The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVII, No. 5 · November 1915
130printed page
scan 17 of 26
130

Reviews and Comments

JEWISH LIFE IN MODERN TIMES* By ISRAEL COHEN

SRAEL COHEN, one time English Secretary to the Zionist organization at Berlin and now, by the curious irony of Jewish affairs in the world of politics, interned in a prison camp in Germany as a Britisher, has written a monumental volume which bids fair to become a standard on the subject of which it treats. It is clearly a work into which much conscientious thought and labor has been put, and the result is fully commensurate with the effort expended to make it thorough, reliable and, what is also important, readable.

The work is subdivided into seven "books"—all comprised in the one-volume—each book being preceded by an introduction which is a kind of philosophical prelude to the facts, figures and descriptions which follow. Mr. Cohen endeavors to cover every phase of Jewish life in the world faithfully and without overemphasis or undue partisanship at any point. In fact, his tendency to be objective and to avoid polemic and the exaggeration incident thereto makes his work solid, and scholarly but, of course, he runs into the danger here and there of being somewhat prolix, tho that is seldom the case.

It must be admitted that he handles his over-abundant material with skill, and manages to bring the orderly approach to his diffuse subject in which so many of the pseudo philosophers on Jewish life are lacking. To illustrate his method, one can hardly do better than to quote some of his chapter headings. Thus in Book I., he views the Jewish people in “Dispersion and Distribution,” “Diversity of Composition,” and—nevertheless—“Solidarity.”

In Book IT. or the Social Aspect, as he calls it, he considers “The Community,” “The Family,” “The Home,” “Home Life and Customs,” “Philanthropy,” “Morality,” “Social Life” and “Racial and Physical Characteristics.” In Book III., consideration is given to the “Acquisition of Civil Rights,” “Sufferings in Bondage,” “Political Activity and State Service.” So, in Book IV., or the “Economic Aspect,” the author treats of “Spheres of Economic Activity,” “Riches and Poverty,” and “Migration.” Throughout, Mr. Cohen shows that he is an adept in subordinating his own views. Apparently, he holds no brief for anvbody. He lets the facts speak for themselves in their logical order for, with a shrewd appraisement of the situation, he realizes that they can only point in one direction and to him to whom that direction is not patent from the mere statement of the facts it would be useless to shriek from the housetops— and incidently spoil a book of well-conceived purposes.

Books V. and VI. deal exhaustively with “Jewish Culture,” “Contributions to General Culture and Progress,” etc., and “Observance, Drift and Apostasy” and the religious aspect generally.

Of especial interest to Zionists is Book VII. with its suggestive chapters on "Assimilation or Conservation." The whole work culminates in the chapter on "Zionism," as might naturally be expected. On the whole,

*Books reviewed in this department are obtainable through the "Maccabaean."

the author without allowing himself to become a special pleader, manages, by the sheer weight of the facts which are forced upon the consciousness of the reader, to build up a powerful exposition of Zionism and the indispensable requisite of Jewish continuity and progress. Zionists will do well to include "Jewish Life in Modern Times," in their library of Jewish literature.

Published by Dodd, Mead and Company, New York City, with twelve handsome illustrations and a map of the density of Jewish population in the world; 380 pages. Price, $3.00.

THE CONQUERING JEWBy JOHN FOSTER FRASER

Mr. Fraser’s title is rather misleading inasmuch as he confidently expects the “Conquering Jew” to be absorbed by the real conquerors, the non-Jews. Nevertheless, Mr. Fraser has written an interesting book, but it must be said that this is due to his material rather than to any special presentation of his matter. The Jews are an interesting people to say the least, and one can hardly be dull about them. At the same time, it is a very difficult matter to understand them— especially for a non-Jew—and it can hardly be said that Mr. Fraser has possessed himself of this indispensable prerequisite. He does indeed pile up great columns of facts and statistics of Jewish achievements, like the author of that other much overrated book, “Israel Among the Nations,” but, as in the latter’s case, they point in all directions and, lacking in any logical premise, begin somehow to tumble about the ears of the reader without enlightening him and yet, apparently, without disconcerting the author in the least. To what end does he pile up all these facts? It is a mystery. Nobody knows. For, despite the friendly tone of the book, its author begins as an anti-Semite and ends as one.

For an alien to write about the Jewish people at all —about any people in fact—it is necessary to approach the subject with at least the misgivings and humility of a Lacfadio Hearn. Mr, Fraser, however, does not seem to doubt his qualifications for the task in the least. He writes with the ingrained conviction of the Christian to whom the continued existence of the Jewish race is sensed as compromising to Christianity or at least to the Christian races whose office it is to supplant the Jews in the favor of God. Mr. Fraser tries to do justice to Jewish achievement in the world. But he believes that the best achievement of the Jewish race would be to pour its vitality into the non-Jewish melting-pot. This, by the way, is a view that is distinctively Occidental. To the Oriental, with his profound acceptance of the ways of God, the existence of other races is as natural as that of the variegated hues of the sky. Not so the newer races. Whatever the barbarian cannot comprehend or absorb he would smash into smithereens with the heavy mace of his ignorant appetite. It is a characteristic of an immature. over-eaeer tvve of mind.

Mr. Fraser predicts the early demise of the Jewish people. Of Zionism he seems to know nothing. He was in Palestine but apparently got no glimpse of the Zionist colonies but contented himself with a glance at the dung-hills of Jerusalem like so many other ingenuous travellers in the Orient.

Published by Funk & Wagnalls Co. Price, $1.50 net, cloth bound.