The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVII, No. 4 · October 1915
90printed page
scan 1 of 26
Facsimile · scan 1 of 26
Scan of p. 90
Text · transcribed from the scan

inability to find a market for their goods, and without the capital to enable them to store their products, they are on the verge of bankruptcy. These colonists are different from the rest of the Jewish population. They have property which remains valuable, in spite of their inability to work the land for one or more seasons. If Palestine were free, and loans could be raised through regular banking facilities, the colonists might have mortgaged their property and tied themselves over the bad seasons. But there are no adequate banking facilities, mortgaging of land is not possible in Palestine, and unless help comes to them from without, they are bound for destruction. This situation should arouse the Zionists and the Jews of America. Jewish Palestine can be saved for the better times coming after the war, if the Jews of America could be made to realize that in Palestine they have an opportunity actually to save a whole section of Jewry, which is not the case elsewhere. Here are a job that is waiting for thorough workmen. We have thrown into Palestine last year about a quarter of a million dollars. This year if we give Palestine half a million, we are almost positive that it will be saved for the better time coming. They rely upon us. Will American Jewry respond?

DEPUTY FRIEDMAN'S ADDRESS

The speech of Deputy Friedman delivered in the Duma, given elsewhere in this issue, indicates, in some measure, the policy the Jews of Russia have adopted toward their own problem. It is quite clear that the Jews of Russia are committed to the war, which is regarded by them as involving the Russian people whose destiny is complicated with their own; but in common with other Russian citizens, the Jews feel that their interests demand a clear setting forth of the iniquities of the Russian government, providing such an indictment does not have a direct bearing upon the war. The government, when attacked, must be attacked on the basis of its incompetence, but not as the party engaged in a war with Germany. Deputy Friedman thus sets forth the unfair, the cruel, the indefensible acts of the government, and asks for redress. He does not mince words, but comes out with astounding boldness giving facts and figures. The position is this: Here are citizens giving their lives for the Russian cause. They are bound in destiny to the Russian people. And while shedding their blood for the “fatherland” the Russian government treats them as aliens. He points out the gross injustice, to say the least, of the incident of an apothecary's assistant, wounded in the war, being refused the right to remain in Petrograd for treatment, and only after special intervention obtaining permission to remain only two months. About half a million Jews were forcibly expelled from Poland and brought down to the verge of beggary. The Jews of Kovno were offered permission to return to their homes provided they gave hostages. Hostages demanded from citizens whose sons were fighting Russia’s battles! With boldness unparalleled, Mr. Friedman said, “We know the root of the evil, it lies there!” pointing to the ministerial benches. American Jews may speak with bated breath of the dangers to which our people may be subjected to, should we speak one word against the Russian government at this time; but when in Russia a Jew speaks so frankly, surely the time has come for us to be equally as bold, and not to hesitate to speak of the extra-brutal policy of the Russian government.

distinguishing clearly between the government and the Russian people, and with no intent to commit a breach of neutrality. The fact that Russia is now at war should not give it immunity from being brought to the bar of international justice with regard to its treatment of its Jewish subjects.

THE DANGERS OF FREE SPEECH FOR JEWS

An argument used against the Congress is that free speech on the Congress floor would be dangerous to Jewish interests. This argument is persistent. It is based upon an idea which has been repeated for a generation and has become a habit with many, who have given up going behind the idea to see whether there is any validity to it. Suppose a delegate to the Congress rises, securing the floor upon some pretense or in a regular discussion, and in the course of his remarks attacks, say, the Russian government. Would this be dangerous? Would the Russian government consider the remarks of an individual as indicative of the attitude of the Congress? Have not thousands of Jews given utterance to such remarks already? Are they not doing so every day? Has not Mr. Schiff gone further than speaking against Russia, and made it known that he refuses to participate in a loan to the Allies should Russia be included? Evidently he thinks there is no danger in his policy. Those. who helped to abrogate the treaty with Russia thought there was no danger in open hostility to the Russian government. Should a man at a Congress declaim against Russia, and imitating Deputy Friedman, point out the atrocities committed by the government, would the Congress, or the Jewish people, be bound by what he says? Would not the Congress be judged by its resolutions, and not by the chance remarks of a delegate? Furthermore,there are democratic parliamentary rules which can be invoked, and would have to be employed to regulate the debates. Off hand it may be said that a great deal of the so-called dangerous discussion could be relegated to the committee rooms, where these committees could hear argument for or against a proposition, and in their report to the Congress, the arguments made before it could be presented in printed form. Thus, the sting and heat of any point that may be made would be removed. In short, the dangers of free speech, taking an extreme view of what may happen, would not outweigh the benefit to be derived from a frank discussion of Jewish affairs. \We should be able to distingush between words and action. And we have no doubt that the Congress can be surrounded by such solemn and dignified ceremonies, and the delegates impressed with their grave responsibility, that even the dangers feared would be reduced to a minimum, and we would have instead well-arranged, carefully conducted discussions that would be a credit to our people.

THE ORGANIZATION OF THE CONGRESS

The conference called by Mr. Kraus was, in onr opinion, one step in the direction of organizing the Congress, although he may not admit that fact. We regard every attempt to impress upon American Jews the necessity for organization in order to cope with the grave situation in Jewish affairs that has arisen, as an essential to the organization of the Congress. The Congress is not an end in itself, as Mr. Brandeis says, but a means, and there are a number of other auxiliary means that must be employed if the Jews are to be oroeanized to meet the situation. We must