The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVIII, No. 1 · January 1916
3printed page
scan 3 of 32
Facsimile · scan 3 of 32
Scan of p. 3
Text · transcribed from the scan

refusal of all other general relief committees to assume a definite and certain responsibility for Palestine has compelled the Provisional Committee to take up general Palestine Relief. This work also.entails large expense to the Provisional Committee. The Emergency Fund meets the budget of our Zionist schools and institutions in Palestine. This means not only paying the teachers for their work, which is relief in a larger sense, but it also means that the children in the schools, deprived of support at home or from their parents living in Russia or Galicia, must be fed and clothed, which is elementary relief. From the Emergency Fund must also come the funds for maintaining our organization activities. All our other work, the work of the Transfer, the work of Palestine relief, the work of maintaining the Zionist schools and institutions, would be impossible unless the Zionist organization here and abroad were maintained intact, and at an unusual degree of efficiency. It is of importance not only for the direct Palestine work we are doing, but also for the future of the Zionist movement, that during this crisis not anti-Zionist, or anti-nationalist influences secure predominance in Jewish life, but that the Zionist flag be held aloft, that the Zionist ideal be held at the summit of Jewish life. We cannot now permit that our organization submerge itself. It is the Emergency Fund that enables us to maintain our position.

A Coalition Actions Committee.

V. JABOTINSKY, the well-known Russian Zionist, makes an interesting and valuable proposal in the letter printed elsewhere in this issue. He advocates the formation of a coalition Inner Actions Committee, and bases his suggestion upon the facts that in time of war all parties presumably interested in the welfare of the cause are usually drawn into the administration of governments, and that the Inner Actions Committee as now constituted represents only one party or tendency in Zionism. It is a fact patent to all interested in the Zionist organization that the Inner Actions Committee has, for obvious reasons, not been able to function with the same freedom and authority as before the war. The members of the Committee owe allegiance to various political entities. The seat of the Committee is in one of the belligerent lands. Communication with members cut off from the administrative seat is difficult. At the outbreak of the war, the Inner Actions Committee declined to remove the headquarters from Berlin, although it subsequently established a branch office in Copenhagen, and recognized in a measure the activities of the Provisional Committee in the United States. But legally, and actually, the authority for the direction of Zionist affairs is now, as it was before the outbreak of the war, vested exclusively in the hands of the Inner Actions Committee, located in Berlin, with one member in New York, one in London, one in Russia, one presumably in Constantinople, and two remaining in Berlin. The fundamental mistake of the Inner Actions Committee—from a superficial knowledge of the circumstances—was its refusal to transfer actually and officially its headquarters from a belligerent land to a neutral land. There may be potent reasons for its refusal, but we have not been informed. The fact remains that deliberation over Zionist policy has become impossible in the Inner Actions Committee. The decisions are bound to be uninformed. vacillating and without definite object. Mr. Jabotinsky’s suggestion, therefore, for a coalition ministry, although made late in the day, is therefore

in order. It will have the additional value of bringing into the Inner Actions Committee men who represent new horizons and give decided added authority to whatever decisions are arrived at. A criticism of the Inner Actions Committee, which arises independently of war conditions, is the fact that the present administration regards itself as representative of a victorious Zionist party. Zionism is not in a position to allow its central administration the privilege of regarding itself as the party that has won in a Congress. The organization is a volunteer organization, and all administrations should include members of all recognized parties. In fact, a coalition government should be the desideratum of the Inner Actions Committee at all times. Had that been the case with the present Committee, there would have been more important influences at work in it than are found there now.

Knights of Zion Convention.

THE leaders of the Knights of Zion may be depended upon to organize a fine demonstration convention. They have in the past shown their mettle. The convention just closed was in effect an unusual demonstration, for Zionism is everywhere the topic of interest, not only among Jews, but among well-wishers of the Jewish people as well. The mass-meetings arranged were in the highest degree successful, and important pronouncements on Zionism were made by Mr. Brandeis and Dr. Levin, who were ably supported by Judge Julian Mack, Max Shulman, Nathan D. Kaplan, Leon Zolotkoff, Dr. H. M. Kallen, Judge Hugo Pam and others. The West is a large field for Zionist work, and conditions are much more favorable for the spread of Zionism than in the East. Our comrades in Chicago have adopted plans which will lead to a successful invasion of the middle-western states. The endorsement of the idea of state associations, is a step in advance. Such state asociations will enable the Zionist workers to concentrate in fields that are familiar to them. They will have their work circumscribed. Much better work can be expected under such conditions. The establishment of a bureau in Chicago, with Leon Zolotkoff in charge, will provide the technical facilities that have to date hindred progress. We have no doubt that the Convention will stimulate a healthy deevlopment and added support to all Zionist institutions.

The Menorah.

THE Menorah Convention held in Philadelphia during the holiday week made clear that organized students are slowly finding their position in Jewish life. While the Menorah was organized as a non-partisan study association, it is developing men and women who are interested not only in the academic phases of Jewish life, but also in the practical application of theories. The Menorah man cannot be held in leash, once he knows what Jewish life has been. He is bound to go from theory to practice. In other lands, the Jewish student is not unlike the non-Jewish student. The student body is usually an active body, concerned in the politics, the economics, the art and literature of their people, not as neutrals, but as partisans. A state of neutrality is a state of arrested interest. There is bound to come a moment when neutrality must be abandoned and the Jewish student will have to decide whether he is for or against orthodoxy or reform, Zionism, nationalism, etc. From the discussions held at the convention, it is evident that the Menorah men will soon graduate.