The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVIII, No. 5 · May 1916
109printed page
scan 13 of 26

to-face fight with a crystallizing society. There can be no personal religion which consists in seeking personal realization through escape from the trammels of collective life. It must be distinctively aggressive. Anything which does not possess this character is mere subjective sentamentalizing.

Let us now test the movement of reform by this test. The activity towards adaptation can not have a direct effect upon the masses of the Jewish race; except in so far as it causes the masses to recognize more clearly the anomalous position in which they find themselves. It is only negative in its effect. Test it now for effect upon the Diaspora life, and what are the results?

As prerequisites to the contribution of the individual to the social group, perhaps we ought to consider the following truths. One must have interests in common with this group, be like-minded with them. He must be identified with this group, otherwise his work is looked on as foreign, and will have no direct reaction upon the life of the group. Further, the fact of difference from the group must be a privilege, and not something that is forced upon one and cannot be helped. Now, do the few among us who are seeking personal realization in the Diaspora come up to these standards? I believe they do not rise to these requirements. As we have seen, the difference from the Jewish mass-life does not involve an aggressive attitude, or any self-sacrifice for a higher ideal. In fact, their relation to the Jewish type-life as it exists is merely one of discarding the inconvenient. There is no idealistic element involved here, I am merely discarding my old clothes to get into new ones which will permit me to enter higher society. While it is convenient to discard the old, there is a distinct premium placed upon adopting the new. There is here no expression of personality, but the desire to fall in with a system. Again, are the few here contributing to the type-life of the group? Are they not merely trying to make themselves like it rather than it like themselves? The question then arises, “Must our search for personal realizatian meet always with such futility? Certainly, we must consider an inner harmoniousness a sure sign of a good life. Must we not then try to obtain such a harmony by possessing a religion which will harmonize the facts of my struggle for personal realization ?”

Yes, the personal element in religion should normally be the most dominantly impressive one to the individual. The idealization of the self should normally be the highest expression of all religion, perhaps. But one must develop himself in conformity with the laws of development. One cannot have personal religion, or personal realization, in a condition

where he cannot definitely affect a distinct social group to a higher life. At the present, those seeking personal realization such as the Diaspora offers belong distinctly neither to a Jewish group nor to a Diaspora group. But their tendency is inevitably towards an identification of themselves with the Diaspora. To attain personal realization, therefore, they must definitely ally themselves with the Diaspora. At present, they are suspended, as it were, in mid-air in the act of transition.

There is only one solution to the difficulty. By removing the masses, the few would in time become indigenous. They could thus fully identify themselves with the social life of this country, and, thus placed in a society with which they would be undeniably bound up, they could attain that measure of personal eralization which they are at present vainly seeking. The fact that there is a mass-existence here prevents the identification of the few with the indigenous life, As it is from this very mass-life that they are trying to escape. The masses, on the other hand, placed in an environment of their own making, will be also able to attain that ideal measure of personal life that must necessarily be now_lacking. A higher personal life would thus manifest itself in a personal religion identified wth the mass-life rather than a national religion held to be authoritative, but unsatisfying. The only solution is the existence of a Jewish state in Palestine.

With the shifting of the responsibility for conserving the racial type and culture from the shoulders of all to a central state those Jews placed in the Diaspora will be more free to participate in the Diaspora life. For there is no doubt that even present day tendencies to assimilation are checked by a subconscious appreciation of the fact that nationality must be conserved. However a Jewish State would allow us to have in our midst individuals such as all normal nations have, individuals who mix with other nations.

Situated as I now am among a farming people, I can see clearly how personal idealism and personal religion are distinctly the attributes of the man who is free in an environment which he feels is distinctively his own. A certain proximity to nature, and the feeling of independence and power that comes from getting a livelihood from nature rather than from the consent of some other man, or through an exercise of wits, is the greatest element in any personal realization. Give our masses Palestine, with a certain proximity to nature, contact with big natural force, and a type of society in which they can feel some ownership, and which is distinctively their own, and you shall see a blossoming of thought and art such as the world has never yet beheld.