The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVII, No. 3 · September 1915
75printed page
scan 10 of 26
THE MACCABAEAN FOR SEPTEMBER
75

far more cogent than these negative reasons. Zionism is not merely a balm for wounds nor even merely a cure. It is an enhancement of life, a promise of achievement. To the world, the Jewish race is a race worth preserving and the Jewish national ideal is a noble and valuable ideal.

The strength and quality of the Jewish race are proved by three facts: its endurance and increase through centuries of oppression and persecution, its large number of individuals of high achievement in all departments of life in spite of numberless obstacles and handicaps; and, lastly, the high standard of social morality in its communities. No signs of race deterioration have appeared. Although degradation and suffering often reflect on the individual's physical and moral development, the fine race quality persists in his children.

It is hard to evaluate the national ideal of a people without a land and without a state. The prophetic or missionary character of the Jewish people, implied by the word “chosen’” has been recognized in all ages, but “ has been variously interpreted. To the Christian this quality culminated in Christ, who gave to the Christian world the divine inheritance cut off from a sinful Israel. To a certain minority sect among the Jews the word “chosen” means a literal and individual superiority of the Jews, whose mission it is, scattered among the nations, to enhance the morality of their Gentile neighbors. Such a view is not only rightfully resented by their quite normal and quite moral Gentile neighbors, but it is disgusting to the modest and sensible Jew himself. The Jews claim no individual superiority. Nor do the exhortations of Moses and the later prophets point to the fact that as a mass of individuals they could ever all claim such surpassing virtue. It is true that Jesus transmitted to the Gentile world the Jewish code of personal morals. This has now been thoroughly assimilated by the Christian world. Nor have the Jews anything to gain or give by a claim to priority and a dowager’s testy demand for gratitude.

To the traditional Jew the meaning of “chosen” is quite different. It was the nation that was chosen for a national task; not the individual Jew. To justify this choice, the nation must suffer and labor and be severely punished and be lashed into obedience. God manifests his justice through human history, the history of nations. National, international, morality is the peculiar and still untried and unfulfilled ideal of Jewish teaching. All the nations shall walk in the way of the Lord. The Jewish people is a chosen people—not a chosen mass of individuals. Palestine is a holy land: that means the land where the Jewish people is to work out its destiny. Imperalism is precluded. One land for one people. If the Jewish people, chosen for this task of national regeneration, proves itself unworthy, it is to forfeit the land. Unless you are a righteous people, says the Lord, you cannot keep the land I lend to you on this condition. How different from the principle laid down by European statesmen that necessity knows no law, and that the welfare of the nation is the supreme and only moral criterion of individual action !

The Jews today believe and repeat in their prayers that they were banished from their land because they were unworthy. They also believe and repeat that their exile is a punishment and a discipline, and that they are at last to return to Jerusalem with singing and to Zion withi

everlasting joy. Then will all the nations accept the yoke of the Lord, and walk in his ways.

Such is the poetry, the romance of Jewish ideals. Practically, it expresses itself in laws of social righteousness, and in the ideal of law itself. The Jewish people brought into the world the ideal of democracy, both international and intra-national. Democracy is a purely religious ideal, based on the fatherhood of God and upon faith in the equality of man —an equality of what may be called primal soul-dignity —the relation of each to God and therefore to ultimate justice. For in what other way are men equal? The acceptance of the ideal of democracy is a matter of faith, for it cannot be based on expediency, since undemocratic states are often more efficient than democratic ones. And so far democracy has never been fully tried. In Jewish life, it expresses itself in the ideal of impersonal law, which precludes the necessity for an arbitrary human ruler. One of these laws demands gen eral education —"And thou shalt teach them diligently to thy children" —others, also essential to democracy, dictate the conditions of land-ownership or lease; restrict by protective laws the ancient and formerly accepted in stitution of slavery; safeguard the equal rights of all be fore the law; make equal provision for the support of all members of the community.

But it is not so much the individual laws that express this democratic spirit as the two facts that the law was given to the whole people, and that at all times, while there was a commonwealth or social unity, the law could be interpreted and developed to meet the changing needs of the people. As a theory of individual morality, democracy was passed on to Christianity, which is a personal religion. As a theory of national and international morality it is still untried ; it is the ideal to be worked out by the Jewish people in the Jewish nation. Scattered individuals cannot fulfil a national ideal. And it is an ideal so noble that its advocates ought at least to be given a chance to fulfl it.

Palestine in Jewish Thought.

By the mass of the Jews these Biblical ideals have never been intellectualized. They are transmuted into habit and emotion, character of the people, the habits of democratic organization and lawfulness, and the religious ideal of Palestine. This passion for the holy land, an inarticulate unreasoning passion, has expressed itself so far in pilgrimages and in individualistic migrations. Many causes have combined, until recently, to prevent a national movement. In any such movement the love of the Jewish people for Palestine, and its place in their religion and history, would make it the only spot on earth that could draw to itself the masses of the Jewish people.

Zionism Expressive of Jewish People.

The Zionist movement, which was officially and politically organized in 1897, might be called the articulate and self-conscious agent of the Jewish people. This gives it its representative character although its organized membership still forms a minority among the Jews. The Zionist Congress, with its many delegates from every civilized country, is the Jewish congress. For inertia cannot be represented and constitutes no opposition by its failure to be represented. The opposition amone Tews, while it un-