THE MACCABAEAN
DEVOTED TO ZIONISM AND ALL JEWISH INTERESTS
ESTABLISHED OCTOBER, 1901
VOLUME XXVII
Published monthly for the Federation of American Zionists by "The Maccabaean Magazine," 44 East 23rd Street, New York Entered at New York Post Office as Second Class Matter. Subscriptions for one year $1.00. All foreign countries, including Canada, $1.25. Single copies, ten cents. Subscribers are advised to notify us at once of any change of address.
C O N T E N T S
EDITORIAL
THE WAY CLEARED FOR PEACE.
The American Jewish Committee has cleared the path for the Congress movement by abandoning its conference which was to have been held on October 24th. It thus confesses that it is powerless to interfere with the progress of the movement for democratic organization in Jewish life. It confesses not only its lack of power and influence, but by abandoning its conference it admits that the argument advanced against secrecy in Jewish affairs, and autocracy in Jewish organization, could not successfully be controverted. Its defeat means an end to the controversy between an open Congress and a secret Conference. There is now only one constructive program in American Jewish life which has relevancy to the problems that confront us. It is the program of having a representative assembly assume responsibility for Jewish affairs in this country. That program is embodied in the Congress for which the people are to be made responsible, and which they will control.
At this time, only one thought is in our minds: How best to develop the Congress idea, and to bring into the movement all classes, sections and parties in American Jewry. But we cannot refrain from pointing out that the education of the American Jewish people has proceeded so far, that they have made it impossible forever for a small group of men, no matter how sagacious and influential, to assume the entire responsibility for, and the control of Jewish affairs. This is a victory of sound Jewish public opinion, hitherto smothered and inarticulate. For it was the power of public opinion, not the influence of one man or party, that made it impossible for the American Jewish Committee to overawe the Jewish people and dissuade them from doing what they considered the best thing possible for them to do. Public opinion, as expressed in Jewish newspapers, organizations, and in mass-meetines overwhelmed the arroeance of indi-
viduals and paralyzed every effort to impose their wills upon the Jewish people.
This is a gratifying development of American Jewish life. It makes for a broadened responsibility. It makes for more intelligent action. It brings into Jewish life the healthy note of struggle and controversy which was bound to result in more intelligent action. There was a time when discussion of important Jewish issues was impossible. A silent mood enwrapped all Jewish enterprise. But the controversy that raged about the Congress-Conference agitation was a frank discussion instead of the secret manipulation of issues and conventional apologetics. Good comes from the airing of grievances, from frankness, and from a bold tackling of Jewish issues.
We now pass to a new chapter. In that chapter there will be controversy and differences of opinion, but, let us hope, they will be centered on questions of method, issues of organization, varying ideas of education, etc. The work of organizing the Congress involves many difficulties, and we shall need the wisdom of all classes and elements. Let no one withhold his counsel, and regard himself as too superior or too wise to enter into the deliberations of the Jewish people.
PEACE WITH THE WORKMEN'S COMMITTEE.
Following the withdrawal of the American Jewish Committee and the abandonment of its Conference, the National Workmen's Committee and the Jewish Congress Organization Committee, after a number of conferences have arrived, according to the latest reports, at a clear understanding. The resolution of the Workmen's Convention has been accepted by the Congress Organization Committee as a basis for the calling of a conference of national Jewish organizations which is to call the Congress. This acceptance is the best indication of the willingness of the Congress ad-