be adopted. Mr. Schechter here reported for the minority. The minority report appears later as Mr. Schechter's substitute resolution.
Mr. Davis of Pittsburgh: I move that the minority report be tabled.
The motion to table was voted on. 128 voted in favor of tabling it and 81 against.
Dr. Pool: I would like to know, in view of the fact that the whole situation between the leaders of the congress and the conference movement is still under discussion, whether it is timely for us to take up the matter of the Congress.
The Chairman: The Congress Committee has decided to reject the invitation of the American Jewish Committee to attend its conference. I believe it is timely for us to take up the question now, to indicate, as one of the constituents of the Congress Committee, whether we are satisfied with its action.
The Chairman: The minority report is tabled and is not to come up again, but at the same time we have agreed among ourselves for the good and welfare of the Movement that there should be a discussion on the issue presented by a number of Zionists as to the policy to be adopted by the Zionist organization in the Congress movement, I shall ask that no motion to close debate be put, until the question had been thoroughly discussed. I shall recognize Mr. Louis Edward Levy of Philadelphia.
Louis Edward Levy of Philadelphia: Fellow Zionists: I am impelled to give expression to that sense of profound regret, that deep sorrow to see that large numbers of Zionists and also of:non-Zionists throughout this land have been taken hold of by grievous dissension which has become manifest in American Israel and which is threatening the future not only of American Israel but the future of the Zionist Movement. I therefore offer as a resolution, expressing the sense of this organization at this convention. This resolution is a substitute........
The Chairman: You have no right to introduce this resolution at this time. You are not a regularly accredited delegate of this convention, and further, the question is to be discussed on the basis of the majority and minority reports.
Mr. Levy: This resolution that I propose is simply a substitute for the one before the executive committee of the Federation of American Zionists. That the Zionists be instructed to adopt measures to prevent the further development of this dissension and to exert every possible effort to remove its cause.
The Chairman: I believe that that pious wish is one with which the Federation is in full accord.
Mr. Schechter of New York: I offer this as a substitute motion: “Whereas we reiterate our belief in a democratic Jewish Congress, but whereas any Congress of American Jews, in which all great groups of American Jewry are not adequately represented is bound to defeat its own ends and present to the world a lamentable lack of unity in Israel, and whereas the present Congress Organization has admittedly not succeeded in working out a scheme of representation and a basis of action saticfactory to all groups,
"Therefore, Be it resolved that the Federation of American Zionists be instructed to make every effort to secure this desired unity of action and that we shall not consider ourselves bound until such further attempts at co-operation be made by the Executive Committee.
The Chairman: The majority report of the committee is practically a vote of confidence in the Federation executive committee and adds instructions to the societies to participate in the congress. The resolution of Mr. Schechter asks that until peace is established the F. A. Z. refrain from participating in the Congress Movement.
Dr. de Sola Pool of New York: I hold that the interpretation you gave is not quite adequate. He does not say that the Federation may not take action until peace is restored. He does say that no action be taken until further efforts have been made.
The Chairman: You will admit that it does not mean anything. Further efforts may mean whatever you please.
Mr. Cowen: Mr. Chairman and Fellow Zionists: The Convention Majority Committee on the Congress aims to
endorse the action of your representatives.. We say it is necessary that the Zionists of America shall endorse the Preliminary Conference and should support their representatives. As a matter of fact, a committee consisting of Judge Brandeis, Judge Pam and Judge Sanders are to appear before the conference of the American Jewish Committee for the purpose of explaining our position. I think the presence of two Zionists like Judge Brandeis and Judge Pam is an indication of the good faith of the Jewish Congress Committee. We do want peace, but we want peace within reason. The motion made in behalf of the minority leaves us in the air and binds us to nothing and embarrasses the whole Congress Movement. If we are instructed not to be bound, how can we vote on any resolution? What right have we on the Jewish Congress Committee if we intend to withdraw? If we serve on the Congress Committee, we must abide by the action and the vote of the Jewish Congress Committee, The Jewish Congress Committee has been accused of being dominated by a Jewish national sentiment. The Jewish Congress Committee is guilty, and that is sufflicient guarantee that they will do nothing that is not in harmony with the spirit of the Zionists of America. The Jewish Congress Committee elected only temporary oflicers in order to keep the door open for responsible bodies to affıliate themselves with it, and the officers are still temporary. But this Zionist Convention has no right to undo the work of the rank and file of the Zionists and their representatives by preventing work in the future and compelling us to wait until every element in Jewry is represented, because the assimilationists, and I do not necessarily refer to the American Jewish Committee, are also an element in Jewry and with them there can be no compromise. It must be left to the committee, headed by Judge Brandeis, to do everything they can to make peace.
In reply to a point of information as to whether it were true that the Inner Actions Comite is opposed to the Congress Movement, the Chairman introduced Dr. S. Levin to speak for the Inner Actions Comite.
Dr. Levin explained, in Yiddish, that up to this time the attitude of the I. A. C. towards the American Congress Movement was not positively known; but that there has come from the I. A. C. to the P. C. a resolution showing their approval of the Congress Movement.
The Resolution, as follows, was read to the delegates: “Das Zionistische Aktions-Komite begrüsst mit grosser Genugtuung die Bestrebungen der judischen Organizationen der Vereinigten Staaten, eine legitime, demokratisch erwählte Vertretung der amerikanischen Judenheit zu schaffen, um bei den Friedensverhandlungen den Lebensforderungen des jüdischen Volkes nach bürgerlicher, ebenso nationaler Gleichberechtigung in allen Ländern, wo sie den Juden vorenthalten wird, sowie nach Freiheit der Einwanderung und Ansiedlung in Palästina und allen Ländern der jüdischen Immigration Geltung zu verschaffen.
"Das EAC wird ermächtigt, die zu wählende Executive des amerikanischen jüdischen Kongresses bei ihren Bemühungen tatkräftig zu födern, eine Verständigung mit allen Parteien, und Organisationen der Juden aller Ländern zu erreichen, die gewillt sind, die Aktion für die Sicherung der jüdischen bürgerlichen und nationalen Rechtsgleichheit zu unterstützen."
English Translation.
"The Zionist Actions Committee hails with great satisfaction the efforts of the Jewish Committee of the United States to create a legitimate, democratically chosen representative body of American Jewry in order to secure at the Peace Conference the vital demands of the Jewish People for Civil and National rights in all lands where these are denied to the Jews, as well as for freedom, to enter and settle in Palestine and all lands of Jewish immigration.
"The Inner Actions Committee is authorized to support vigorously the Executive Body to be elected by the American Jewish Congress in its efforts to reach an understanding with all parties and organizations of the Jews of all lands which are willing to support the movement to secure equal civil and national rights for the Jews."