The Jewish Voice in the Duma
Deputy Freedman's Stiring Appeal
N THE course of the recent general debates in the Duma the Jewish position in Russia was referred to by various speakers. The discussion on Jews was initiated chiefly by the remarks of the Premier, M. Goremykin, who announced that it was the intention of the Government to give autonomy to the Poles who have displayed their loyalty to the Russian cause. By mentioning the devotion of the Poles, the Premier continued, he did not mean that other nationalities had been otherwise than loval.
M. Markoff, the well-known anti-Semite, who was the first to broach the subject of Jews, declared that the wholesale expulsion of Jews from the war zones was justified, and the Government ought to take further precautions to isolate the Jews so that they might not influence the rest of the population with those evils for which they had been exiled from the war zones.
M. Miliukoff, leader of the Cadet party, said that everything that had been suffered by the people paled before that suffered by the Jews. That unfortunate people, which at the beginning of the war was inspired by the general patriotic enthusiasm, had now become the object of systematic perseeution. . . . At a time when nations were struggling for the freedom and rights of small nationalities such terrible deeds were a crying dissonance which embittered friends and evoked joy among enemies. (Loud applause from the Left.) That day such actions had been virtually oflicially condemned, for it was announced that all subjects without distinction or race or religion would receive better treatment.
M. Markoff: "Loyal subjects only."
M. Miliukoff: "Russian subjects are all loyal. Nobody has a right to doubt the loyalty and devotion of Russian subjects." (Applause.)
M. A. Kerensky said: "After a year's war we see before us the Jews crucified through hatred and slanders. I proclaim from this tribune that I personally went to investigate the accusations alleged against the Jews of Kuza, that they had committed treachery against the Russian army. I must reiterate that it is a mean slander and that such a thing could not, because of local conditions, have happened there."
M. Tchechidze said: "The most honored communal leaders are taken from the Jews as hostages, and I ask you, has such super-cynical action ever been committed by a State as to take hostages from its own subjects? I affirm that it is unprecedented in history. (Interruption from the Right: "Spies.") Before speaking about other spies do not forget your own Myassidoff. (Interruption: "He was hanged.") There are many still left. Before our army had time to establish itself in Galicia, Russian methods were introduced. When Galician Jews asked what would be their lot under Russian rule, the cynical reply was: 'If you are loyal you shall have the same "rights" as the Russian Jew.'"
M. Freedman, the Jewish deputy, spoke as follows: “Notwithstanding the difficulty of their position, in spite of their being deprived of rights, the Jews have risen high in performing their duties as citizens, and have in the past ear of war played a remarkahle part. In nothing have they Beh behind with the rest of the population. They mobilized all their available manhood, with the only difference that, unlike the others, they sent also their only sons to the front. A considerable number of Jewish volunteers were recorded in the papers at the beginning of the war. They were volunteers that were entitled by their educational acomplishments to the rank of officer; they knew that being Jews they would not attain that rank, and none the less they went to the war. The Jewish youth who, owing to the educational restrictions, had to go to strange lands for their education, returned to their native country on the declaration of war, or joined the allied forces. The number of Russo-Jewish students that died in defense of Liege and other places on the western front was indeed not small. In Turkey the Zionist youth were, when Turkey joined our enemies, in a dilemma whether they should embrace Turkish citizenship or be expelled from Palestine. They chose the latter, and, as Russians, joined the British army in Egypt. The Jews have built hospitals, have materially contributed beyond their powers, and they have shared in every undertaking with their fellow-citizens. Numerous Jews have also distinguished themselves in the war. I have a letter before me by a Jew who emigrated to the States. ‘I risked my life.’ he writes, “in my journey to Archangel. I did it because I loved my
