would wait to take any move, in the hope that some efforts would be made to effect a system of co-operation.
I ask you to be something better than Congressionists. I want you to be Zionists and to stand for peace. The Congress Committee has appointed a committee of three: Judges Brandeis, Pam and Sanders to see what further can be done. Will it not be in line not only with the true ideal of Zionism—peace—but with the instructions of Dr. Herzl that American Zionism must do the most to save the situation—will it not be in accord with peace if we appoint a committee of three to co-operate with Judge Brandeis?
The Chairman: This matter is not up for action on the part of this convention at this time, Mr. Richards is to be given the floor merely for the purpose of bringing the facts before the convention. Dr. Mendes is too well-informed to need to be reminded that when the Jewish Congress Committee elects representatives, two-thirds of whom are Zionists, it would be improper on our part to appoint another committee to assist its committee. The future of the Jewish Congress Movement is in the hands of the Jewish Congress Committee, of which we are integral factors; a number of our Zionists are officers there and they have been elected to present our views to the American Jewish Committee conference. It would be superfluous on our part to appoint another committee.
Mr. Richards: I desire mainly to state a number of facts relating to our efforts to secure the co-operation of all groups in the convening of the Congress. I believe it was the intention to present these facts to you yesterday, but some important data was crowded out from the discussion.
The facts which I want to present to you have to do with the negotiations with the American Jewish Committee and with the National Workmen's Committee, which we carried on for many months in an effort to secure their co-operation. They are stated fully in a letter which I sent to the President of the Federation, Dr. Harry Friedenwald, on April 5, 1916.
The "breach of faith" with which Mr. Marshall and Dr. Magnes have charged the Jewish Congress Organization Committee consists of the various attempts and efforts which this Committee made to meet the wishes of the American Jewish Committee: of yielding on a number of points, of making different concessions and of losing months and months of valuable time in an effort to win the support of the group of men associated with that committee. We had given every possible consideration to these men and lost so much time in negotiations, that if we had gone on any further, we would really have been guilty of bad faith and disloyalty, not to the American Jewish Committee, but to the various constituent national and central organizations and Jewish Congress Committees everywhere.
De A 2 u A ihr - Det A Dir Be at re ee eh a «A A I will not go so far back as the time of the last Kehillah Conventions in April and May of 1915, to which the advocates of the Jewish Congress first addressed themselves in an effort to win the support of the American Jewish Committee. It is a humiliating story of how representatives of various organizations of New York pleaded with the guiding spirits of the Kehillah and the American Jewish Committee to take the lead in bringing about united action on the part of the whole American Jewry on a democratic basis to meet the great crisis created by the war. The men of the American Jewish Committee who helped to work out and accepted the compromise resolution adopted at the special Convention of the Kehillah on May 23rd, gave every promise that a Conference would be called on a comprehensive and democratic basis to deal with the Jewish situation in Europe. The plan ‚of the secret and limited Lonference subsequently promulgated showed how the American Jewish Committee kept faith with the Jews of New York.
In the interests of harmony, we accepted the program of the National Workmen's Committee as a basis of discussion at the Preliminary Conference which was then proposed, and, in interests of unity, we also agreed to enter into negotiations with the American Jewish Committee at a time when it was still unequivocally opposed to the holding of a Congress. The Congress movement having been in process of formation for about one year and having assumed definite proportions on October 12, 1915, we decided upon the holding of a Preliminary Conference. The Conference was to be
held on November 28th. But owing to the new negotiations, which had been begun, we again postponed the Conference for a future date with the hope of having the American Jewish Committee and the National Workmen's Committee co-operate with us in the calling of the same. You will please bear in mind that in spite of the insistance of our constituent organizations upon the calling of a Conference, the Conference, finally decided upon February 7th, was not actually called until February 27, 1916. It was, as we know, held on March 26th and 27th.
The sub-committee of the Jewish Congress Organization Committee met in conference with the representatives of the American Jewish Committee and the National Workmen’s Committee on November ı2th, December ıgth, 1915, and January Ioth and 23rd, 1916. At these conferences, our representatives made every effort to induce the American Jewish Committee and the National Workmen’'s Committee to join in the calling of a Preliminary Conference to present their respective propositions as to time, place and program of the Congress, to a full discussion of the Preliminary Conference and to submit these matters to the decision of the Conference. n
In as well as outside of the conferences, representatives of the Jewish Congress Organization Committee pleaded with the American Jewish Committee to present its reasons and arguments fully and freely before the Preliminary Conference as to why the Congress should-not be held until after the cessation of hostilities. On various occasions, supporters of the Congress pleaded with members of the American Jewish Committee to show its confidence in the people and in the judgment of the elected delegates from Jewish organizations by submitting the matter of the date of the Congress to the Preliminary Conference. We contended all along that to allow any one organization to decide in advance of a properly constituted and authorized conference on such an important matter as the date of the Congress, was a complete violation of the principle of democracy which was the chief justification and inspiration of the Congress movement.
No progress was made at any of the conferences held of the three sub-committees and at the conference of December ıgth, Mr. Cyrus L. Sulzberger in reply to a direct question, adımitted that the decision of the A. J. C. of November 14th was practically a “constitutional prohibition” and that he saw no way by which the Executive Committee of his organization could deviate from the position taken by the annual meeting. The Jewish Congress Organization Committee had made a number of concessions and among other propositions, suggested that the date of the Congress be left to the decision of an Executive Committee to be elected by a Preliminary Conference.
This proposition was not in harmony with the underlying democratic principle of the Congress movement. Nevertheless in interests of peace, we made this proposition. The American Jewish Committee did not recede in the least from its original proposition. The National Workmen’s Committee made matters more complicated by a secret decision to side with the American Jewish Committee. It became very clear to all that further negotiations were futile and the Congress movement was threatened with disruption by the long delay and inactivity occasioned by these negotiations. Yet, when at the time of the last conference on January 23rd, our sub-committee was asked to appear again before a full meeting of the Executive Committee of the American Jewish Committee, we consented to do so. We were, however, nevr informed of any meeting of the Executive Committee of the American Jewish Committee, at which our sub-committee was to appear. We heard nothing more from the American Jewish Committee and on February 7th, we decided upon our Preliminary Conference. The American Jew- -ish Committee was notified that we regarded further negotiations as futile and that we intended to proceed with the calling of a Preliminary Conference, in our letter of December 28, 1915. In this letter we invited the American Jewish Committee and the National Workmen’s Committee to join us in the calling of a Preliminary Conference at which all matters relating to the Congress should be decided by a vote of the delegates. I want especially to call your attention to this letter because of the various charges that had been made to the effect that we called our Preliminary Con-