to the man who has, in a large measure, helped to build up American Jewish communal life. At such a time, it would be folly to intrude anything but praise of such good works as he has accomplished, and to express regret at the circumstances that compel his retirement. But if in the expression of regret, it is presumed that self-blame is implied, it is necessary to disabuse the minds of sentimentalists. Mr, Schiff, the man, is entitled to our respect and esteem. He has been a potent and influential figure in American Jewish life for half a century. No one will refuse a vote of thanks for this work. But for Mr. Schiff who propa- gates views and ideas that are not in accord with progressive Jewish ideals, there can be no such words of praise. Mr. Schiff has used the good-will of the Jewish people arising out of his philanthropic deeds to speak with assumed authority on a large number of Jewish questions, and because of the kindly feelings felt toward him, has been able to paralyze the activities of large numbers of Jews in the direction of Jewish self-emancipation and democracy. He has boldly made charges against Zionists which we were compelled to repudiate; and when he persisted in making these charges, we were compelled to question his authority to speak for the Jews. He has used all the influence at his command to obstruct the development of the Congress movement, a movement intended to benefit the Jewish people, and which will benefit the Jewish people. He has discussed Yiddish in a way to make that language, the language .of our mothers and fathers, a thing to be ashamed of, while we feel that that language, being the language of our fathers and mothers, is entitled to our respect and appreciation. Every effort to broaden the area of responsibility for Jewish life has been opposed by Mr. Schiff, who has no faith in Jewish democracy. Holding such views, it would have been criminal on our part had we not taken up the sword of contention and meet Mr. Schiff on his own ground. If in the course of the conflict, Mr. Schiff has been hurt, it should be remembered that the honor and the dignity of the Jewish people has also been terribly hurt by Mr. Schiff’s policy of self-depreciation and self-effacement,
The Failure of Opportunism
THE opening address of Dr. Magnes at the Kehillah convention was a clear exhibition of the dilemma in which Dr. Magnes now finds himself as a result of his destructive opportunism. Dr. Magnes went into the work of the Kehillah as a Zionist. He wanted to win over to the Jewish national cause, through local work, that large group of wealthy men who at that time were rigidly opposed to Zionism. Dr. Magnes intended doing what Theodore Herzl had announced as the Zionist slogan: “Capture the Jewish communities.” But Dr. Magnes did not understand the essentials of the slogan. By capturing the communities was meant, using the communities through Zionists working in them, for national purposes. From the very first, Dr. Magnes compromised his Zionism for the sake of progress. Abandoning, in effect, almost from the start the principles and methods of democracy, he allowed all his bureaus to be financed by persons who were not inclined to be in the least Zionistic. The bureaus were separated from the Kehillah, and were not responsible to it. So involved did Dr. Magnes become in this Kehillah work, that at the last Tanersville convention in 1907 he practically abandoned his direct participation in the Zionist movement.
He was a Zionist, but had little time to give to it. The movement lost the benefit of his advice and participation, In the course of time, coming in contact almost daily with persons opposed to Zionism, he lost his enthusiasm for the Zionist movement. He became engrossed in local administration. With the outbreak of the war, he returned temporarily to the Zionist or- ganiaztion, but only for a time. The Kehillah consumed all his time, and then the relief work started. Instead of devoting his ability to the Zionist cause at this crisis, which found the Zionist organization woefully undermanned, he became the agent of the Amer- can Jewish Committee in the relief work, and it was with Dr. Magnes that the Provisional Committee had to deal on all issues involving the relative apportionments to Palestine and Europe. When the Congress movement broke, for a time he acted as a free agent, but when the American Jewish Committee acted in violation of the Kehillah resolution, Dr. Magnes went over to the party in Israel with which—as we had supposed—he had the least sympathy. Instead of being our advocate at a time when we sorely needed an advocate in the ranks of the American Jewish Committee, he became their advocate, At the Kehillah convention, as if realizing the swamp of contradiction and confusion in which he had fallen, pointing out the characteristics of the contending forces in American Israel, he exclaims: “We are crushed between these two millstones.”
An Unpleasant Incident
HE Schiff incident of this month has been most T unpleasant, but not without its valuable lessons. Mr. Schiff assuming to speak authoritatively on a number of questions, did not take the trouble to prepare his address, but left it to chance to have his address correctly reported. The report in the Times on May 22nd, in all probability did not represent his views; what he said may have been indistinctly uttered ör awkwardly framed; the report in the Times may have been taken down by an ignorant reporter; the reports in the Yiddish press may have been garbled by reporters not understanding English well. But the speeches of a man like Mr. Schiff should have been prepared in advance in order to forestall misstatements, in order to avoid slips of the tongue, in order that the larger public may know exactly what the speaker had said. And when the report in the Times appeared, and the Yiddish press at once launched an attack on Mr. Schiff, Mr. Schiff should have denied the veracity of the report, giving, if possible, the exact language he had employed. But Mr. Schiff remained silent for three days, and on the fourth the stenographic version of the speech appeared,. This stenographic version not coming from Mr. Schiff, but from the office of a Yiddish newspaper, the other newspapers refused to accept it as authentic, especially so as the stenographic report made nonsense of the paragraph that had been censured. Two weeks after the Central Jewish Institute dedication, Mr. Schiff apeared at the Kehillah convention and there denied the truth of the Times report, and entered a complaint against the Yiddish newspapers for having believed that he had ever said what the Times had reported. To indicate his feeling in the matter, he announced his withdrawal from Jewish politics. Hereafter, Zionism, Jewish nationalism and the Congress are as a sealed book to him. Under the circumstances, it is unfair to find fault with the Yiddish newspapers. Their attacks would