Jewish bureaucracy. In spite of this, however, it was impossible to call them to book for their disloyal behavior, for we had no agency through which the recall could be exercised. Some times, these men were heads of fraternal insurance organizations; sometimes they were the heads of landsmannschaften;; and as long as they discharged their functions as insurance leaders or heads of hospitals or orphan asylums, the men and women who elected them to office felt no desire to call them to account for acts not directly related to insurance or hospitals or orphan asylums. In the meantime, their leaders were free to play fast and loose with Jewish ideals. The day has passed for such official leaders, just as the day has passed for the leadership of men who stubbornly refuse to account to the people for their acts. Judge Pam comes into Jewish life as the first national figure acclaimed directly by the people for service rendered to Jewish interests organized on a democratic basis.
What Is Going On In Palestine
FROM the reports received here on the Palestine situation, it is clear as to what is happening there. Palestine is being starved like a beseiged city. It can export nothing. It can import nothing. And being a land which depends for the most part upon imports, the embargo of the sea which has been established by the Allies simply means that industry and commerce cease. There is nothing to do but to wait for the end of the war. The colonists, some of the more enterprising of them, have turned to market-gardening, and are thus enabled not only to keep starvation away from their door, but also to bring some of the necessaries of life into the cities. The situation of a beseiged city becomes more critical from day to day. If food is obtained, the climax is postponed for a time, but nothing that the inhabitants may do can bring relief. The most obvious thing to do, of course, is to bring food into the land, or provide them with money with which food may be purchased. But it is conceivable that some thing more important than food is needed to cope with the situation. It is essential that the morale of the community be maintained. The social and economic structure must be maintained, in order that Palestine remain a community and not become a mass of hungry people. It is short-sighted philanthropy to think that a whole country can be treated as a bread line, to be fed in soup kitchens. What is important is the maintenance of such institutions and activities as are necessary for the life of the community. The community must be maintained intact. All communal functions must be discharged. Work should take the place of charity. The teacher, the pupil, the mender of roads, the shomer, the artisan,—all should be kept at their work, just as if the markets had not closed, and life were normal. If the colonists need funds to irrigate their land, and to prepare for the next season, it is better to provide them with the funds with which to pay the workmen, than to force both colonists and workmen to apply at the relief ofiices for their dailv bread.
Constructive Relief
THAT is the difference between the work of the Provisional Zionist Committee in Palestine, and that of other relief committees. The other committees see nothing but hunger, and adopt the simplest and easiest way of meeting the situation; they give
food. Speak to them of the larger relief, the keeping of the avenues of healthy life as open as possible, and they reply that this is no time for any thing but elementary relief. The payment of the salaries of teachers is not relief. The helping of the colonists to keep their farms in shape so that ruin does not overwhelm them is not relief. The building of necessary roads is not relief. In short, soup kitchens and loaves of bread for the hungry. The Provisional Committee adopts the other policy. It has been providing the schools with funds to maintain not only the teachers, but the children. It has maintained the Bezalel and its workmen. It is gathering loan funds for the colonists, and it is advancing in the form of loans money for the workmen’s associations. If some work could be found for the inhabitants of Jerusalem, it would prefer to provide them with some employment rather than have able-bodied men and women taking relief for months. This should be a reply to those Zionists who inquire why the Provisional Committee is collecting money for the relief of Palestine when the Joint Distribution Committee of the other three relief committees has appropriated about $20,000 per month for Palestine. In the first place, for the relief of Palestine as much as $50,000 per month is needed, according to the last report received from Dr. Thon. The $20,000 of the Joint Distribution Committee does not cover even that. In the second place, the appropriation of this committee does not provide for the schools, the institutions, the‘ colonies, and other important and necessary relief measures for the maintenance of Palestine communal life. All these needs the Provisional Committee aims to meet, and it is the only agency which has assumed the responsibility for upholding every bit of Jewish life, collective as well as individual, that existed in Palestine before the war broke out.
Being Made in Germany
W HILE we are discussing the demands of the Jewish people after the war, a number of questions are being decided for us. The report comes that the Warsaw Jewish Community appeared before the German officials and declared that they were interested only in obtaining cultural rights for the Jews. The nationalists present at the hearing insisted that national rights should be granted during the period of the occupation. Of interest also are the various articles that have appeared in leading German Tewish journals, in which officials in the Hilfsverein and other anti-national circles discuss the problem of the Jews in Poland in the manner of Russian anti-Semites, urging the segregation of the Jews there, and pointing out the danger to German Jewish interests if no barriers are erected between the hordes of Ghetto Jews and their more refined co-religionists. We may condemn such utterances as much as we please, but they are potent factors in the making of public opinion in’ circles that may have effective voices in the readjustment that is to follow the war. The friends of the Hilfsverein der Deutschen Juden in this country should read the articles written by Drs. Philippson, Geiger and Alexander. These articles are premonitions of what is to happen when our anti-nationalist friends are fully organized to carry through their policies. They are organizing in Germany—and the anti-nationalist groups in Europe look upon the anti-nationalist organizations in America as subsidiary bodies to be used in furtheringe their policies.