "The Melting Pot" the statement of a purely cosmopolitan ideal. It meant, if we understand it, the denial of any narrow racial or national ambition, and the adoption of a merely human democracy as a sufficient and wholly inspiring ideal. But the dramatist who has given to this conception a great and passionate expression (and it recurs in these essays) is also the Moses who sought a promised land for his persecuted race, not in the States where its identity is lost, but somewhere (under the British flag for choice) with a guaranteed autonomy in Africa. His vision in this book sweeps back to Palestine, like that of more orthodox Zionists, whose position is stated in Mr. Sacher's instructive "Zionism and the Jewish Future." (See Book Review, page 38. Editor.) He also suggests —a suggestion which might well turn out to be practical—a return to Babylonia.
But the Jewish problem, though it may be eased by migration, cannot be solved by it. There are some grim chapters in this book on the sufferings during this war of the Jews in Poland and Russia. It is folly for the Censor to conceal in England what is proclaimed by every printing press in neutral and enemy countries. The normal sufferings of the Jews in Russia have been heightened by the war, and by the "pogroms" and persecutions that have flourished in war, and the Alliance has done nothing to relieve them. If Germany has ruined such case as she had by her barbarities at sea, the moral standing of the Entente has been jeopardized by these anti-Jewish excesses. We have saved Russian financial credit: we should have done even better if, by frank unofficial speech and official remonstrance, we had helped her Liberals to save her moral repute. For our part, we hope that this war may realize the Zionist dream, and that Palestine may become the cultural centre of Judaism, a free State which will focus the aspirations of a dispersed race. But the doctrine of nationalities must mean more to us than a rule to be imposed upon the other side. If our own credit demands that we complete the liberation of Ireland before the war is ended, the credit of the Entente exacts an equality of rights for the Russian Jew.