The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVII, No. 3 · September 1915
79printed page
scan 14 of 26
THE MACCABAEAN FOR SEPTEMBER
79

A Course in Zionism.

(Outline used by the Hadassah Group of the Zionist Training School, and other groups. Address all communications to Miss Jessie E. Sampter, 31 West 110th St., New York City.)

NON-NATIONAL ORIGINS OF CHRISTIANITY.

A. Conditions preceding the spread of Christianity. 1. Social, moral and religious disorganization in Roman Empire. 2. Longing for personal salvation. 3. Messianic hope. B. Teachings of Jesus. 1. Differed from Jewish teachings only in being: a. Anti-or non-national. b. Addressed to the weak individual for his personal salvation. 2. Jesus a social worker without the vision of national salvation possessed by the prophets. C. Teachings of Paul. 1. His sudden conversion. 2. Apostle to the Gentiles; consequent modifications of Jewish religion. a. Abrogation of Law. (Law is national.) b. New character of Messianic idea, the Messiah a personal savior after death. c. Pagan and pre-Jewish elements in Christianity, immaculate conception, atonement, etc. d. Pure individualism in salvation; faith, not works, to be the means of salvation. D. Jewish Nationalism. 1. The three parties: a. Essenes b. Sadducees c. Pharisees 2. Conflicting tendencies work for national ends. Pharisees final preservers of Jewish nationality. Their intellectual aristocracy. 3. The Law (which includes social and political law), the backbone of Jewish national life. School at Yabneh. Living and dying for the Torah. The synod and its liberal law for others, but strictness with itself. Rabbi Akiba and Bar Kochba. The Mishnah and its relation to the Bible and Talmud. The developing Law. E. Essential ethical differences between Judaism and Christianity. 1. Judaism, national, social, as well as personal, covers all of life's activities. Christianity only one aspect of life, the "spiritual", because it did not grow organically. 2. Judaism accentuates oneness of life, of body and soul. Christianity, dualism of body and soul, God and devil, matter and spirit. 3. Judaism, emphasis on this life. Christianity, on other world. 4. Judaism teaches essential purity of life. Christianity teaches original sin. 5. Judaism calls for direct communion with God. Christianity gives Christ as an intermediary and interceder. 6. Judaism preaches social and national salvation. Christianity preaches personal salvation. 7. Judaism emphasizes justice. Christianity emphasizes charity and submission. 8. Judaism encourages family and national development. Christianity preaches self-development, celibacy, weakening of family ties. 9. Judaism demands deeds. Christianity demands faith. 10. Judaism has as ideal of perfection the invisible God. Christianity has the ideal of a perfect man: a limited because past personality. 11. The Jewish hero is the prophet. The Christian hero is the saint. 12. Jewish ethical ideal practical for the individual and the

nation. Christian ethical ideal impractical for the individual and incapable of national application. Love of enemies, turning other cheek, ideal of poverty, etc.

Bibliography

History of the Jews, Graetz, vol. II. pp. 141 to 232.

The Toleration of the Jews under Julius Caesar and Augustus, Dora Askowith, Block Publishing Co.

History of the Jews in the Time of Jesus Christ, Schurer. (For advanced students only.)

Ethics of Judaism, M. Lazarus. (Jewish Publ. Society.)

The New Testament, Gospels and St. Paul.
The Synagogue and the Church, Paul Goodman.

Suggestions for Discussion.

In so short a study as our present one, we have to emphasize the high lights in national development at the expense of much else that is important. \We skip from Ezra to the origin of Christianity. Yet the four hundred and fifty years intervening were rich in national experience and development and crystallization of national will. The Maccabacan period with its dramatic victory.of the weak over the strong, of right over might, and its assertion of national ideals in the face of tempting splendor of culture, and in the face of corruption within and without, has become through Hanukah the symbol of Jewish nationalism. But we are concerned here not with dramatic episodes but with their underlying causes. Perhaps the most signficant fact in the whole Maccabaean complex is that our festival of Hanukah celebrates not victorious battles, but the rededication of the temple. The significance of this folk-expression lies in its emphasis on the spiritual and relieious character of Jewish nationalism.

We emphasize here the origins of Christianity and the essential differences in national and social concepts of the Jewish and Christian point of view, not only because these arose at the crucial moment of the dispersion of the Jewish nation, but also because to us, living among the Christian nations, this contrast brings an added national self-consciousness and an understanding of our peculiar national gifts.

A. ı. The historic need within the Roman Empire for some such spiritual solution as Christianity was so urgent that we must look upon Jesus as the accidental, timely symbol of an inevitable happening. Roman religion had degen-: erated into corrupt politics, national ideals died away before a cosmopolitanism and imperialism that left the individual without any national allegiance: decadent, dissolute morals drove the righteous man from all social hope into the quietism of his own soul. Such intensely personal solutions as Epicureanism and Stoicism spread rapidliy in the Roman world. But they were so purely personal that they lacked the organizing force which is necessary for the institutional permanence of any idea. Judaism also spread. There were many Roman converts. But national and social Judaism, the life and faith of the Jewish people, was bound to be transformed by these tortured souls hunting for individual salvation.

2. At the time of the preaching of Paul, social dissolution was widespread. The ship of state was wrecked, the time to save the ship was past. Therefore, now the cry went up: "Save himself who can!" It was no longer possible, apparently, to save society. Therefore, each individual soul must save itself by intensive purity.

3. The Jewish idea of the Messiah as a man who, with God's help, would restore the Jewish nation, was gradually transformed into the hope for a miraculous Messiah who would come to save the individual soul from among the debris of humanity.

wi BETWEBSEBEREN 7,D B. The person of Jesus symbolizes these Messianic loneings in his life and in his teachings. Jesus preaches the personal morality of Juda'sm.

Many of his most quoted sayings, claimed as distinctively Christian, are exact quotations from the Bible or

(Continued on page 88).