The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVIII, No. 1 · January 1916
12printed page
scan 20 of 32
12
THE MACCABAEAN FOR JANUARY

for the bone of liberty thrown them or promised us excised the references to Zion from the prayer books, had no conception of Zionism in our sense for the simple reason that this Zionism did not exist. The past generations talked about a Messiah who would lead back Israel to Palestine, etc. That, of course, a modern man cannot believe, but a sane, honest, scientific movement to reclaim the land, to purchase the land that was stolen from us, to ask the world to protect us, those of us who wish and can return, against that Zionism no sane Jewish scholar ever preached in the past, for it did not exist either in thought or in the possibility of realization.

What then is Zionism? Zionism is the desire on the part of many Jews to procure by purchase the land of our fathers and establish a politically secured, publicly recognized home for the oppressed Jews of the world. But some Jews are always afraid of what the Christians will say. They are on excellent terms with their Christian neighbors and yet they know them so little that they are always afraid that they will misunderstand them. Why an honest man, with honorable intentions, in a broad-minded country should be afraid to dream and labor for a mighty cause is beyond my ability to grasp. We have as much right to live as any people on the face of the earth. England does not seem to have such fears as our good friends entertain, for on August 14, 1903, in a letter from the Foreign Office, regarding a place for a politically assured and publicly recognized Jewish Home. Mr. Clement Hill writes to the Jewish Colonial Trust that the Marquis with Lansdowne has studied the question, and "if a site can be found which the Trust and His Majesty's commissioner consider suitable, and which commends itself to his Government, Lord Lansdowne will be prepared to entertain favorably proposals for the establishment of a Jewish colony or settlement on conditions which will enable the members to observe their national customs."

If we are scattered, granting that we are given an invitation to scatter ourselves, then what becomes of our Jewish spirit, our Jewish Religion for the sake of which our good friends tell us God has scattered us.

When we read even superficially the pages of our suffering and the noble help of ruling nations we see that our problem is plainer than it has ever been since ‚the dispersion, assimilation or preservation. Both Anti-Zionists and Zionists cry out against assimilation. They differ only as to the method to be pursued of preserving the remnants of Israel. Or am I wrong when I assume that the Anti-Zionist also cries out against Assimilation? Can it be possible that they have a tacit understanding with the naturalization officers in every land that we are painlessly and noise- lessIy and unsuspectingly to commit suicide? Well, that would not be as inhuman as the Russian method, nor as galling as the German method, but to us Jews is as thoroughly unsatisfactory. We want to live as Jews without any promise that under the name of Modern Judaism, we are going to have the Jew melted out of us

That I am not dreaming but know whereof I speak, let me introduce you to one of the finest Christian gentlemen, pleading the cause of Jew, in his wonderful book, "Israel in Europe." No Jew could have been more fair nor could any one be more severe with the Anti-Semite than F. G. Abbott, and yet this is his honest reading of the hand of history, and therefore he regrets the shameful practices of Anti-Semites: "Anti-Semitism is a movement retrogressive in a twofold sense. Retrogressive in as much as it shows that the current of European humanism is flowing back-

ward, and retrogressive in as much as it has actually checked the gradual and voluntary assimilation of the Jew."

The dearest friends of the Jews have recognized that if they would only let us alone, give us a little peace, a little kindness, a little liberty and a little modern education, and social standing, the Jewish problem will solve itself, we shall painlessly, voluntarily, and joyfully commit suicide by way of assimilation. Recognizing this fact, if we had nothing else to speak about, we cry out in our anguish, we don't want to be absorbed, we don't want to die a sweet death. We want to live, live as Jews, live as a blessing to humanity, now that the world needs us more than ever before. As Jews, knowing and feeling our own genius, understanding the genius of all other peoples, we know as thoroughly as the prophets did that the world does not know the meaning of Religion as the Jew understands it, does not know the meaning of the spiritual forces that play in human life as the Jew does, has not the courage to be guided by the divine within man, and that if the Jew is absorbed, we feel there would be lost to the world a priest-people who would have lived their message in their own land, as an example to all the world.

In Russia the Jews form 4.6% of the total population, but 94. of them live in the Pale of settlement, about 6,000,000.

“I can testify,” said a great Christian scholar, one of the greatest honest writers on Jewish affairs,” that nothing in Europe is so poor, no beings earn their crust of rye bread with such bitterness as 9/10 of the Russian Tews.

In Odessa—I am picking out just at random—there are 48,500 souls. 1/3 of them lived on 120 lbs. of coal for the winter. Of 60,000 patients 33,000 are Jews, although the Jews are only 1/3 of the population. 63% of the Jewish dead are buried free.

The Jews of this country are always looking for a home. Russia will not let them live, nor will she let them go without a passport, and a passport costs money, and money they have not; they have not enough to live nor enough to die on. Even if they could obtain from the benign Paternal Government money to leave, where shall they go? England and the United States, the most liberal countries with land sufficient to populate a new world, even these have "Immigration Laws" and even a blind man can read the meaning of the Immigration Laws.

In every land we are giving up our life to the surroundings, some of the noblest and best of our people are being drawn away from our ranks, and in ever fewer numbers we are asked to keep up the unequal conflict with the world forces, very few of them friendly to the struggling, aspiring, faithful Jews. It almost seems as if in a world of hypocrisy and bloodshed and make-belief love, there is no room for faithful servants of God.

Through indifference, through baptism, through secession, through intermarriage we are losing our men and our women, our boys and girls, our culture and our distinctiveness. "The sun of liberty dissolves the ties more readily than the fires of the Inquisition."

Here the Anti-Zionists tell us to be a good citizen one must be an Anti-Zionist but in Germany scholars. Mommsen, Treitschke and Paulsen say that to be a eood German one must be a Christian.

There are I am told over 100 English societies alone for the purpose of undermining the Faith of Israel and stealing her men and women from her fold.

Let me read the baptisms so far as they have been

UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS AT URBANA-CHAMPAIGN