the national religion itself to a better filling of the needs of a higher personal life. Personal initiative away from the national religion, therefore, has normally proved a benefit to the total life of the nation. By breaking away, the individual has not cut himself off, but has normally acted as a stimulus to the group.
wa A De Er er RT DR Dal re 77 Ren Se et ER. DER So much for a nation normally situated. The individual is undenied member of a group, even though he deny the group religion. In rebelling, he has fulfilled his function to the whole group to a consequent enhancement of its life. If he had belonged to no definite group, or not considered himself as belonging to any group, his action could have had no significance.
This individual, on the other hand, could not have really conceived of himself as a person. We conceive of ourself as persons only when we belong or consider ourselves as belonging to a group.
en rn A re ne © Kit — An = a Personal religion is thus a normal manifestation of healthy personal life within a normally-growing group, The social environment is here assumed and the individual reacts to it just as he would under other circumstances to the forces of nature. Ä vigorous, capable nature, which under other conditions might have braved nature or harnessed it in a new way, will, in a normally growing nation, assert himself in an original and unconventional manner with institutions. The individual has become differentiated from the ETOUD.
Personal religion thus serves as the integrator of the elements of personal realization, and as motivator of the inner impulses to ethical conduct. It is thus concerned with the individual in his two phases of individual and member of group. Personal religion is thus normally the manifestation of healthy individualization within the group. National religion, as we have seen, is primarily the conserver of tradition, and the organ through whose functioning continuity is maintained in progress, so we have concrete rather than purely abstract or theoretic progress.
Let us now analyze the present religious situation of the Jewish people. We have said that national religion serves normally as an organ of progressive continuity within the nation. But suppose now, a nation situated, so to speak, in an environment which does not allow it to develop healthily and function in its own way. It can do one lose itself, or it can withdraw itself into itself in every phase of its existence or than the performance of these activities required to tide it. This last possibility is illustrated in the action of certain bacteria under unfavorable circumstances, who go into a torpor akin to death, but resume healthy activity upon drawing into itself the organism has conserved self-identity, whereas if it would have fully adapted itself, it would have had to do so at the expense of its distinctive individuality. The nationalistic character of the Jewish religion at the present time, with all its static quality and its emphasis on who find ourselves, is but the expression of the Jewish Will—to live as complete Jews when the opportunity shall offer.
The question now arises: "Concretely, wherein does the Jewish People find itself to-day in an unfavorable environment? Is there not in this country equal opportunity for all? Have not a great many of us fully adapted ourselves without loss of individuality?" The answer, to me, is obvious. What is possible for the few is neither desirable to, nor possible for, the many.
This country offers opportunity to individuals, not to races. Yet, nevertheless, the masses who come here are pervaded and inevitably controlled, by forces which make for their being closely associated with a Jewish Nation. They leave other countries as members of the Jewish nation, and as such settle here. If it were possible to scatter them over the whole United States, so there would be no Jewish communities, there would be no Jewish difficulty. But it is in the nature of the Jewish question that we settle in masses; and whereever there are masses with a common tradition, that tradition will be maintained to the very end of time. Even further, at the bottom of this fact of Jewish mass-life lies the Jewish National Will-to-live. The masses, therefore, in the Diaspora, will never fully adapt themselves to their environment. Their former social habits gain in authority through being religionizcd and in force through mass-living. Such a condition can be altered only by the inoculation within the masses of modern skepticism along with the absorption of the substance of modern life—both spiritual and material. But such a process cannot go on fast enough or efhiciently enough among a people with whom the struggle for existence, as transplanted organism, is fiercely centered on its lower phases, and with whom their distinctiveness is so ultimately complicated with every phase of their existence. Thus, to remove a Jew from hidden former social environment and habits of life, you must change his mode of thought, a thing which in turn can be accomplished only by the removing of him from the mass. Thus, the argument for assimilation turns in endless eircle.
But now, while the masses cannot and will not adapt themselves, there are a few for whom such a course is both possible and pleasing. These individuals find themselves surrounded by two types of social habit— the immediate Jewish and the larger Diaspora. Since the former restricts their activity, they try to realize their powers by fusing themselves with the Diaspora life, It is needless to point out that only a few of those who attempt such a life, are really successful. The majority of them remain bound up with their former type of life to a greater or less extent. In reality, the tendency is to complete cutting away from anything distinctively Jewish. Thus, were it not for the retaining of the name Jewish, as referring to this number, and a somewhat illogical recognition of some subtle relation with other Jews, this number would be in no way identified with anything Jewish. But now, while I have so stated the case with the Jewishness of this group, I must present another side of the question, distinctively bound up with the whole of the discussion.
Throughout this whole question, the most fundamental fact is the existence of social habits. It is through these that groups are distinguished from one another; and in turn the group religions. As far as mere logic is concerned, there is no reason in the world why people should have any historical associations connected with their religion, if what one is seeking for is universal, or so called prophetic religion. On the other hand, ıf one pleads personal religion, one must recognize the fact that all individuals are members of social groups, which both make personal religion possible, and which are normally the scenes of the conflict of personal religion with a crystallizing national religion. In other words, every one, will or nill, is a member of a social group. As such, the struggle for personal religion must have a direct effect upon the life of the social group within which it is taking place. Personal relieion must result in a face-
