The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVIII, No. 6 · June 1916
124printed page
scan 4 of 42

have ceased if he had denied the truth of the report at once. The whole incident is to be regretted, from the dedication of the Central Jewish Institute, through the attacks in the Yiddish press, down to Mr. Schiff's address at the Kehillah convention.

Respect for Public Opinion

EVERY one is in favor of peace. It is a blessed word. But to cry peace when there is no peace is folly. Mr. Schiff and Mr. Marshall do not forget in their utterances always to insert the word peace somewhere. But it has no meaning. Their peace means, agree with us and there is peace. If you do not agree with us, you are contentious fellows. Is it possible that the wisdom of the Jewish world is embodied in the person of Mr. Marshall or Mr. Schiff, with Dr. Cyrus Adler and Cyrus L. Sulzberger as added weight? What are we to do when from the wisdom of thousands of others we ascertain that a Congress would bring good results for the Jews, while, on the other hand, a few men say that it would have the opposite effect? Suppose we have a third opinion, and we are obstinate about it, and say that neither a Congress nor a Conference, before or after the war, nor any Jewish organization can bring any results for the Jews? How are we to arrive at a decision so far as action is concerned? What are we to do? If it were only a matter of opinion, we need not take a vote on it if we cannot arrive at a unanimous opinion. But every one knows that we shall have to do something. What is that something? Shall it be what Mr. Schiff, et. al. advise? Or what the Congressists advise? Or what some third or fourth party advises? What is the democratic thing to do? Is it not to take a vote, after deliberation, discussion, argument, etc.? Is it honorable and decent for the peacemaker to advise accepting Mr. Schiff’s point of view for the sake of peace? And yet that is what a number of peace-makers on the Congress question have been proposing, as if the truth or the best judgment can be reached as a matter of personal favor to this or that man.

Relief for the Occupied Territories

THERE are rumors of a scandal in connection with the distribution of American Jewish relief funds in the occupied territories. Involved in it are the Hilfsverein der Deutschen Juden and its leaders, James Simon and Dr. Paul Nathan. If what is being rumored is true, the Joint Distribution Committee of the three American Jewish relief committees should at once terminate its relations with all German Jewish connections. As most of our readers know, the relief monies from America for the occupied territories of Poland, Courland and Lithuania are sent by our relief committees to the Hilfsverein or the Hilfscomite for the Jews in Poland, etc., which sends it to the American consul at Warsaw, who hands it over to a Warsaw Jewish committee; but the Warsaw Jewish Committee receives its instructions from the Hilfsverein or the Hilfscomite, and not from or through the American consul. Criticism has been made of this method of distributing American Jewish funds. It was pointed out that the Polish Jews were being placed in jeopardy by having them receive money from a German organization at a time when the Poles and the Russians look upon Jews with suspicion. But for some unaccountable reason, the Joint Distribution Committee

here continues the appointment of the Hilfsverein or the Hilfscomite as its agents in Poland. There is some doubt as to the status of the Hilfscomite. The Hilfscomite is for all practical purposes, the Hilfsverein doing provisional relief work. The secretary of the Hilfsverein, Dr. Bernard Kahn, is secretary of the Hilfscomite, and the Hilfsverein's office is the office of the Hilfscomite. If further proof were needed of the identification of both organizations, these facts may be given: Letters addressed to the Hilfscomite are answered by the secretary of the Hilfsverein on letterheads of the Hilfsverein; the Joint Distribution Committee has received from the Hilfsverein a request to be allowed to use part of the funds received for the administration of the relief work.

Miss Szold’s Retirement

MISS HENRIETTA SZOLD has resigned as secretary of the Publication Committee of the Jewish Publication Society, having served the society for twenty-eight years. To those familiar with the workings of the Publication society, the retirement of Miss Szold must be regarded as a serious loss. While a Publication committee has been responsible for the selection of the manuscripts to be published, Miss Szold has been responsible for the actual preparation of the manuscripts for the printer, and editing of the manuscripts, and the hundred and one details that are of importance in the getting out of books. Her keen sense of literary values, her accuracy, her good taste are reflected in every book sent out by the society. In a number of instances, she is responsible for the practical re-writing of manuscripts, the painstaking verification of dates and figures. In short, Miss Szold has been the editor of the Publication Society, doing her work unostentatiously, devotedly, and utterly regardless of self. This service the Jewish Publication Society dismisses with a brief reference. The president of the society in his report says: “Miss Szold’s contribution to the work of the society is well known throughout Jewish literary circles. The board has made certain that we will have the benefit of her co-operation and has appointed her to membership on the publication committee.” This coldness and ingratitude is characteristic of the officials of the Publication Society.

Mr. Zangwill on Zionism

THE few words Mr. Zangwill gave to our interviewer, whose article appears in this issue, are filled with the characteristic forms of expression for which the clever author of “Without Prejudice” is famous. But aside from poking fun at some of the serious problems now confronting the Zionist movement, there is nothing in the interview that reveals a constructive policy. Mr. Zangwill declares there is no Jewish nation, and yet all his theories depend upon the existence of a group of people bound together by ties that are wholly national. He says that Palestine will never hold all the Jews who are being displaced by the war, and yet he offers no suggestion as to where they should go. In fact, to our regret it must be said, Mr. Zangwill the statesman is unable to say exactly what he would like to have Jews do. His is a pessimistic point of view, without hope and without comfort.