darkness in which men have come to dwell, it is the inviolability of true racialism, the sanctities of national consciousness and national integrity. These stand out as they have never stood out before ‚and the world that is to be reconstituted after the war must give its due to every nationalism and every racialism and every religionism, else will this war be but a prelude to war after war. These inviolably sacred things can neither be merged nor submerged. From the war there is to result not the passing of peoples, the extinction of races, the destruction of nations, but the persistence of these in mutual tolerance and upon the firm basis of reicprocal reverence. Moreover, shall it not be hotly resented that nationhood is set up as if it in itself were evil and opposed to the spirit of religion? So to urge is as unreasoning as to maintain that religion is evil because its abortions are hypocricv and bipotry.
The wrong kind of nationalism is wrong, but not the right kind. There is an excess as there is a paucity of nationalism or racialism or religionism which is bad. But these things are not bad in themselves.
DER FE ae el - Re er en Wi Fer See a * ee ze The Jew for a time made a virtue of necessity, accepting as established the fact that Israel was a faith and not a people or racial survival. Now the world finds that its dreams were vain, that races will go on and nationhoods pefsist, but Israel alone is still expected to make a necessity of its mistaken virtue and to cry on,—Kaftaned Easterner and Western captain of finance, —we are of one faith, but we are not a race nor a fraction of a race. We are at one in nothing save our religion, or irreligion.
. But our irenic anti-Zionist brothers imagine that if they iterate often enough that Israel is a religion and nothing more, the world without will accept their judgment in the question as decisive and irrepealable. As if the world accepted our own appraisal of ourselves in any regard! Do these really believe that the world thinks of us as different in faith alone, as if, perchance, we were Quakers rather than Romans, Methodists rather than Presbyterians. We may exclaim until Doomsday that we are just like the rest of the world in all things save in faith. The world benignantly smiles, or malignantly sneers that we are different. That we are different is patent in a thousand ways, but the difference is not necessarily to our credit or discredit, and whether that difference is to be creditable or discreditable depends upon whether it is translated into distinction rather than persisted in as distinctiveness. The difference is, or rather the differences are,—and our faith is one of the items of difference, — one of a great number of differentiae.
And if we maintain very stoutly that no difference obtains save touching the content of our faith, what shall we say of the underlying assumption that unity of faith obtains among all Jews? Moreover, what becomes of the unbelieving Jews, and there are some such, or are they to be read out of Jewish life? Granted that they are, the world will smile at the absurdity of it, for it lumps us together without paying heed to aught save the incontrovertible fact that chief among the differentiae is the fact of race and all that race means,—history, background, lineage, consciousness, experience, faith, life, and, for Israel, suffering, trial, hope.
a A nn ne ne 7 he — A ee ee Facts are unannullable, and the fact is that we are a race or the surviving members of a racial group, —that we are a people yet though not only all men else forget, but many of us would fain forget. Moreover, this whole theory of religionism as the sole criterion of the content of Jewishness has been built up in order to deny the racialism of the Jew,—that is, that the element of race is chief among the differentiae as between Israel and non-Terael
Speaking for a moment in terms parenthetic, as a Lib-
eral, I admit that to me it seems nothing less than a tragedy that Liberal Judaism is ready to divorce itself completely from Jewish life. So woeful is the misinterpretation of the content of Jewishness that I am fearful lest Liberal Judaism become a desicatted sect and fail to have part and parcel in Jewish life. This were unhappily, but none the less justifiably, the doom of Liberal Judaism, if it so will.
Does it not behoove them that still imagine themselves to be in sympathy with the spirit of Liberal Judaism to use the term “irreligious” sparingly? Let it not be too freely bandied about for, facing facts frankly, there is not too much religion within Liberalism to-day any more than within orthodoxy. Under the unhappy and erring guidance of those rigidiy orthodox Liberals whose Liberalism is a cramping memory rather than a liberating hope, Liberalism is almost ceasing to be a consciously religious movement. It is, alas, no longer dominantly spiritual, and it comes with poor grace for those utter secularists, if so un-Jewish and un-Zionistic a term may be employed, to dub Zionists irreligious, seeing how much of irreligion obtains within the ranks of so-called Liberal Tudaism. :
As for giving justification to the anti-Semite through our persistence in the Zionist faith, what of that? Granted that it be true,—and it is not true, save as the term has regard to Jewish anti-Semitism in whatsoever guise,—anti-Semitism is not so much in opposition to Semitism as it is the denial of the Jew’s non-Semitism. Or are we to change the texture of our lives and the habit of our souls to avert the ill-will,—and not always real ill-will,—of the anti-Semites? Is that possible, and if possible or feasible, is it ever desirable?
And the unwisdom, not to say folly, and the injustice, not to say shame, of lightly using such terms as "un-American" and "hyphenated Americanism" with respect to those of us who are Zionists! Not only will all those terms hurt in all, but they represent the gravest and most unpardonable of injustices. We who are Zionists stand in a peculiarly unassailable position, for America means not the triumph of one race or faith or nationality. One becomes an American not by surrendering self but by spending self in a maximum of loyalty and service.
ee. Titan - a Er er Se Be ar" er en a ee How can Zionism be irreligious, for behold its works vivifying and spiritualizing! How can Zionism be irreligious, seeing that it saves the Jew, and without the Jew Judaism cannot be. If the Jew pass, then is Judaism perished. Zionism saves the Jew and to save the Jew is ultimately to save Judaism. We have too long been working at the wrong end, trying to save the Jew through Judaism whereas Zionism saves Judaism through the Tew.
re It may be possible for some men to escape the enthusiasm and religious passion of such a great and ennobling movement as Zionism has proved itself to be in the life of Israel for half a generation and then to brand that as irreligious by which one has somehow remained untouched. I do not insist that Zionism is a religion, nor yet that it can take the place of religion in the life of multitudes of Jews, but it is indubitably become a part of the religious life of the Jew and it is being served with nothing less than religious consecration and religious passion. The Jew clings to Zionism in the spirit of religion. It has deepened his interest in Jewish problems, quickened the pulses of his Jewish life, stirred the sympathies of the Jewish people, again introduced into Israel a spirit of fraternity which can never come through the giving of alms but only through the prosecution of a great purpose. Religiousiy democratizing and fraternalizing has become and is destined to remain Zionism upon American Israel. —unpon Israel.