The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVIII, No. 6 · June 1916
146printed page
scan 26 of 42
146
THE MACCABAEAN FOR JUNE

nent American Jews. Since then the American Jewish Committee itself has published the evidence against the Russian Government, a good part of which was available even then.

The old policy of “back-stairs diplomacy” and supplication was advocated by the President of the American Jewish Committee. “We have no army, no cannon, no land of our own,” he said, “the Jewish question should not be presented to the Peace Conference. There are more effective ways.” These other ways, naturally, do not require for their utilization a Congress which would mobilize the power and dignity of the Jewish people.

The delegates to the Convention, including the Chairman, pleaded in vain with the three or four individuals of the American Jewish Committee “to have more confidence in the people, to believe in their intelligence and good intentions.” These few men, however, refused to believe in any such thing. A formal vote on the question was avoided. The delegates consented to wait one month, during which time, it was hoped, Mr. Marshall and his colleagues would modify their views and “permit” the Jews of America to meet in Congress.

During this month, although the Congress idea was rapidly gaining adherents all over the country, a committee was busily at work on the attempt to patch up a compromise. On Monday, May 24th, the Congress session of the Kehillah convention took place. Prof. I. A. Hourwich reported that an agreement with the American Jewish Committee had been reached, but that the term “Conference” was to be substituted for Congress. The American Jewish Committee was afraid that a Jewish Congress would be construed as an act of disloyalty to the United States Congress! Prof. Hourwich then read the following compromise resolution:

"Whereas: This Convention of the Jewish Community (Kehillah) of New York City favors the idea of holding a conference of delegates of Jewish societies throughout the country chosen by their membership for the sole purpose of considering the Jewish question as it affects our brethren in belligerent lands, and in view of the fact that the American Jewish Committee has heretofore decided to hold a Conference to which the heads of the leading Jewish organizations of the country are to be invited for the purpose of considering the same subject, be it resolved

That the Jewish Community (Kehillah) of New York City, as a constituent part of the American Jewish Committee, recommend to the latter that it hold a special meeting of its members with all convenient dispatch, to consider the advisability of calling a conference of the character favored by this convention in lieu of the Conference which the American Jewish Committee has heretofore planned."

On the recontmendation of the Chairman, this resolution was voted on without debate, and was accepted by a vote of 82 to 62. The matter, however, was not so easily disposed of. The dissatisfaction with. the wording of the compromise resolution finally came to a head with the offering of another resolution that the Kehillah representatives on the American Jewish Committee be bound by the action of the Convention and instructed to vote in favor of a “Conference” at the special meeting of that Committee.

It was then that the utter helplessness and apparent meaninglessness of the Kehillah, as an organization, revealed itself. Mr. Louis Marshall practically denied the right of the Kehillah to instruct him! And

even the Chairman hinted that the Kehillah is not sufficiently representative of New York Jewry to instruct its own representatives on the American Jewish Committee. The Kehillah, it seems, was indisputably representative, as long as it did the will of the American Jewish Committee. Now that the time had come when it was bent on expressing its will, it had lost its representative character.

The delegates, however, realized that to be denied the right to instruct their own representatives was merely to be trifled with. They refused to continue to play the role of a democratizing vencer for the American Jewish Committee. They passed the resolution of instruction by a vote of 118 to 87. The passing of the resolution was the declaration of independence against absolute, if benevolent, despotism. But, it seemed, a last test was necessary. An attempt was made to nullify the declaration of independence, by proposing a resolution that “it is not the intent of the resolution passed to force any member of the American Jewish Committee to vote against his conscience.” The delegates stood the test. They rejected the subterfuge by a vote of 93 to 82. But although they would not be instructed, the Executive members of the Kehillah, who were also amongst the leaders of the American Jewish Committee, took an active part in framing the above resolution. Before the motion to instruct was made, they gave repeated assurances of their intention to carry out this resolution, in the sense that the Conference or Congress would be called and convened on a democratic basis.

Did the American Jewish Committee keep faith with the Kehillah and through the Kehillah, with the people of New York? The call for a Conference which the American Jewish Cammittee subsequently issued was in complete violation of both the letter and the spirit of even the compromise Kehillah resolution. The secret, exclusive, undemoöcratic Conference of a restricted number of delegates and organizations, which was subsequently set for October 24th, and which was to be held in Washington, changed the whole Congress idea into a farce and the leaders of the American Jewish Committee thus made a laughing stock of all those who participated in the two separate conventions and who gave so much thought and time in discussing so vital an issue to the Jewish people. Despite all assurances and pledges, the leaders of the American Jewish Cammittee gave no serious consideration to the wishes of the Kehillah and its constituents in the matter. In fact, it treated the whole orranization as a neeligible factor.

Nevertheless, the New York Kehillah, as such, by the action of its accredited representatives stands committed to the calling of an American Jewish Congress. What have the officers and Executive Committee of the Kehillah done to carry out the will of its constituents? They have hitherto of their own accord, for the most part, initiated activities for which they later sougth the sanction of the conventions. Here is an undertaking in which the Convention itself took the initiative. Will the Kehillah for that reason ignore it? It may have the legal right but has it the moral right to dismiss this most vital matter by refering it to the American Jewish Committee which it knows to be opposed to a Congress such as its constituents demand? Is the democracy of which it boasts to be merely of a passive, acquiescent, amen-saying nature? Are its constituents to be treated as a lot of children, to be chided and ignored if they should have the inpertinence and bad taste to express a

(Continued on page 157)