The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVIII, No. 4 · April 1916
78printed page
scan 5 of 25
78
THE MACCABAEAN FOR APRIL

which is one of its innumerable forms although not necessarily a permanent form. We are therefore committed to two axioms. One, of the basic nature of *struggle; two, of the permanent and basic nature of national differentiation. From these two axioms follow two concomitants. From the first one, which includes the acceptance of struggle as a law of life, flows the concomitant that it is wrong to surrender. 'Thou shalt not surrender' may be said to be a law of all life actuating the most unnoticeable creation of the universe alike with the Indian chanting his death-hymn and the nation battling until its last man falls and its women die by their own hand. There is no transcending this law in any code of morality that has ever been formulated. The concomitant of the second axiom i. e., of the basic nature of national differentiation, is that each nation must struggle to maintain its identity at all costs.

IV.

War is not a crime in itself but only when associated with a criminal object. A much greater crime both to the nation involved and to the world at large is submission to conquest. Submission to conquest involves, first, an immediate and far-reaching deterioration of the progressive elements in the conquered and a degradation of the whole moral gamut of the nation whose sinister influence emanates to all the world; second, the resultant influence upon the conqueror is to numb his sensitive faculties with the state of glut which is the prelude of that callousness, moral obloquy and inner stagnation which is characteristic of all surfeited nations; third, submission to conquest upsets the balance of power in the world of nations and leads to that fatal feeling of insecurity among other nations. We arc familiar with this last proposition in a general way, but have we ever stopped to consider its practical workings? It is very simple. For example, if a nation A conquers B, A must thereafter maintain a standing army to keep B in subjection. Now C cannot afford to allow its neighbor A to possess a stronger army than it (C) possesses because of the menace constituted by this disparity in armed force, C consequently feels compelled to increase its budget of army and navy expenses which it proceeds to do. D, a neighbor of C, happens to be in the same relation to C from a military standpoint as C was to A. As a result of C’s increase of armament D, too, must make an increased showing. And so the movement for increased armaments spreads from nation’ to nation. It is obvious that it would have been far better for B as well as for the rest of the world if it had fought until it was absolutely destroyed rather than submit to conquest. This, according to the Law of Struggle, is the cardinal sin. Thus we see that a single nation like Russia, for example, holding a dozen or more races in subjugation by force, becomes a morass of pestilential proportions carrying the gospel of permanent and increasing militarism to Germany and to all the other countries of the world. The most intolerable aspect of this condition of affairs is that, on account of the burglarious attacks upon the free life of the world by these robber nations, other nations who are content to live at peace with the world, i. e., to struggle along non-destructive lines, like the United States, are likewise compelled to arm and to stimulate

*I cannot now enter into the full definition of Struggle nor its differentiation from war. I refer the reader to the last chapter of my "Book of Pain Struggle" to be had from the Maccabaean Magazine, 44 East 23rd Street, New York City.

an enforced, easily-misunderstood martial propaganda in self-defense, until they, too, are drawn into the morass of militarism from which they vainly try to escape. The whole world is dragged willy-nilly after the triumphal chariot-wheels of the nations that have achieved success in subjugating other peoples. Thus it is that blood cries for blood, and no nation is absolved from punishment when one sister nation is permitted to be crushed by another.

lt becomes apparent, then, that the whole guilt of the military system of the world rests upon the shoulders of the nations that rob. If nations were to unite to-day on the principle of allowing each people the unrestricted possession of its own soil, the entire milı- tary system of the world would disappear like a nightmare because there would be left no object for the maintenance of such enormous expenditures of thought, energy and resources. The whole paraphernalia of war would be discarded as the junk of an outworn form of struggle peculiar to a hyena-period in the life of man. To talk of peace, of banding in organizations for the spreading of the gospel of disarmament is fatuous where such organizations or movements do not place the elimination of tyranny and the freeing of subject peoples in the foreground of their peace- programs. There can be no peace save the peace of righteousness—the peace of right-doing, of restoring to each what belongs to each.

The question suggests itself, doubtless. how can I expect the elimination of war since I have already conceded struggle as inevitable in itself and also for the maintenance of national individuality. I have already said, however, that struggle is not synonomous with war. There are innumerable forms of struggle. For example, I am struggling now when I strive through this paper to impose these ideas upon the reader in opposition to other ideas which I conceive to be hostile to my desires. We know of many struggles carried on in a similar manner which have prevailed although the armed forces of the enemy were aligned in opposition. Again, we have already seen that the real object of war is ethnic preponderance and also that ethnic preponderance obtained through war is deceptive, temporary and vicious even in its resultant influence upon the conquerors. Unless one nation absolutely destroys another— which is an absolutely barren act—no permanent conquest is possible through war. The French set out to conquer England which, technically speaking, they did. After a few generations of French rule, however, the garrison of conquerors absolutely disappeared, swallowed up by the alien life upon which they had come to impose their will, so that their traces are hardly discernible save to the student of genealogical trees and a few petrified customs, France has since received many a beating at the hands of England and its poor Norman province with it. Swords decided nothing here. The decisive element was the elementary qualities in the genius of the people. In other words, not war, but strength of soul, the spiritual forces of people decide as to who shall prevail, if either, or whether the struggle shall be a drawn one. The idea that one nation may foist its spirit upon another merely through the resulting issue of a battle is an absurdity. Where such a thing did occur—as through the conquest of one small tribe by another—the result is traceable to the fact that there was no real ethnic difference between the conflicting races and the war was simply a crude mode of contact and amalgamation which could have been accomplished more profitably without war, althouph the adversaries were too blinded by preju-