at this time and that a committee of three be appointed to receive further nominations from the floor to report at the convention session all names regularly nominated from the floor and by the nominations committee. With your consent I shall appoint on that committee Mr. Avner, Dr. de Sola Pool and Mr. Sachs.
Unanimous consent given.
The convention adjourned until three in the afternoon.
WEDNESDAY AFTERNOON SESSION
The Convention re-convened at three o’clock in the afternoon at the Hotel Walton, Louis Lipsky presiding.
Mr. Neumann, of New York, was recognized to report for the special committee on Hebrew publications, which had been sent out in the morning to bring in recommendations bearing upon Hebrew periodicals.
Mr. Neumann, of New York: Our committee reports as follows: “The Convention recommends to the Zionists of America to buy shares of, secure subscriptions for, and support in every other way the Hebrew periodical ‘“Hatoren,' whose publication has been possible through the active work of the constituent members and executive members of the Federation of American Zionists. The Convention further recommends to the Zionists of America as worthy of support the ‘Haibri’ a Hebrew periodical devoted to the interests of the Mizrachi Movement.”
The resolution was unanimously adopted.
Mr. Brodie, of Baltimore, continued his report in behalf of the General Resolutions Committee:
I. Resolved, that the Federation of American Zionists ask the members of the constituent organizations and affiliated societies to assume a per capita tax of ten cents per annum for the benefit of Young Judaea.
Mr. Baron, of St. Louis: I am utterly opposed to a resolution being passed by this Convention unless it has for its purpose to bind the Zionists by resolution to bring about the result intended. It is encouraging a lack of discipline in the ranks of the Zionist organization to pass resolutions and leave them to the will of individuals or organizations to carry out. I want to see a resolution, whether it be for Young Judaea or any other purpose, express that we here bind the organizations to do thus and so. It is a waste of time to come here with a proposition “If you want to do so, do so.” For that reason, I believe that this resolution should be defeated.
Mr. Brodie: In explanation of the attitude of the General Resolutions Committee, I want to say that when I read a resolution, it does not mean that the committee recommends it, unless the resolution expressly says that the committee adopted it.
Mir. Schneeberg, of New York: I will explain to you the desire of Young Judaea not to go to individual societies and ask them for contributions to Young Judaea work. We feel that it would be better to go to individual Zionists and ask them to make donations. We feel that Young Judaea should not be placed in a position to feel it needs its entire support of the Federation. In this manner, a system will be formed of putting Young Judaea on an independent financial basis. This resolution was passed at the last Convention, but not carried out, due to the request of the executive committee of the Federation.
Mr. Kesselman, of New York: Mr. Schneeberg seems to agree with what I am about to say. Young Judaea, as any other organizations must be made self-supporting but not by means of contributions, donations, etc. If it is to be self-supporting, it is to be so by members of Y. J. And while those members may not be in a position to contribute the entire budget of the organization, it is the duty of the F. A. Z. to support it from its means and not first to give it a subvention and then permit collections, etc. I understand there is a plan to make the members of Y. J. pay dues to the parent organization, and that will be better than a resolution submitted. I feel that we can table the resolution without damage to the Federation, Zionism or Y. J.
Dr. Pool, of New York: Mr. Baron, who is opposing the motion took the ground that this calls for a voluntary tax and is therefore useless. We feel in bringing in this resolution that it at least has a moral value and that this moral value is perhaps more valuable than the income of the tax. Young Judaea cannot be self-supporting and the suggestion that Y. J. members pay further dues is a suggestion impossible to carry out. Members do pay dues. We feel that by the adoption of this resolution the Federation will be the gainer financially because the F. A. Z. subsidy will not cover all Y. J.’s needs and anything that can be gained in money will aid the F. A. Z.
A motion was made, seconded and carried to table this resolution.
Mr. Brodie: Resolution II. Resolved, that lecturers, speakers and propagandists of the F. A. Z. and its constituent organizations be instructed to organize and get into touch with Y. J. groups in the centers they visit.
Motion adopted.
Mr. Schneeberg called for a resolution submitted to the resolutions committee, but not reported. The resolution reads as follows:
III. Resolved, that in recognition of the work and growth of Y. J., it be recognized as an organization subordinate to the F. A. Z. This, however, shall not be construed as entitling Y. J. to greater representation to the F. A. Z. than it now possesses.
This motion was not considered, on a vote of 20 for taking the matter up; and 45 against taking it up.
Mr. Brodie: IV. Resolved, that this Convention recommend to the Congress Organization Committee the publication of all the correspondence which had passed between the Congress Organization Committee and other organizations concerning the Congress question.
Mr. Schechter, of New York: Does this mean communications from officers of other organizations? For instance, yesterday some letters were read from Mr. Schiff, etc. Does this include the letter to Mr. Schiff?
The Chairman: This refers to official correspondence only.
Mr. Schechter: Is Mr. Oscar Straus' letter official correspondence?
The Chairman: No.
Dr. Pool, of New York: I oppose the motion because we have not yet reached any haven in this long journey to the Congress. This is no particular time to publish the correspondence. The recommendation is therefore practically valueless, unless you reword it to the effect that when negotiations are finished this should be done. But at this time it will leave no impression with anyone.
The Chairman: This is only a recommendation to the Congress Committee to do so at any time it may think it necessary.
"Mr. Baron, of St. Louis: I amend the motion to include, at the appropriate time."
A motion was made, seconded and carried that the debate on this question be closed.
The resolution was carried with the amendment.
Mr. Brodie: V. The F. A. Z. in convention assembled at Philadelphia, on July 4th, 1916, hereby publicly records its appreciation and gratitude to William C. Hornblower, Director of Refugees and Encampments in Alexandria, Egypt, for the devoted and effective services which he rendered to Palestinian Jewish refugees.
Motion unanimously adopted.
The business of the meeting was here interrupted to allow Dr. Schmarya Levin to speak to the Convention, before leaving on urgent personal business.
Dr. Levin: The seed of Zionism was planted in America only three years ago. At first there was only the trunk, but there were no strong roots and no branches. The second years the tree looked very pretty, and we were amazed. It was covered with branches, but the roots were rather weak. The tree grew rapidly and now there is not only Zionism above, but also strong roots. I have spoken regarding it often. It is the yearning of the people toward God. I do not believe in accident. The great moment has come. We have a leader who can lead us. At this Convention we have had no large dem-
