ing of piteous letters, a wailing demand that this hunger of the starving be stilled. The emphasis was placed upon the abject, staring misery of our people in Europe, but there was no lifting of the audience to the idea that probably there may be some way of working so that in addition to the relief of patent distress, the future of our people may be secured. The story of huge calamity where the individual feels powerless to affect the issue does not bring about a desire to be of greater assistance. Its effect is to paralyze all effort. One is moved to action only when one feels that action will accomplish something to remove the cause of distress one feels. The general relief measures of American Jewry at first suffered from anemia of feeling and sympathy. Sympathy was there, but it lacked vigor. Feeling was there, but it had no objective. The great outbreak in Europe found American Jewry merely a mass of dissonant beings, with no real national interests except those of elementary defence. It found us unable to cope with a situation which individual generosity or sympathy could not help, a situation that demanded national relief, sacrifices of individuals upon a national scale. Had we felt ourselves a nationality, the European war would have provoked acts of heroism and of astounding self-sacrifice. We have not felt the national pull to make sacrifices, for everything we have done has been poisoned by the selfishness of individul existence. Under these circumstances, men worth half a million have not been ashamed to give only one hundred dollars to the relief fund. Families living in luxury have sacrificed less than what it costs to run an automobile, or to maintain a seat in the opera house, for the relief fund. The whole relief problem has been reduced to the three cents a day to feed an infant. Into this confusion, the one bright light, that comforts and gives reassurance, is the Zionist ideal, and the Zionist way of looking at things. It is not accident that Zionists, a minority among the Jewish people, are the majority among the relief workers. It is not an accident that in these troublesome times, Zionists feel compelled to force their thoughts upon American Jewry. It is inevitable that Zionists, feeling keenly Jewish distress, should be the first to sacrifice themselves and to feel that now is the time to arouse every other Jew to feel a sense of equal responsibility.
Mr. Brandeis at Carnegie Hall.
THE clearest exposition of the democratic ideal in Jewish life has been contributed during the past seven or eight months by Mr. Louis D. Brandeis, in his addresses on the Congress movement. At no time in the history of American Jewry have we had so brilliant an analytical mind, so cogent a thinker, operating with Jewish ideas and expressing them with dignity and grace. In his Carnegie Hall address, however, Mr. Brandeis connected his views on democracy with the question of Jewish rights. There have been some— Zionists included—who have resented the intrusion of the problem of democracy into Jewish affairs at this time, Mr. Brandeis now makes clear the unavoidable necessity which compels the application of democratic ideals to the solution of the Jewish problem. Our radical friends have been greatly bothered with the difficulties of formulating Jewish demands They have made so much of those difficulties that they have lost sight of the greatest difficulty of all, to wit, the difficulty of giving strength and power to Jewish demands. All of us know that justice and humanitv
stand behind the demand for Jewish rights, the demand for national recognition, the demand for a national center, but these demands based on justice and humanity are not in themselves potent in convincing the nations that justice should be done to the Jewish people. We must be prepared to stand behind our demands, and impress the world with the reality of our conviction and to win these rights through sacrifice and devotion. And how are we to rally our powers, and make our strength servicable to the Jewish cause? Certainly not by transferring either to the nations or to influential persons of our own nationality the responsibility and the burden of liberating us. He who would be free must himself strike the first blow. The Jewish people themselves must participate in their own emancipation, not by vicarious sacrifices, but by giving themselves, their thought, their possessions, their time; they must be prepared to do the same things that other nations are now doing to maintain their own existence. Therefore, the essential first step in the direction of obtaining Jewish rights is to organize the Jewish power and influence and determination to sacrifice. The Congress thus becomes, as Mr. Brandeis has repeated every time he has spoken on the subject, and rightly reiterated, a means to an end, the end being the self-emancipation of the Jewish people.
The Preliminary Conference.
THE Congress Organization Committee has set March 26th as the date for the holding of the preliminary conference which is to decide the ways and means for calling the American Jewish Congress. This step was taken with a view, in part, to transferring to the preliminary conference without further delay the vexatious questions that have been the subject of negotiation and discussion between the various organizations interested in the Congress. The preliminary conference is to be the second step in the direction of organizing American Jewry for the Congress, which, in turn, will be the essential first step in the movement for acquiring Jewish rights. Back of the preliminary conference are the organizations favoring the Congress and the local Congress Committees, which are to be transformed into the election and pre-election machinery for the organization of the Congress. For the Conference, the unit of representation is the lodge or society or congregation. For the Congress, the unit of representation has not yet been selected. Some time ago, Dr. Isaac A. Hourwich proposed that the delegates to the Congress be selected by different groups of Jews in every community, the synagogue Jews voting together, the radicals together, the various lodges together, the Zionists by themselves, etc. This in his opinion would be the easiest way out of a difficult problem. On the other hand, it is proposed that the elections be held in the regular way of a municipal election; the city to be divided into several districts, and every man and woman voting in his or her district. It is evident that while this seems the simplest it would be the most expensive method. The preliminary conference will have the important task of devising a workable scheme that will not entail too large an expense. It is to be hoped that national organizations interested in the Congress will participate in the preliminary conference where all the important questions will be discussed and settled:; Congress—conventions should be held at least two weeks before March 26th, to elect delegates to the Conference.
