The Maccabaean · Vol. XXVII, No. 2 · August 1915
53printed page
scan 8 of 22
Facsimile · scan 8 of 22
Scan of p. 53
Text · transcribed from the scan

Zionists, but I have not a doubt that in this audience there are men and women who are not yet Zionists, but who ought to be, and in the few minutes allotted to me I shall say a word or two to them—nothing that will be new to you Zionists, something, perhaps, that may help them in finding the way, in following the bright path along which I have so recently been led.

‘‚There is always a lurking fear among the non-Zionists that there is something incompatible between Zionism and patriotic Americanism. We Americans are citizens of a state to which, as citizens, native-born, not naturalized, we owe our fealty to the last drop of our blood. For we Jews are not citizens of a Jewish state, although some of us may change and become that in the future. We Jews are part of a people—a people bound together for thousands of years by a common tradition and a common inheritance, a feeling of belonging togetherness. That becomes evident whenever any calamity happens to the Jews in any part of the world; that ought to become evident to every thinking man and woman without calamities if he but reflects on the history of the Jews. And so as every man owes loyalty and belongs to his family, to his circle of friends, —yea, as every American owes loyalty to his commonwealth as well as to his nation, and there is no incompatibility between any of these loyalties, so we Jews owe loyalty to our people, our nation, our nationality: and at the same time we Americans owe the fealty of patriotic citizenship to our state, our country. More than this, a man while he can be a citizen of but one state, can belong in feeling to more than one people. A man may be not only a Jew, but he may be in the sense of belonging to the nation by tradition, by a common culture, by a common language, in some respects a Frenchman, a German, an Englishman. There is no incompatibility in that double nationality, although, of course, only one can be predominant, and in the true Jew who has the Jewish nationality, that must predominate, because that is stronger through his veins. And so I say to you who hesitate on this point—and I speak advisedly when I say that there are many who hesitate in fear of their patriotism prejudiced or doubted—throw away your childish fears. You will become better citizens, nobler sons of your country when you look back to your history of thousands of years and proclaim yourselves earnestly and to the fullest extent one of vour own veonle.

“There is a great Jewish problem throughout the world. We in America realize in our own lives but little of it. Our brethren in Western Europe feel it more, and those in Eastern Europe feel it like a dagger in their breast every day of their life. Zionism may solve this problem. But I do not care whether it solves the problem of the Jew in Russia and Roumania or elsewhere, or not. I am for Zionism as a practical ideal for the Jews of all the world, because it is right that every nation, every people should have a central rally place for the people of its own culture throughout the world, in all the countries, and through all the ages may make individual capacity help along in the world’s great movements. But not only the individual should contribute his individual share to the progress of the world. Every nation, every people, big or small, has a mission on earth to develop itself, not merely for the benefit of itself and its members, but for the benefit of all mankind, and we Jews as a people have made our contribution to the world in the days of old when we were not merely a people and a nation, but a nation and a people in a great state, great in its forces, great in its power for good, great in its contributions to humanity, even though small in territory and in population. And to-day, when all Europe is at war, not because each nation is endeavoring to benefit all mankind by giving the best that is within him, but because one or the other or many of them are attempting to impose their nationality upon others, big and small; because one or the other of them’ is attempting to throttle the small nations of the world and to prevent them from enjoying the natural rights not merely of men, but of people, to develop themselves; in these days, I say, when all Europe is at war because of the attempt at national dominance, it is time for the Jews to proclaim the true mission of the nation, big and small, not to dominate, not to attempt to thrust down the throats of others our peculiar culture, our big peculiar ideas, our big peculiar contributions.