The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVIII, No. 6 · June 1916
145printed page
scan 25 of 42
Facsimile · scan 25 of 42
Scan of p. 145
Text · transcribed from the scan

Here is the only time and place you are influenced by your non-Jewish ideals. The laying of too much weight on money in the Zionist propaganda; the laudation of the wealthy at times who promise contributions but often do not make payments; the bending of the knees to the shul-Jews; and the inattention paid the proletarian—these are shafts of your friendly criticism. When Zionism to you is the grandest scheme of the age, you naturally are bent to keep it holy as much as

is allowable.e Money is needed but enthusiasm is needed more. A man like you lives, actually lives, on enthusiasm,. This accounts for your preference to attend a First of May celebration to a Tisha B’ov mass-meeting.

But, in the long run, considering all phases of the situation, you find you are cheered sooner and quicker by the Hatikvah than by the International. The latter, however, has its place, too.

Where Does the Kehillah Stand?

BY ISRAEL GOLDBERG.

WHAT has been the role of New York Jewry in the present crisis? It is no exaggeration to say that the Jewish community of New York is to-day the Jewish center of gravity, the power-station which must energize the action of preserving the bulk of the Jewish people in Europe and of securing for the Jews a dignified future. A million heads, a million pair of hands must work in the cause of Jewish salvation.

The organization of this greatest of Jewish Communities of all times and places! What an endless vista of power and usefulness! The enormous difficulties of the task were not sufficient to discourage the men who, some seven years ago, began the attempt by organizing the New York Kehillah. This was the most ambitious experiment in Jewish organization that had ever been attempted. It had its basis in the theory that all Jews, no matter what religious or economic differences divide them, possess some interest in common, as Jews, upon which they can all unite. The organization of the Kehillah enlisted the best forces in the community, including the young and idealistic who saw in imagination the democratic organization of the masses for Jewish service.

The fundamental causes of the failure of the New York Kehillah to accomplish its main purpose—the organization of New York Jewry—was, first, the fact that it took up activities which could not unite the various elements; and, secondly, that it failed to engage in undertakings which did have the power to bring about that result. And both its sins of commission and ommission may be ascribed to the fact that it chose to subordinate itself to, and subsequently became the mere instrument of the undemocratic and unrepresentative American Jewish Committee.

In spite of its reiteration that it aimed or actually did represent the will of New York Jewry, the Kehillah never made any real attempt to secure its budget from its supposed constituents, but subsisted almost entirely on the contributions of the few who naturally determined its important actions.

Much has been said and written by orthodox and radical in criticism of things the Kehillah has carried out. But what it has not done is even more serious. And in respect of the latter, nothing is more serious than its failure to take the lead in the creation of the American Jewish Congress.

To the creation and effectiveness of the Congress, the inaction of the Kehillah is likely to be of small consequence. But what a pity that an excellent op-

portunity, which is likely never to return, was thus destroyed! For here was an opportunity to unite all classes of Jews upon a popular program of action which could rouse their enthusiasm and secure their moral and material support. It was an opportunity for the Kehillah to make itself the supreme and really comprehensive Jewish organization, a condition which would have made it effective for work in other directions as well.

The manner in which the Kehillah acted on the Congress issue makes a highly instructive object lesson to all those interested in effecting the organization of Jews of New York. This lesson should be taken to heart, for it may save us from repeating similar blunders in the future.

The sixth Convention of the New York Kehillah, April 24th, and 25th, 1915, before which the Congress question came up, was pronounced by its Chairman to have been the "most historic Jewish meeting" in America. It was certainly the largest Kehillah convention, the reason for this being the evident interest of the Jewish organizations concerned in having the Kehillah, as the central New York organization, take the lead in the calling of a Congress. The tenor of the convention left no room for doubt as to how the vast majority of the delegates stood on the Congress question. A committee of ten, of which Prof. I. A. Hourwich was Chairman, had already prepared a plan for the calling of the Congress.

However, at this “greatest and most historic gathering in America,” there were a few individuals, to whom the Kehillah had previously subordinated itself and who were powerful enough to prevent the vast majority from carrying through its wishes. The few, of whom Mr. Louis Marshall, President of the American Jewish Committee was the leader, were pleaded with, exhorted and flattered, as though they were absolute monarchs, to grant “the people” their wishes. But “to call a Congress would be very dangerous” they announced and the rest, for the time being, at least, had to submit. It was at this same session that Mr. Louis Marshall, so deeply alarmed at the possibility that ill-advised language might be used at a Congress, himself used words so ill-advised as are bound to bear harmful effects upon those in whose interests the Congress is to be called. Mr. Marshall is on record as having said: “\Vhere are your proofs? (against the Russian Government) What do your proofs consist of? Of newspaper reports? Do you think the United States can do anything on the ground of such evidence?” Imagire the joy of the Russian agents and abettors of this whitewashing of the Russian Government by one of the most promi-