The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVIII, No. 2 · February 1916
29printed page
scan 7 of 28
Facsimile · scan 7 of 28
Scan of p. 29
Text · transcribed from the scan

the world from an entirely different angle. It projected its own state into humanity at large and professed to see visions of a nationless society. His own abnormal condition the Jewish cosmopolitan declared to be the final word of wisdom and proceeded to tear out of his heart the last vestiges of sympathy with his people. The tremendous growth of national solidarity attendant upon the introduction of universal education and the rise of material prosperity, he decried as the last agonizing groan of a dying monster. All the exalting nobility and self-sacrifice involved in the work for national weal was lost upon his blind passion. He saw nothing but red. This type of Jew has wrought great ruin in our life and we still see and feel the effect of his pernicious activity.

A Dee PR RD Wr Au rear. A The European upheaval has at last torn the veil off the eyes of the most simple-minded. It has taught us Jews a great lesson. The world at large, and our people in particular, have paid an awful price for it, but it is a lesson worth having, especially when the cost was not of our bargaining. We now recognize that nationalism is a power of the utmost significance and greatest influence in human affairss. We now understand why all nations, small or big, cling so tenaciously to their individuality. A very brutal, cruel operation we have been put through. . But we are cured—let’s hope for all time—of the dangerous folly of building our future upon the disappearance of nationalities. One might as well build on the extinction of personality: both are substantially the same.

The National Standard of Justice.

The second vital lesson which the war has brought home to us in an imperishable fashion, is the exact definition of justice. It was not excogitated by some luminary of the philosophical firmanent, it is being acted out on the fields of battle. Of course, it lacks the niceties of hair-splitting argumentation and is perhaps faulty in logic, but, then, it has the undisputed advantage of being transparently clear, —a praise hardly to be accorded ethical writers. Heretofore, the peaceable citizen in the hours of leisure, had thought that the code of morality elaborated by famous theologians or scientists must be rigorously adhered to if one was to be good and hold the respect of one’s fellow men. There was a ready-made set of precepts alike applicable to all peoples, conditions, and places. The brotherhood of men, irrespective of color, creed or race, hovered before the longing eye of the true humanitarian and flowed mellifluous from the glib tongue of the popular orator. It still is the favorite theme of the preacher and haranguer and will continue to be so to the end of time. However, there is no gainsaying the fact that the war has administered a severe jolt to the abstract theories of our time. Many a cherished illusion has been blasted, and not even long-winded morality has withstood the shock.

The truth is that nothing has really changed. The war has only demonstrated, in a ruthless manner, what should have been known to all. And that is, that national interests are supreme; that the highest standard by which to measure individual conduct is the good of the people. A self-evident truth, a time-honored maxim, indeed,—and essentially ethical, at that. Nevertheless, it required a war of nations, an unparalleled cataclysm, to put it in concrete form before a sophisticated world.

A little digression into the realm of speculative

thought will be deemed pertinent. The highest expression of righteousness is apparently implied in the admonition to offer your left cheek when the right one is smitten. Obviously, this moral precept should hold good on the part of all men. So that the supposed assailant is likewise enjoined to put forward his other jowl when I hit him on the first. If not, my non-resistance would only serve to breed more evil. The hand that struck me would never relax unless fatigued by physical exhaustion. If Iam to share my bread with the other, so is the other to do by me. In other words, it is a case of universal non-resistance and mutual help, which means that everyone’s conduct is to be such as not to conflict with the interests of others. Should there arise a dispute between two equally moral the point at issue would be settled pacifically and amicably by mutual agreement or by the decision of a third party. Should two persons of unequal social standing be at variance, say king and subject, the higher stationed individual would enjoy a larger share of attention. He being clothed with more authority by the people, his interests are considered superior. If an individual should place himself athwart the interests of a group, he would ultimately be compelled to yield ground. The concern of the manv has ethical prioritv over that of the one.

Gauged by the same measure, the interests of the minority in general are subordinate to those of the majority. At this point the moralist would rightly enter a vigorous protest. His emphatic claim would be that the interests of the minority ought not under any circumstances to be sacrificed in favor of the majority. Each group, as each individual, has a right to live and prosper. And the ingenuity of social thinkers is taxed to its limit in finding a suitable way of safeguarding the smaller units of society. Here we come to a conclusion. If within the confines of a body politic higher ethics demands a vouchsafed place for the minority, what shall we say of the interests of a whole people, small though it be as compared to the world at large? Can anyone expect of a people to forego aspirations in favor of others? Even if humanity were a compact, politically organized whole, that part of it which every extant nation would constitute would be entitled to full consideration. So much more so when mankind is split into a thousand and one peoples and nations. Why, then, should one cultural group give place to the commands of other groups? If individuals should act alike toward each other, what shall we say of nations? Unhappily, there is no higher tribunal that could adjudicate international differences, and war is still resorted to as the ultimate means of settling a dispute. However, this state of affairs does not in anyway change the right of supremacy inherent in each and every people. Practical needs regulate and modify international relations. Relative strength counts most. But ethically there is but one standard— the national.

Still whatever are the moral opinions of the detached thinker, the present death-grapple of so many nations has conclusively shown that the national standard of justice is the only one to which man is capable of rising in supreme moments. Everyone of the combatants is confident that he fights on the right side and his prayers to God are sincere and unalloyed. If all speak of justice in general as the cause of the battles, it is because everyone of the belligerent nations views justice, and the world in general, through its national angle and assumes its interests to be identical with those of all but its immediate antagonists.