population affects a nation only insofar as it is evidenced in emigration. This factor then, instead of making for cosmopolitanism, as some cosmopolitanists fondly imagine, has been shown to be fairly tame and harmless. The upshot then of all that was said here, is that nationalism is a persisting fact, that the various nationalities are not doomed as such to disappear, that while their political organization and political forms of living may undergo changes, their cultural content, because of their constantly flowing, uninterrupted cultural life, is permanent. Hence nationality as a cultural entity is permanent and under normal modern conditions not subject to death. Emigration is really not a factor affecting the essential existence of a given nationality. Nay, more, the very cosmopolites, adherents, as they are, for the most part, of socialism or anarchism, seeing as they do a speedy reorganization of society such as will make emigration unnecessary, ought least of all to doubt the permanence of nationalism —at least cultural nationalism—because realization of their aims would eliminate the chief disturbing factor—emigration. Emigration (not travel) they ought to know—is not undertaken unless absolutely needed, for it involves a most tragic breaking up of all economic, cultural and sentimental ties and is resorted to only as a final extremity. Hence, if their views were realized and emigration precluded, how then could nationalities disappear? On the contrary, each added year of history, of cultural progress and cultural life weaves closer and closer the ties holding together each nationality, adds to the sum total of factors and achievements by which each given nationality is not only strengthened, but is justified in its existence.
DurrT - Drau en TA ee er The corollary for us Zionists from the thesis of the permanence of nationalism is natural enough to perceive: Since nations do not disappear, why should we? Where puny insignificant nationalities, that have given no important cultural values to the world such as the Serbs, Bulgarians, Rumanians, etc., are assured national existence, why should not we, the oldest civilized people of the Western World, admittedly of the highest capacity, who have ineffaceably left our impress upon the historv of the world?
tr te re SD a ee er a en De N ee ee Di There are those of course, such as the Jewish founders of Socialism, Ferdinand Lasalle and Karl Marx, who urged our submergence among our host- nations. Such urging was done, by the way, at just the time when another Socialist confrere of theirs, Moses Hess, brought forth his attempt at a solution of this last nationalistic problem, pointing to Zionism as a better and truer solution. But such submergence is entirely futile, as the question of nationalism would hardly be solved thereby. There are others who assert that we are not a distinct nationality—but eine kon- fession, yet who fain would seek surcease of sorrow for Israel and who could only find it in complete absorption by the other nations, thus bringing about a most inglorious ending of our history. They make ridiculous the generations that have been martyred, so that we might live and carry on our heritage until the days of a happier existence for us, when our real living destiny 'will be exercised and none of that famous post-mortem one of the reform rabbis.
These pitiful apologists of our national death may be discounted by virtue of the fact, that the Jewish people are as yet not ready to be eaten up and that the other nations are afraid of the indigestion which might be the result.
So much for nationalism as an unescapable fact,
the final persistence of which is undoubted, even if that were undesirable. But cultural nationalism is quite the reverse. It is most beneficial.
The nation is the larger individual. If you will, interpret it along Hegelian lines as forming the true synthesis between the individual and all the rest of humanity. It is the vehicle by which the individual expresses himself to humanity at large, by which he works for all humanity. A great artist who produces cultural values—and we are not speaking merely of works of civilization, such as inventions, discoveries, innovations, etc., in the field of science which by virtue of their impersonal character are truly international—such an artist draws on his immediate environment which he knows thoroughly and naturally sympathizes with—his own national characters and happenings—and therefore understands. Indeed, the more truly the artist represents and typifies his own nation, the greater, the more genuine, is his service to the world, where only the true, the supremely true is of any account.
Where an artist of one nationality tries to act as interpreter for another nationality, be his activities ever so earnest, his productions will rarely attain greatness. This is unfortunately the tragic case with Jewish artists among the other nations of the world. But wherever a great Jewish artist turns to Jewish subjects, he at once attains the pre-eminence denied him elsewhere—witness our own Bialik, Peretz, Lillian, Schatz, etc.
This is one consideration. There is another one just as important: Nationality, being the result of an age-long adaptation of a race to natural and historical conditions such as climate, principal mode of living (trading, manufacture, etc.), relations toward neighbors, common efforts to ward off incursions of enemies, in many cases, common religion and, certainly, common ideals and tendencies historically developed, means distinct individuality, which means distinct national character. Now in the arena of universal culture each nation brings to bear its cultural productions, results of that national particularity. This results in clash, in competition with those of other national individuals. Now, whatever be the views of the readers on competition in the economic field—let them prefer, if they will, co-operation— in the field of scientific inquiry and cultural activity competition is a conditio sine qua non. French Iyrical poetry in the nineteenth century and French modern music bears the decided imprint of having been stimulated by a sort of national envy of similar German activity. German poetic literature of the eighteenth century had undergone decided stimulation by English literature. German literature—especially German romanticism—and Byron stimulated the development of the Russian and Polish literatures. Schiller stimulated our own secular Haskalah literature in Hebrew. Consider the influence of the French decadents upon Polish, German and Russian literatures, of Ibsen upon modern, especially German drama, etc., and the reactions thereupon. This is nothing if not cultural, intellectual competition produced by the clash of different national entities. This is the friction productive of the sacred spark of cultural energy. And this divergence, between the nations is a potent cultural factor. Could this be, if there were naught in the world but a wearisome monotonous, platitudinous sameness as there is amone the countless millions in China?
This divergence, then, between the nations is not only a potent cultural factor, but a most advantageous