How far away is this from the intricacies of the supercommentary written on the sub-commentary—which is the normal Jewish procedure.
Mr. Brandeis unerringly recognized and utilized Herzl’s great creation—the congress as a means for democratic expression. In 1896 as in 1916, we needed mötive power such as only organization can give us. What is more important, we needed to know, as now, the coneensus of opinion. It was then as now an absurd joke to assume that men “of influence” or without it, knew the will and the wish of the Jews. There had been no Jewish political life, there were no Jewish statesmen. Plenty of men lacked even ideas, and many who had ideas had no conclusions. The first positive answer to the Russian May Laws was the pathetic suggestion: buy off the persecutors. Arnold White was practically bribed to stop his attacks on the Jews in England by being sent to Russia as Baron de Hirsch’s commissioner. White went on his mission but to his honor be it said the bribe failed to make him stay out, and this is symptomatic of the labors of the “men of influence.” Nor were the Jewish mass leaders trained to think. Had the opposition come into the first congress, it was an open assembly, Zionism could have been overthrown, for nothing had been done to guard the Zionist interests of the assembly. The Zionist spokesmen coming as they did in the main from Eastern Europe were untrained in method, un- clear in thought, and strongly tempted to rule their own groups by brute force. As the most backward and cumbersome of continental methods of procedure were adopted, the congress was recalled at the mercy of every “spit fire,” the speeches being “the thing;” the resolutions which finally registered opinion being apparently an accidental production of the last morfent of debate. But the opposition did not show up. Probably it agreed with Rudolph Mosse of Berlin, who believed he could squelch Zionism by spending ten thousand marks on articles written by opponents.
FETT ET RE A AR Ar ET N 3 7 ee ae The congress became a training ground, and though the method of debate has never been improved, with each passing year, the delegates came with much clearer perception of purpose and better instructed. I believe I described the fifth congress as the first Jewish parliament because it was apparent that the Jews were willing to accept its moral sanctions, and brought new issues before it for discussion and de- eision.
The process of education through the congress is illustrated through its enactments from the first loose organization to the establishment and successful launching of the Jewish Colonial Trust. Five years of discussion had brought a sense of responsibility in the mass—agitation had not been wasted. Political training was, however, still backward. Had, in 1903, a group of delegates declared that the East African project was not within the scope of their mandate and that they desired a special congress to consider it after receiving instructions from their constituents the history of Zionism might read differently to-day. Emotions were, however, uppermost, and the movement had necessarily to suffer from the difficulties created by speech-forbidden Russia. Men always came and still come, out of Russia as out of an impenetrable forest. They bring part of the shadows with them. Some times these shadows are philosophy, sometimes rhetoric: always there remains the question how representative is this opinion.
When I came to America I was willing that my opinions should undergo a sea change. Jewish life was hard enough, for it was and is a current against the main stream of existence. Zionism was a current within that current, and one that selected its course along boulders. America might provide a new idea. It did not. It intensified every previous conclusion. Here leadership was still more consecrated to the policy of not leading. It had even the demerit that it carried out its policies at the expense of the Baron de Hirsch Fund. It lacked the remaining virtue of Western European charity, there those who called the tune paid the pipers. Opinionlessness except on the pettiest of ideas was the order of the day. The Yiddish press was fattening on its anti-German attitude—what a profound joke on its war attitude. The vulgarities of Jacob Gordon were being discussed by the so-called intellectuals of the East Side as serious contributions to the philosophy of life, while the East Side was a quagmire which had inevitably to birth Rosenthal gangsters and white slaves. The thing was written so large across the life east of the »Bowery and elsewhere, that on one occasion in Pittsburgh in 1902, I turned what was to have been a Zionist address into a discussion of turning the brothel- keepers out of the synagogue. I schemed to organize a “white button” brigade of Jewish youth who would not consort with fallen Jewesses, or betray Jewish girls. A dozen such fantastic ideas possessed me in 1902-3 during which time I delved into the depths of the American Jewish cloaca. I was so disheartened by the corruption around me that I obtained from Herzl a release of my promise to remain in America three years, and I offered this conclusion to the late Gustave Gottheil shortly before his death. “The rabbis of the rich congregations of New York have forfeited my respect because they do not seem to know what is happening below Twenty-Third street, and your communal leaders are wholly unworthy because they have provided nothing but an automatic Americanization factory on East Broadway,” and everytime I read the platitudes of the assimilations and their rabbinic satellites, I am tempted to reply: “judging by what you failed to do between 1890 and 1915 you have lost the right either to preach or direct us now.”
To-day the Jewish people together with all other peoples over the world face a world crisis and in considering the problems that make up this crisis they do not regard the Zionists as a party injury but as the active elements in the race.
We may not succeed, but we shall not wholly fail. Those who are against us on the other hand, will suffer no defeat, because they are making no attempt to achieve anything; therefore, at the end of twenty-five years it seems to me that the Zionists during that period have been greatly accummulating their strength. through action to meet just the storm that rages throughout the world—whereas all those who are not Zionists—some will hope for Zionist success—some will accept Zionist success if we achieve anything, and some will be even more embittered by success than by our theories, so that at the end of a quarter of a century we come back to where I started as an individual.
We have to teach the Jewish people their rightful position in the world and more than one-half the teaching must be accomplished by practice.