The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVIII, No. 2 · February 1916
34printed page
scan 12 of 28

A Reply to Jewish Pessimists

BY DR. SCHMARYA LEVIN

IT really true that at one time the Jewish nation possessed heroes, and that today these heroes have entirely disappeared? Is it really true that the long, dark, bitter Goluth has robbed the Jewish nation of its heroism, the dearest and noblest virtue a nation can possess? Is it really true that the Jewish nation has become internally disrupted, divided into many fractions, like so many atoms, which struggle with each other in the whirlwind of life, and have caused the Jewish nation to become but the semblance of its former self, thus depriving it of the magnetic power of attraction?

We have pessimists enough who reply in the affirmative to all these questions. They have ceased to believe that the Jewish nation, as such, can be set up again, and they advise us to hasten the assimilative process which has enveloped us, that we may be fused with our neighbors, become obliterated, as soon as possible. They advise that each of us, individually, should seek his own safety, as best he can, by delivering himself into the clutches of an unkind Fate, without offering stubborn resistance, that each of us should cast himself spontaneously into the new world, should allow himself to be swallowed up in a new sphere, and peacefully adapt himself to the conditions of the new life.

We have enough pessimists who assert that the present war in which the Jewish population of the various lands is so deeply involved, will have a great influence on the Jewish migrations. They prophesy, that the antagonism, created by the war among the Jews of the various belligerent nations, will not end with the cessation of hostilities.. The English, the French and the Russian Jews, that is the Jews of the allied countries, will have no dealings with the Jews of Germany and Austro-Hungary. The bond of nationalism, which has until now kept them together, has been torn asunder and they will have nothing in common with each other. Our new prophets go still farther! They maintain that the antagonism among these groups will deal a deathblow even to the Zionist organization, whose superstructure is founded upon nationalism. The Zionist Congresses will become an impossibility and the sublime ideal of a universal Jewish unity will henceforth belong to the historic Dast!

re Were there any truth in this prophesy, were it fullfilled, it would be the most convincing proof that the Jewish nation, as such, is destroyed and is on the verge of disappearing from the world-scene. It would prove that the Jewish nation lacks the cement, the potential energy, the hidden heroism, without which no nation can exist. The Zionist movement, in the last few decades, would be similar to a volcano which belches out before being extinpuished.

Fortunately, this prophesy is false and will never be fullfilled. The prophet who uttered it, lives far from, and does not understand, the people of whom he prophesies. He does not know its soul, does not feel its pulse, and his utterances merely reflect the pessimistic sentiments of a verv small Jewish group, a

group which before the war had little intercourse with the Jewish nation. It is one of the small Jewish sects who have long ceased to sympathize with the plight of their brethren and who revive only when a catastrophe befalls the Jews. The Goluth also bestowed upon us the remarkable gift of catastrophicJudaism! This small group has long lost its faith in the Jewish national heroism. With the coming of the war it was weakened still more and deprived of the last spark of solidarity. Comes the prophet of this small sect and cries out in his perplexity, that the Jewish nation is destroyed and that the time is ripe to begin preparing ıts tombstone.

Ya el De - ke Ars est ah He who has closely observed the development of the Jew in the last few decades, who has listened intently to the sentiments of the Jewish masses, who has closely watched the change in the partly assimilated youth of Western Europe, must admit that in recent years the bond of nationalism among the various scattered portions of the Jewish nation has, in a measure, become stronger and firmer than in all the past generations of modern times. The Jewish literature, both Hebrew and Yiddish, has made greater progress in the last forty years, than in the entire Haskalah epoch. It has become more vigorous, more instructive, richer in subject matter, broader and more artistice And since literature must draw its nourishment from life, we can see in its development the best proof that the Jewish life has become more abundant and richer in a national sense. Literary accomplishments lacking national spirit and national zeal leave no impression. They are abortive accomplishments whose appearance is not perceptible and whose disappearance is not noticed. And we have a convincing proof! At the time when the Hebrew literature passed through a great development, the German, the Russian, the French and the English Yiddish literature deteriorated by degrees. ‘The best authors and artists departed from us, broke away from the center. Each of them considered it a distinguished honor to become a German, a Russian or a French author. Almost without exception there remained the modern theologians, who were compelled to follow the Jewish style although their works were composed in foreign languages. Therefore the entire Jewish literature in foreign tongues has taken on a theological character, as if the Jewish life had dragged itself, heart and soul, into the synagogue, as if the Jewish life had lost all its power of attraction and had hidden itself in the Beth Hamidrash corner.

Jewish heroism, in recent years, has also adopted a new form. It has begun to be constructive by emancipating itself from its own Goluth. There is a vast difference between the Goluth heroism and the emancipated heroism. The emancipated heroism is productive, it creates in life certain prominent values whose worth can be ascertained. The Goluth heroism, the enslaved heroism, may possess the same power, but no one notices it, for its power is exhausted that it might not be suppressed by an opposing force. The emancipated heroism creates the hero who admires and is admired; the Goluth heroism makes the martyr who arouses more pitv than admiration, more svmpathy