ents, Germania and Brittania, in exchange of notes, franker than is usually the case, leading to ultimatums and culminating in war. Let us weigh the arguments and recriminations of these two powerful political and commercial hierarchs and see how far their confessed reasons are justifiable motives for war. Incidentally, we may consider to what extent war, successful war, is effective in accomplishing the results sought through its means.
Quoth Germania: Brittania, you must surrender to me some of the vast territories you control.
Quoth Brittania: Why, pray? I conquered them in order to profit by them. Why shall I surrender any of them to you?
Germania: I must have more markets for my products. You control too many of the world's best outlets for my good.
Brittania: Nonsense! You know very well that I am a free trade country and you can invade my own markets including the British Isles on equal terms and compete with me. As a matter of fact, you have been underselling me wherever you could and in a great many productions I cannot compete with you at all, because I cannot make them. Why, I am one of the best customers you have! This is surely no reason for trouble between you and me!
Germania: Perhaps, these inequalities, if there are any, could be straightened out in some way through a meeting between some of the wise men of my country and those of yours. But you forget that my territory is congested. It overflows, and I must have more room in which to expand. My children leave me and go off to the far ends of the earth because of the overflow.
Brittania: Well, why not let them go? Let them emigrate. They can come in peaceably in my territories under my rule. Or, if they prefer, let them go to the United States of America where they have always been welcome.
Germania: That is all very well, but I will not send them in under another flag. I dare not!
Brittania: Why not, pray?
Germania: You know the answer as well as I do. When my children leave me to settle under your flag or the flag of the United States, they are lost to me in a few generations. I want them always to remain true Germanians, to carry the culture, traditions and prestige of their mother country with them wherever they go or, at least into such additional territory as they have to go. That is only possible under the flag of Germania, their own flag.
Brittania: How absurd! Is it not enough for you that you have a perpetual reservoir of tradition, culture and prestige in Germania? What more do you want?
Germania: Indeed! And how about yourself? Do you not have your own flag floating over practically every nook and corner of the world that could not be defended against the prowess of your sons? Do you think that you are the chosen of fortune? I, too, want my place in the sun!
a Mn Sep ne IE ze Dh er. En Dt A u et Brittania: Now you are treading upon dangerous ground, Germania! The whole world acknowledges the beneficence of my rule. I conquered because I am of a conquering race! As long as my flag floats over my world-possessions, the permanency of my race, my language, my traditions and culture is assured! I will not depart from this bulwark of my prestige! Upon it depends the existence of British influence upon the world.
Germania: So! Well, I, too, want a chance to prove the beneficence of my rule! I feel convinced in my heart and soul that it will prove better than yours! Besides, you have allied yourself against me with the enemies of my colleague, Austria, to dispute her hierarchy in the Balkans where you have no interests at all! You even joined hands with the Russian government, the hired assassin of France!
Britannia: I had to do this in defence of mv interests. Remember, Germania, you have been threatening me for years! Russia wishes to assure her predominance in the Balkans, in the same way as you and I wish to assure ours in other spheres, except that she is rougher in her ways, more short-sighted and
therefore less benevolent in her methods. She also has her political and economic problems.
Germania: Then in spite of the economic, political and moral reasons I have advanced, you refuse to cede me any territory?
Brittania: Because of the economic, political and moral reasons I have advanced, I must not only refuse to cede you any of my territory but if you dare to seize any belonging to my allies, I shall, in self-defence, be obliged to pitch into you.
Germania: You deny me a place in the sun, then? You are pushing the sword into my hand!
Brittania: You cannot hope to mend the matter now.
Germania: Well, I will mend it!
Brittania: And I will defend it!
And so they go after each other in the gruesome fashion with which we are acquainted.
III.
It will be evident from the foregoing little dialogue, that although the belligerents are impelled to wage war upon each other from motives that may truthfully be said to be economic, political and high-falutin, as each of them claims, nevertheless, these motives are economic, etc., in relation to the individual ambitions of each of the belligerents only. In other words, each nation is seeking its maximum good, as it understands it, for itself only and not for the other nations, so that when we say for example, that the war is being fought on economic grounds, it is a misnomer. The truth is that the war is fought on ethnic grounds, that is, each nation seeks its greatest economic and other advantages for itself—as auxiliaries for its continued ethnic preponderance. Thus, as I have tried to indicate, Germany, for example, is not interested in the well-being of its children in other lands unless they persist as Germans. If they prosper as newly-constituted Englishmen or Frenchmen, Germany considers them alienated and lost which, indeed, is the fact. The same holds good with reference to the attitude of the other nations toward its emigrants. This is an unavoidable position if we believe in nationalities as distinct ethnic entities. No nation by nature committed to the principle—as all of them are—that its ethnic continuity must be maintained and promoted will look with equanimity upon the submergence of its subjects in alien areas.
ru ER DEE A SE It is folly to infer from this that the continued existence of different races and nationalities is an evil which must be extirpated, as the so-called cosmopolitanist holds. Without entering into a lengthy discussion of this question, it should suffice to say that the climates of the world, if nothing else, are pledged to the perpetuation of different races of men. National forms are simply the natural expression of the lifeexperience of large ethnic groups. This they can no more eliminate than we can shed our skins. Can Chinamen by an act of will become Britons? Can the Eskimo become a Zulu? In the same way, one must be obtuse to imagine that the Frenchman can at will’ become a German or vice versa or even the Jew become an Irishman. I say, “even” because in the latter instance, neither the Jew nor the Irishman is permitted a distinct national expression in the political sense and yet, who can fail to find a radical differentiation between the two? But I had no intention of going so far into the discussion of this issue, if it is an issue. This thesis is founded upon the assumption that the existence of different races and nationalities in the world is a fact in nature which must be accepted as axiomatic.
The first axiom, to which allusion has been made before, is that struggle is basic; struggle, not war,
