The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVIII, No. 4 · April 1916
79printed page
scan 6 of 25

dice to appreciate the fact. Nature itself decides the justice of the case.

Take, for example, the Jewish nation. According to all the rules of military philosophy they should have been swallowed up and utterly submerged in the maelstrom of opposing races among whom they persist, relatively, a handful.

Had the ethnic difference between the Jews and the rest of the world been slight or had the Jewish people been deficient in its ethnic will-power, these exiles from the east could not have survived the temptation to surrender and be at peace nor the pressure put upon them from without by the nations among whom they dwelt. It is folly to ascribe the continued persistence of the Jews to the fact that they lived in Ghettos. One might say with equal truth the Russians held out for a number of months against the attacks of the Japanese at Port Arthur because they lived in a fort! Were the Russians under compulsion to live ina fort? They might have come out and surrendered as, indeed, they ultimately did. So, too, the Jews might have come out from behind Judengasse and Ghetto-wall, embraced the religion of their oppressors and submitted to the will of the conqueror. This privilege has always been open to them. What prevented them? Briefly, strength of soul, persistence of the national will to struggle as an ethnic entity. This they did without armaments, military organizations and the like which were an arm of defence which they had lost in the wars with Rome. The rabbis, who were the accredited leaders of the Jewish masses and the captains of the thousands and tens of thousands, devised by every means within their power to create a kind of intellectual discipline governing every action of the daily life of the Jew through which the solidarity and national identity of the Jews might be maintained in the face of the hostile multifarious centres of attack radiating from alien peoples and environments. Sometimes these rabbis (teachers) gave fanciful reasons for their injunctions but the instinct which begot them was always the same, the conservation of the national identity. As the Rabbis could only retain their hold upon the mass of the Jews through this intellectual discipline, it followed that they held the ignorant Jew in abhorrence (“Split him open like a fish!” one rabbi said) because they felt that in the limited mode of struggle open to the Jew, the illiterate individual had no hold upon the national life-line and must be submerged by any chance wave from the ocean of anti-semitism. So, too, with the instinct of the herd for seeking out its own best interests, the Jews would not harbor a renegade no matter how repentant nor what the impelling force was that resulted in his apostasy! So, also, dissentients could not be tolerated in the state of siege in which the Jews were. In fact, quite an interesting study could be made by a biologist of the law of the herd as developed in an intellectual people driven by necessity to novel methods of self-preservation. (Not the least of the stupidities of Christendom is the singular impression that it has nothing to learn from post-exilic Israel.)

Now I do not cite the foregoing facts about this powerfully-struggling people by way of heaping encomiums upon the Jews, but to point out how profound the matter of ethnic struggle really is and how pitifully inadequate a struggle through force of arms alone is to give one race preponderance over another. The victory is simply not to be gained in that manner. Such victories are merely superficial and short-lived. Can we really entertain the idea that a number of empty-headed, obtuse boys drilled to wield the short-

sword or the rifle can superimpose their spirit upon a matured, cultivated nation? Doubtless they can create waste-places, they can destroy and bring degradation in their wake. But that is the limit of their capacity.

Even in America, we have to meet the onsets of different races and different mixtures of races clamoring for supremacy! Why the clamor? What do all these raucous voices hope to accomplish? Deep in the soul of every inhabitant lies the sure seed ot inevitable persistence or disintegration. Time will tell whether the composition of the German or Englishman is such as to entitle him to a distinct existence in this country in the ethnic state in which he arrived here. If their differentiation is sufficiently great, if they have sufficient ethnic soul to justify distinctive ethnic existence, heaven and earth will see to it that their points of dissimilarity are maintained to the extent to which nature and their strength of spirit entitles them. And this applies to Germans and Englishmen in other parts of the world as well. Time will deal justly with them, In the meantime, they have their great reservoirs of national inspiration and culture, Germany and Great Britain, and if, despite these sources of strengthening influence they cannot maintain themselves in other lands beyond the seas as distinct en-' tities, they do not deserve nor have they the right to be so maintained by force of arms. The resort to arm in such a case is the last argument of a weakling al tempting something beyond his natural capacity. It is the act of an envious invalid polluting the food he cannot eat. Nations dedicated to such an unfair method of struggle are the enemies of mankind, as well as of themselves.

The chief belligerents now at war have their own national reservoirs, they hold sovereign sway over the land which constitutes the national domicile and, save for the war into which they have plunged, the continuity of their national life is secure. But how about those nations who like the Jewish people, are without a home of their own? Are they, too, not entitled to a reservoir of national energy, a place in the sun of life? For them the struggle to maintain their national identity in other lands is a hundred fold more difficult because they have nowhere whence to draw sustenance with which to refresh their souls in the hard and unremitting war which the world is making upon them. Is peace on earth thinkable without justice to the small nationality? No, it is not thinkable and there will be no peace without justice to all that have been despoiled.

V.

We have now to consider to what extent, if any, the just requirements of international trade commit the world to the resort to arms. It would be easy to devote a book to the subject, but since this is out of the question within the limits of this article, I have the other alternative of being very brief.

But it really does not require a book to call the thoughtful reader's attention to the stupendous folly involved in the wholly unnatural tug-of-war existing in the trade relations of the nations. Every nation is strainng for exclusive markets. Why? Why will one nation set up tariffs and spur on the growth of an industry or manufacture which is being done better by its neighbor? We are familiar with instances of this in our own country. But besides this, it is well known, for example, that at least one of the belligerents has for years been selling some of its products to the South American market at a loss, simply to keep competitors out of the field and to retain control of it for