The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVII, No. 3 · September 1915
26scan
of 26

THE MACCABEAN

DEVOTED TO ZIONISM AND ALL JEWISH INTERESTS Devoted to Zionism and All Jewish Interests Established October, 1901 Volume XXVII October, 1915 No. 4

Published monthly for the Federation of American Zionists by "The Maccabean Magazine," 44 East 23rd Street, New York Entered at New York Post Office as Second Class Matter. Subscriptions for one year $1.00. All foreign countries, including Canada, $1.25. Single copies, ten cents. Subscribers are advised to notify us at once of any change of address.

C O N T E N T S

EDITORIALS89
POLAND AND THE JEWS, By Nahum Sokolow94
I. O. B. B.'s ATTEMPT TO SECURE UNITY OF ACTION; THE EMERGENCY FUND; DEPUTY FRIEDMAN'S ADDRESS; THE DANGERS OF FREE SPEECH FOR JEWS; THE ORGANIZATION OF THE CONGRESS; THE BALKAN STATES; THE RUSSIAN ATROCITISTS91
JUDAECUS (A STORY of Roman Times) By Hyman Segal102
EIGHT MONTHS OF COSSACK RULE IN GALICIA, By James Fuchs92
JEWISH UNITY AND THE CONGRESS, By Louis D. Brandeis105
A LULLABY IN JERUSALEM, By Jessie E. Sampter107
THE JEWS IN THE WAR109
THE ZIONIST MOVEMENT110
WHERE AND WHOM TO JOIN112

E D I T O R I A L

THE I. O. B. B.'S ATTEMPT TO SECURE UNITY OF ACTION

Mr. Adolph Kraus, president of the I. O. B. B., seeing that an issue had arisen between the advocates of the Jewish Congress and those who opposed the consideration of the Jewish problem by a democratic assembly, intervened as a peacemaker and sought to bring about an agreement as to the policy to be adopted. His obect was to act as the mediator and probably to throw the weight of his influence in the direction leading to peace. 'T’he meeting of October 3rd at Hotel Astor resulted in no definite conclusion, which was not his fault. The advocates of the Congress presented their arguments in favor of the democratic organization of the Jews of America, and representatives of the opposition stated their case against it. The official report gives nothing of what was said at the conference, but drawing our conclusions from the unauthorized reports that have appeared in the Yiddish press, it appears that while Mr. Brandeis, speaking for the Congress, confined himself wholly to the presentation of his case, discussing the matter calmly and in a friendly spirit, the leaders of the opposition availed themselves of collateral arguments that have no bearing upon the issue, and indulged in intemperate remarks that had the opposte effect from that expected. Mr. Kraus maintained a neutral attitude. The position taken by the Congress party was throughout consistent and conciliatory. Mr. Brandeis repeated the arguments that have been made quite frequently in the public discussion. The Congress movement depends upon discussion and friendly interchange of ideas. The essential feature of the organization of the Congress is that there shall be free and frank discussion, and the more discussion, the wiser the decisions finally to be made. FEvidently, what some

of the American Jewish Committee have been claiming for their private committee, that it is as representative as it could possibly be, and that it is desirous of democratizing itself, is merely a pious wish, and not a matter for which sacrifices should be made. If these men of the American Jewish Committee truly desired the democratization of its status, they would have welcomed the Congress movement, and used it to attain the desired goal. But on every occasion where the issue implicates democracy, these men are found opposing anything that smacks of popular control and representation. One is almost forced to conclude that they do not mean what they say. For example, it is rumored that Mr. Marshal claims that he was the author of a plan for the democratization of the American Jewish Committee, yet he abandoned his plan some time ago and persisted in assuming the role of the prosecuting attorney of Jewish democracy.

THE EMERGENCY FUND

The receipt of a cablegram from Mr. Gluskin, now in Alexandria, stating that the Palestine colonies are on the verge of utter ruin, may be accepted as the unvarnished and exact truth. Palestine is isolated, which means that little or nothing is being brought into the land, and that little or nothing can be shipped out of it. The first to be affected by this isolation were those who depended upon the gifts of brethren living in Europe and America. Next came those who lived upon commercial activity, and last, and most important to us, come the colonists, the creators of wealth, who are now unable to secure for themselves the necessary prerequisites for agricultural work. If they had oil for their machinery, they could have grown their oranges and grapes and almonds, but without the power to irrigate their land, coupled with