which the Congress Movement was based, and that is, that every Jew shall have a right to voice his opinion as to the destiny of the Jewish People. I say that it is not worth while having peace unless we have a peace with honor, and we have fought out that question. In the very beginning there were people who came to us and told us the same thing. “For God’s sake, you are breaking up Israel! Let us have peace!” And if we would have been weak-kneed and given in at that time and not fought out this principle of democracy, there would not have been a Congress Movement that was worth while having. We fought out this first princple, that a Congress must be held on a democratic basis, and those who were opposed to the Congress Movement reluctantly gave into us, because they knew that we were right and had the courage to stand by our convictions. And the next question was also a fundamental one: whether the people who were opposed to the American Jewish Congress, people in the American Jewish Committee and outside of it, did they have a right to dictate to those who wanted to participate in the Congress, when it should be held, and under what circumstances.
I would not insult the intelligence of the Inner Actions Committee, to place upon it the interpretation which Dr. Solis-Cohen places upon their letter. He says the Inner Actions Committee has given a privilege to the Zionist Movement to participate in the American Jewish Congress, which shall make all parties agree. Does Dr. Solis-Cohen think for a moment that the Inner Actions Committee wants us to have peace with those who want us to surrender our Zionism? The Inner Actions Committee has given us the privilege and God speed in the work of making all parties in Israel agree, and if we cannot do it with honor, let us have a democratic Congress that shall give a right to the voice of the Tewish People t0 be heard.
The Chairman: I shall ask the indulgence of the convention for a Zionist who has in years past been active in the movement in England, but who is not a delegate.
pe er re er ee Br en - Se EN nen FE en en Ad N A er - nnd vi Dr. Joseph Friedlander, of New York: I believe a good deal irrelavent matter has been introduced by the various speakers. I want to tell you that I am a strong opponent of the Congress idea, and I speak with some knowledge of European conditions and statesmanship. Why have you thrown this apple of discord into the middle of American Jewry when there was no necessity for it? Do you understand what the aim of the Congress is? It is evidently to elect representatives, to send delegates to a peace Congress that will never be held. I do not believe that there will be a peace Congress. If you wish to have a voice in the future destiny of the Jewish People, it is not necessary for you to join the ranks of any ordinary federation society. This is not a way of trying to bully-rag the American Jewish Committee into trying to take your views. The American Jewish Committee is established for years and represents I4o organizations. I do not know what you are fighting for. I read in this morning’s papers that Dr. Levin declared last night that we are to fight the American Jewish Committee to the bitter end. Dr. Levin is here as an Ambassador, and he ought to know that it is not his duty to interfere in domestic affairs.
Owing to the many applications for the privilege of having the floor, the Chairman asked unanimous consent that the remaining time be given only to those speaking against the Congress Movement, which was done.
Dr. D. de Sola Pool, of New York: Although I said that I was opposed to the motion, as I am, I am not opposed to the Congress Movement. There is, so far as I know, only one speaker here opposed to the Congress Movement, and that is the speaker who preceded me. Mr. Schechter and Mr. Leon Kohn who represent the amendment, are for a Congress. Their only question is a method of working towards that end. I am for a Congress, but I believe that this whole issue has been confused, and that it can be readily split in view of this resolution of the Actions Committee. The Actions Committee is the supreme body in Zionist life. We are responsible to it. We are bound by its expressions of policy. That being so, there is no room for further discussion. The Congress Committee is not our superior in the sense that the Actions Committee is, and according to the exact and literal wording of their resolution, we must
act, so long as we have a sense of discipline within the International Zionist Organization, and I would therefore ask, whether such a resolution as this would satisfy you, instead of the two others:
“Whereas, the Zionist Actions Committee hails with great satisfaction the efforts of the Jewish Organizations of the United States to create a legitimate, democratically chosen representative body of American Jewry in order to secure at the peace conference the vital demands of the Jewish People for civil and national rights in all lands where these are denied to the Jews, as well as for freedom to enter and settle in Palestine and all lands of Jewish immigration, and whereas the I. A. C. (and mind you, I am reading their resolution) is authorized to support vigorously the executive body to be elected by the American Jewish Congress in its efforts to reach an understanding with all parties and organizations of the Jews of all lands which are willing to support the movement to secure equal civil and national rights for the Jews,
Be it resolved, that the Federation of American Zionists, through its constituent societies, continue to support the Movement for a democratically chosen Jewish Congress in the spirit of the resolution of the I. A. C."
Le “ih LA SE A Wi AL ZUAVYALLAVYAL Wh BA Aa Ah Ye The Chairman: Dr. Pool’s resolution would confuse the issue by offering a compromise which does not clearly define the issue. The resolution as brought in by the majority of the committee states very clearly that we are dealing with a definite proposal. There is a Jewish Congress being organized which has an executive committee and a program. The intention of the majority of the committee is to approve of the action of the Federation in the creation of this executive committee of the American Jewish Congress and to ask the Zionists to agree to its establishment. If you do not like it, vote against it. This resolution of Dr. Pool’s practically deals with a resolution of the Inner Actions Committee not having a direct bearing on our issue with regard to the American Jewish Congress. I think the Convention is entitled to decide this matter clearly. Either they approve of the resolution of the majority of the committee or they approve of the resolution brought in by Mr. Schechter.
Dr. Pool withdraws his resolution.
Mr. Barondess: We did our best to make peace. We talked of nothing else. We sent committees. We had conferences with them, and every time we met with them they always answered that the time has not yet come for the American Jews to be represented in a democratic congress. Your answer to-day should be that the time has come; that the American Jews want to talk for themselves and they will talk for themselves, and all those who stand at a distance are welcome to come to us; and when they declare that they are for a congress and they want to unite with us, be certain that all doors will be open, for we want peace and they don’t want it.
The previous question was called for. By motion, the discussion was closed.
The Chairman: There are two motions:
First. — Motion introduced by the Majority Committee: “Be it resolved: That this Convention endorse the program for the calling of an American Jewish Congress on a democratic basis, adopted by the Preliminary Conference held at Philadelphia on March 26 and March 27, 1916, and the action of the Executive Organization Committee for an American Jewish Congress there elected; and be it further resolved, That this Convention pledges the co-operation of all its constituent organizations and societies to the work of oreanizine such a Congress.”
Second.—The motion introduced by Mr. Schechter:
eh DE Fe En = du El en Fr ne Ye m he mi Rn AU an un en An rn al “Whereas, We reiterate our belief in a democratic Jewish Congress but whereas any Congress of American Jews in which all great groups of American Jewry are not adequately represented is bound to defeat its own ends and present to the world a lamentable lack of unity in Israel, and whereas the present Congress organization has admittediy not succeeded in working out a scheme of representation and a basis of action satisfactorv to all such groups,
EEE EN EEE EEE ET ee RN - TE Therefore: Be it resolved, That the Executive Committee of the Federation of American Zionists be instructed to make every effort to secure this desired unity of action, and that it shall not consider itself bound until such further attemnts at co-overation be made.”